Greatest winger ever

[nick87]

Lol Eric Grothe Snr
Motherf**ker couldn't handle Eric Grothe Jnr let alone Nick Cotric

 

[WaznTheGreat]

Lol Eric Grothe Snr
Motherf**ker couldn't handle Eric Grothe Jnr let alone Nick Cotric

Eric Grothe Jr would have actually been the greatest winger ever if he actually cared about Rugby League tbh,dude didn't give a shit and was still a beast.

 

[stormbati]

If Semi stayed and played this way for a few more years he would of entered the conversation.

 

[Albert Rosenfeld]

If Semi stayed and played this way for a few more years he would of entered the conversation.

The correct English grammar is "would have."

For the record, Semi has already entered the conversation.

And in fact he will return to rugby league after French rugby union. But even then it is hard to see how he could ever be better than Brian Bevan.

 

[gregstar]

I remember Ian Herron kicking 3 from 5 and almost scoring a try one afternoon.

He also returned a kick into the field of play in the same match.

So I don't think he should be left out of this discussion.

 

[TheVelourFog]

None have the long jeverdy

 

[stormbati]

The correct English grammar is "would have."

Exactly

 

[Albert Rosenfeld]

I remember Ian Herron kicking 3 from 5 and almost scoring a try one afternoon.

He also returned a kick into the field of play in the same match.

So I don't think he should be left out of this discussion.

Your introduction of Ian "Mr Nobody" Herron's name suggests that you have a poor sense of humour.

 

[gregstar]

Your introduction of Ian "Mr Nobody" Herron's name suggests that you have a poor sense of humour.

Clearly you never saw his efforts dick pus.

He was the pioneer for future stars such as Luke Covell who made an impact second to none.

Get stuffed.

 

[Vee]

He was the pioneer for future stars such as Luke Covell who made an impact second to none.

By which you mean that his impact was less than none. Fair call.

 

[gregstar]

By which you mean that his impact was less than none. Fair call.

a Herron & Covell pairing could have secured a premiership had they ever been united within 1 era.

 

[Vee]

a Herron & Covell pairing could have secured a premiership had they ever been united within 1 era.

Would have Horder and Blinkhorn looking over their shoulders.

 

[moffla]

Vunivalu /close thread

 

[Albert Rosenfeld]

Would have Horder and Blinkhorn looking over their shoulders.

gregstar is not quite smart enough to be rated an imbecile.

 

[halfbackBENHUNT]

Amos Roberts

 

[_Johnsy]

Best I have seen, Eric Grothe Snr.

I'm now 46 and have been watching RL since I was 5, & guru is the best, and by some distance.

 

[Albert Rosenfeld]

I'm now 46 and have been watching RL since I was 5, & guru is the best, and by some distance.

You are too young to have seen the best. His name was Brian Bevan.

 

[Vee]

You are too young to have seen the best. His name was Brian Bevan.

Maybe, but that wasn't the question, was it?

 

[gregstar]

gregstar is not quite smart enough to be rated an imbecile.

But smart enough to be above the current blues halfback no doubt.

Just how stupid were the other sperm cells for you to win?

 

[Smack]

Todd Byrne