2018 R19 Fri - Sharks 28-24 Raiders @ SC Group

[skeepe]

What did they f**k up it wasn’t a knock on

There’s no way you can conclusively rule that from the footage.

 

[Miller was a legend]

There’s no way you can conclusively rule that from the footage.

Bullshit

The expert on commentary said he never touched it

What’s his name? Was it Roach?

Very smart guy. Everyone knows it.

Who are you to argue the point with a class act like that guy?

 

[eddiesmith]

So a ball goes 5m forward into the wind and everyone blows up about it being called forward? Wow

Don't worry, tonight wasn't about getting the Sharks up, it was about guaranteeing the Broncos spot in the 8, penalty count will be 15-2 against us next week with 3 players sin binned and the 2 penalties received in the 80th minute when we are down 30-0

 

[Generalzod]

There’s no way you can conclusively rule that from the footage.

It pretty clear that he didn’t touch it

 

[Miller was a legend]

Ok so the footage is in conclusive but the touchy thought it was

Doesnt matter how many times you look at it the ball never deviated or exhibited any sign it was touched. The replays showed no evidence the ball touched Ramien.

The issue is why did the flog of a touch judge put his flag part way up when the player was a metre in the field of play?

That started the confusion.

I’m not sure if the ref called knock on or not, but he didn’t blow the pea out of the whistle to stop play.

Based on the replays it’s a try, but the officials need shooting

 

[BWNB]

We should replay the game on Tuesday night.

 

[gitano]

Hahahahahahaha I'm so so happy. Raiders season is overrrrrr. Get onto the Bali planning Skeepey and Walt. I love love love what happened tonight.

 

[Hutty1986]

Hahahahahahaha I'm so so happy. Raiders season is overrrrrr. Get onto the Bali planning Skeepey and Walt. I love love love what happened tonight.

I wouldnt be too lippy gypsy m8. Cowboys will probably end our season tomorrow night.

 

[gitano]

I wouldnt be too lippy gypsy m8. Cowboys will probably end our season tomorrow night.

Nope. Top 8 is now set Faiders are mathematical

 

[Beavers Headgear]

Why wasn't there this much outrage when we got robbed by a forward pass against the Broncos

Or when the Raiders beat us with the last try coming off a pass that was at least 3m forward

 

[mave]

Or when the Raiders beat us with the last try coming off a pass that was at least 3m forward

Or Melbournes match winning try vs Manly just last weekend.
Nothing to see here, eh Skeepe ?

 

[carcharias]

Poor old raiders
Whinging about
1) a fair try to the sharks where a touch judge briefly raised his flag .
None of the players even saw it.
They didn’t play the whistle.

2) a strip on the bell that probably should’ve been a penalty to the sharks ( before it eventually was one for dissent)

The excuses never stop

 

[Raiderdave]

What did they f**k up it wasn’t a knock on

how would you know
the footage used is from behind the ball carrier & the ball disappears from sight
the touch judge had a clear view & indicated it grazed his arm
that's why it was a no try , there must be evidence to over turn that

there wasn't
it should have stayed a no try

 

[McLovin]

Game thread sponsor - Kleenex

 

[Surely]

I think we can all.agree the refs and touches have been pretty ordinary this season

That's what happens when knobs tinker with rules and rule interpretations all the time.

At its base it's a pretty simple game made complex.

 

[Raiderdave]

It pretty clear that he didn’t touch it

theres nothing clear about it at all
you can't tell from the vision , so guess what , the on field call stays as per NRL rules
but apparently not if idiots are in charge of the VR

 

[Generalzod]

theres nothing clear about it at all
you can't tell from the vision , so guess what , the on field call stays as per NRL rules
but apparently not if idiots are in charge of the VR

The ball wasnt touched if it was it would have changed direction...play to the whistle

 

[sup42]

Hate when refs decide a result with their blundering...last night was the stuff of nightmares....I'm not Raiders fan....that was just chilling.

 

[Raiderdave]

The ball wasnt touched if it was it would have changed direction...play to the whistle

theres no evidence either way
no try was the ruling
that's what it should have stayed

playing the whistle is irrelevant here

 

[TheFrog]

The ball wasnt touched if it was it would have changed direction...play to the whistle

Need a snickometer.