For your sake, I hope you don't sign Madge. May as well keep Hasler.
You need someone who gets the club. Not some scientific coach trying to turn the players into robots. One thing about the Bulldogs, is that they were hated by every non-Dogs fan, but equally respected. They played for each other and with passion and when they turned the attack on, they would beat anyone.
Madge doesn't understand that and doesn't know how to coach that. A coach like Toovey, who runs on emotion as much as brains is exactly who the Dogs need in my view.