What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Appointing blame

Who will we blame for Widdop this season?

  • The coach

    Votes: 30 69.8%
  • The forwards

    Votes: 3 7.0%
  • The hallfback

    Votes: 5 11.6%
  • Duges can't pass

    Votes: 4 9.3%
  • The hooker can't pass

    Votes: 2 4.7%
  • Benji Marshall

    Votes: 5 11.6%
  • Objective View

    Votes: 6 14.0%
  • Another forum contributor (please specify)

    Votes: 2 4.7%
  • Other (please specify)

    Votes: 6 14.0%

  • Total voters
    43
  • Poll closed .

Rexxy

Coach
Messages
10,609
"Appointing Blame" ??? I think you mean either "appropriating blame" or more logically, "apportioning blame"? On your "poll", yes understand it's a strawman, but the answer is simply Widdop is a talented footballer trying to alter his style by trying to carry out the instructions of a clueless coach.
 
Last edited:

Glenn01

Juniors
Messages
232
"Appointing Blame" ??? I think you mean either "appropriating blame" or more logically, "apportioning blame"? On your "poll", yes understand it's a strawman, but the answer is simply Widdop is a talented footballer trying to alter his style by trying to carry out the instructions of a clueless coach.
Really? Well evidently your command of the English language is superior to my own. I thought "appropriating blame" would mean to take the blame. In some kind of convoluted way I guess it makes sense though I could be wrong. As for "apportioning blame", well that makes perfect sense but it's not the question I was meaning to ask.

You know what, if you say "appointing blame" is incorrect, it must be incorrect but I still don't see how that is so. Tell me if you can, what exactly is Widdop's style?
 
Last edited:

Glenn01

Juniors
Messages
232
So anyway, if Rexxy has finished lecturing me about the English language, this poll is ending shortly. Please get your votes in. No surprise McIdiot is winning. I thought Objective View would be polling higher. I know who the trippy old dude voted for without him even having to tell me. 1. McIdiot, 2. Benji Marshall and 3. the forwards. #3 because JDB does play in the forwards.

On the subject of JDB, I really feel for this guy. Playing with Widdop and under McGregor has really screwed up his career. I believe in a team with a decent coach and playmaker, he would have been recognized long ago as one of the best locks in the competition. If it wasn't for a few injuries Frizz wouldn't have gotten a chance for NSW but once he got it, it really showed how bad the playmakers and coach for STI are.
 

getsmarty

Immortal
Messages
33,485
Gareth Widdop stars as St George Illawarra Dragons smash Penrith Panthers
nathan_ryan.jpg

  • March 4, 2017 6:21pm
  • Nathan Ryan@nath_ryan
  • Source: FOX SPORTS
LET your actions do the talking.

It’s a rugby league cliché but if Gareth Widdop’s actions were words, they’d be something to effect of ‘give me a new contract’.

Almost four years ago Widdop signed a lucrative deal with St George Illawarra worth close to $650,000 a season or $2.5 million.

Now off-contract and with an uncertain future after the club shelled out $1 million plus a season for Ben Hunt in 2018, the 27-year-old has wasted little time pushing his case.

The five-eighth was brilliant in Saturday’s 42-10 win over Penrith, scoring two tries and setting up another.

While The Panthers’ attack looked disjointed for the bulk of the game, the red V were flying.

1f0aac9cdd85afb0c89f902d93bb6943
The Dragons celebrate with Jack de Belin after he scored a try.Source: Getty Images

The Dragons’ new recruits wasted little time showing their worth with Paul Vaughan making some determined runs, Cameron McInnes scheming around the ruck and Nene Macdonald producing some huge defensive efforts.

The Dragons kicked their season off with McInnes delivering a short ball to Joel Thompson who barged over the top of Matt Moylan and Bryce Cartwright for the first try.

From there Gareth Widdop lifted his side.

After securing repeat set with a perfectly weighted kick, Widdop put a short pass between Cartwright and Te Maire Martin minutes later for Thompson to cross for his second.

Shortly after Martin made up for the defensive lapse when he engaged the line and offloads to Waqa Blake on the flank.


611007_640x360_large_20170304174918.jpg

Martin, Blake make magic try

0:38
Blake pulled off a Superman-like dive to ground the ball just inches from the touch line and reduced the margin by eight.

Four minutes from halftime Moses Leota spilt the ball and Jack De Belin made the Panthers pay.

Off an inside ball from McInnes, De Belin pushed past Peter Wallace, Latu and Moylan before lunging for the line and gifted his team an 18-4 lead at the break.

After losing Drew Hutchison to an ACL injury in the pre-season, Josh McCrone won the battle for the no.7 jersey.

Five minutes into the second half and McCrone produced a banana kick in-field with Widdop beating Wallace and Moylan to the ball to score the try.

The Panthers hit back shortly after when Martin produced a perfectly timed tip on to Moylan who lobbed the ball to Tyrone Peachey who scored in the corner.

e37538358ef21a6b2d0fdbe71dfb6909

Jack de Belin of the Dragons breaks the defence.Source: Getty Images
Trailing 24-10, Cleary made a dive for the line but was denied when McCrone’s knee knocked the ball out.

Seconds later the Dragons went the length of the field with Dugan setting up a try for McInnes when he kicked for himself, regathered and shuffled the ball wide.

“Penrith have been really poor,” Fox Sports commentator Brett Kimmorley said of the Panthers.

“Their attitude has stunk.”

Widdop scored his second after Nightingale picked up a stray pass from Martin and popped the ball up for his playmaker to stroll over.

With 10 minutes remaining Widdop gave a short ball to Thompson who broke the Panthers’ line and the backrower secured his hat-trick, the first of his 10-year career.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nrl...s/news-story/1f8a83789c45d76c7d4f40280cf28cdb
 
Top