Every finals match so far ruined!

[OldPanther]

The title needs correcting. Not all. Sharks were robbed.

 

[The_Shield]

Storm first try was of a 5meter forward pass for starters

It came off the Eels player. Fair try. The only try that came from a forward pass was the Radradra one. Eels have nothing to complain about. The only time they looked threatening is when Melbourne were a man down

 

[TheFrog]

Whether it touches his hand or not shouldn't even be brought into consideration.

Lets change the rules in the middle of a game so the team I want to win can win, hey.

 

[This Year?]

Lets change the rules in the middle of a game so the team I want to win can win, hey.

I didn't care who won the game. If you read all my posts in the thread you will see that I only think it is a knock on. No need to get defensive about it. I don't have any agendas.

How would you feel if it was Manly that scored the try in that fashion?

 

[Perth Red]

Flano classic whinge in the post match, I thought he was about to reach for the tissue box! Surprisingly he didn't mention the 50-50 grounding try that went there way lol.

 

[Willie Ray]

I don't know of any other sport where the officials are as conspicuous as they are in RL....but it's what we're stuck with....this week your team gets the calls,next week they get dudded.......
Refereeing consistency is like saying "talented rapper,".... Just doesn't exist.

 

[Raiderdave]

Serious question. If your referring to the JAC try, it was touched by parramatta so fair try. If your referring to the second try with Cronk/Glasby, absolutely nothing wrong with that, Glasby always had the ball not Cronk. If your referring to the penalty for taking out Slater, that's a penalty everyday of the week, the Eels player ran several metres just to put a shot on Slater. There was a forward pass for the Radradra try but in the end it had no bearing on the result.

the first storm try wasn't a try , its not clear if it touched an eels player , but even if it did
it came out of the storm players hands in a forward direction , so it doesn't matter
its not a try

big call
but it was very early so you can't say that cost the eels the game
they overcame this & hit the front
then proceeded to F it up badly in the 2nd half .... that.. is not on the refs

 

[moffla]

Was the best week 1 finals in years

 

[Danny-Boy]

Tyrone Peachey.....nuff said.

 

[Spade]

Was the best week 1 finals in years

Only because all games were thrillers but the refs were shit.

 

[roboshark]

Yep. The NRL will think everything is great

 

[Someguy]

Storm probably the hardest done by of the weekend 2 blantant sin bin offences let go for parra

 

[insert.pause]

League fans are all a bunch of miserable whiny sooks who are only happy when they are complaining. The Sharks were shit, Manly were shit, that's why they lost.

 

[simmo1]

Been some all-time sooking this weekend. 10/10 to all involved.

 

[King hit]

Flano classic whinge in the post match, I thought he was about to reach for the tissue box! Surprisingly he didn't mention the 50-50 grounding try that went there way lol.

Like people always do. They only focus on the stuff that goes against them not the stuff that goes their way.

 

[The_Shield]

the first storm try wasn't a try , its not clear if it touched an eels player , but even if it did
it came out of the storm players hands in a forward direction , so it doesn't matter
its not a try

big call
but it was very early so you can't say that cost the eels the game
they overcame this & hit the front
then proceeded to F it up badly in the 2nd half .... that.. is not on the refs

It did not come out of the hands forward. The way Scott passed the ball there is no way it came out forward. It then hit the Eels player and went up in the air. It's a clear try.

Radradras try was a forward pass, but everyone only seems to care about the JAC try

 

[Danny-Boy]

'Finger of Tyrone'

 

[Rabbits20]

Flano classic whinge in the post match, I thought he was about to reach for the tissue box! Surprisingly he didn't mention the 50-50 grounding try that went there way lol.

Plus Leutele dropped it just outside their own 20 coming out of trouble on tackle 5.

Then Bird scores off the piggyback penalty..

2 tries of theirs shouldn't have been scored.....

It all evened out in the end..

 

[davi]

Flano classic whinge in the post match, I thought he was about to reach for the tissue box! Surprisingly he didn't mention the 50-50 grounding try that went there way lol.

Some fans and media personality's are now starting to tire from these coaches' tirades. Particularly when their teams had their chances to win and stuffed it. I think Barrett complaints have merit, but Shane Flannigan's team defiantly had their chances and fluffed it.

Flannigan has suggested Maloney should have not been sin binned for his professional foul which really hurts his credibility.

http://www.news.com.au/sport/nrl/cr...t/news-story/399ce6017f3a3e6cbb5f077d988e9c4f

 

[Cherry_poppins]

Only because all games were thrillers but the refs were shit.

No dogs helped

Still shit refs all weekend