Who would you rather have at your club? eddie paea or mitchell pearce...

[Rovelli]

Easy in hindsight, but Pearce showed much more in first-grade last season.

And I'm a Kiwi. So is Paea.

 

[byrne_rovelli_fan82]

Neither. Haven't proved enough.

 

[Sood]

lol. i wonder how long till a souths fan starts a sandow v pearce thread. :lol:

 

[Tommy Smith]

I'm a roosters fan, yet i still see more in Paea than i do in Pearce.

Pearce just doesn't seem to cut it for me and wont be able to play on reputation for much longer.

there both young though so anything could happen.

Hang your head in shame.

 

[Tommy Smith]

They both can't tackle for crap but I chose Paea as he has more potential in him and will probably play senior rep footy. Just needs more expiernce in first grade.

But watching him for Norths he played well last season.

:lol: This thread is GOLD.

Pearce is a fantastic defender. Arguably the best defensive half in the NRL. I believe he is equal first in the competition for 1-on-1 tackles.

Some people have no idea.

 

[Bman26]

Lol@souffs?

 

[Jono078]

I'm suprised the poll was so close really.

 

[Sood]

I'm suprised the poll was so close really.

Paea was actually leading this poll for a long time 2.

I dont think we got too many talent scouts on this forum. :lol:

 

[BeeeeeRad]

Neither. Haven't proved enough.

Nearly all teams would love to have Pearce on their team. He has shown plenty of talent already, one of the best defenders for his size always puts in the effort and is about to play a State of Origin. All signs are good and that he will be a great player and most teams would love a half like him for example the Warriors.

 

[j0nesy]

Mitchell Pearce hands down.

 

[Big Mick]

Pfft...Wade Graham will sh!t on both of them.

 

[-Dr.J-]

Mitchell Pearce really owned last night


Dominant performance


He was playing eh..??

 

[Billigan]

eddie paea

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

Eddie Paea sh*ts on Mitchell Pearce

Have you seen Paea play???

He is still young. But he masterminded the junior kiwi's ownership of the junior roo's. Impressive stuff

Eddie Paea has just been called into the Kiwis..... that would make him better....

Confidence that is horribly misguided. Pearce is rubbish.

Paea by far .

I saw Paea last night,he comes in to my work alot,came in with his family.

Paea --> Pearce

Wade Graham --> Both

I'm a roosters fan, yet i still see more in Paea than i do in Pearce.

Pearce just doesn't seem to cut it for me and wont be able to play on reputation for much longer.

there both young though so anything could happen.

They both can't tackle for crap but I chose Paea as he has more potential in him and will probably play senior rep footy. Just needs more expiernce in first grade.

But watching him for Norths he played well last season.

eddie paea

id take pearce nearly becuase paea is from the rabbitohs. whens the last time a rabbitohs junior hailed as 'the next big thing' actually ended up producing for more then one season?

this quote is paul pierce because it's the truth ...

 

[Brownie.Kougari]

After yesterday's game, Eddie Paea any day of the week.

I've never rated Pearce...

 

[ShadesOfTheSun]

Nearly all teams would love to have Pearce on their team. He has shown plenty of talent already, one of the best defenders for his size always puts in the effort and is about to play a State of Origin. All signs are good and that he will be a great player and most teams would love a half like him for example the Warriors.

'Nearly all' is a fairly gross exaggeration. I'd say that over half the teams in the NRL have a prospect at #7 who's either comparable to Pearce or better.

The Cowboys have Thurston, the Titans have Prince and the Storm have Cronk. All of them are fairly young and are far better halves than Pearce.

Brisbane have Wallace, Souths have Sandow, and Newcastle have Mullen and Rogers - players with comparable ability and potential to Pearce. There's no real reason why either club would go through the trouble of chasing Pearce's signature just to exchange one undeveloped potential wold beater for another.

Manly have Orford. They will definitely not be looking to replace him after this season's Dally M and premiership medal.

Cronulla have Barrett. The Warriors (now) have Jones. Neither would want to trade for Pearce.

Which leaves us with the Tigers, the Bulldogs (arguable), the Eels, the Panthers, and the Raiders. Hardly 'nearly all'.

 

[Phillips]

Finch >> Pearce

 

[Mr Saab]

After yesterday's game, Eddie Paea any day of the week.

I've never rated Pearce...

Yeah cause the Scottish are one of the great nations for League.
Wake up to yourself

 

[Chook Norris]

Originally Posted by shiznit
Eddie Paea has just been called into the Kiwis..... that would make him better....

:lol:

 

[Tonearm Terrorwrist]

After yesterday's game, Eddie Paea any day of the week.

I've never rated Pearce...

LOL this is reserve grade eddie paea you're talking about????