Halves Options 2019

[sharkman73]

of course it did.
perry played his part.
as did chad.
chad had a great season 2016.
to say he didn't have much to do with it isn't right.
what makes chad excel has been removed.
it's a vastly different arrangement now and this does not suit his game.
move lockyer on at the time and see how perry goes.

We're in agreement.

 

[Birdee_Num_Num]

Moyza isn't the issue, put him next to a decent half and he'll go to another level. Unfortunately we're stuck with Chad and I don't see a better option atm, which is pretty sad given how bad he is.

Unfortunately Flanno Jnr is nowhere near NRL level.

Leave Wade where he is. We've tried him in the halves before, doesn't work and never will.

doesn't look like it.
I'm saying the 7 isnt getting the assistance he needs from his 6.
you are saying the opposite.
1 player is in the top 5 paid in the squad.
1 is not.
let's go recruit another marque half shall we?
thought we just did that.

 

[sharkman73]

doesn't look like it.
I'm saying the 7 isnt getting the assistance he needs from his 6.
you are saying the opposite.
1 player is in the top 5 paid in the squad.
1 is not.
let's go recruit another marque half shall we?
thought we just did that.

No, I'm saying Moylan isn't getting the assistance he needs from his halfback.

 

[Birdee_Num_Num]

No, I'm saying Moylan isn't getting the assistance he needs from his halfback.

if you think we are in agreement over that you need your eyes checked.
you don't go from state a to state b and blame things that haven't changed in the transitional phase when working out why something is no longer successful.
what's the benchmark? 2016.
the 7 is capable.
What's changed? The 6.
buy a better half that compliments Chad's game or stick with the one we had.
so you're saying we needed a new 6 and 7?
should have gone for hunt as well lol
fmd

 

[Defer to the coifed]

 

[Mr Angry]

lol

 

[sharkman73]

if you think we are in agreement over that you need your eyes checked.
you don't go from state a to state b and blame things that haven't changed in the transitional phase when working out why something is no longer successful.
what's the benchmark? 2016.
the 7 is capable.
What's changed? The 6.
buy a better half that compliments Chad's game or stick with the one we had.
so you're saying we needed a new 6 and 7?
should have gone for hunt as well lol
fmd

Only the 6 has changed since 2016, has it? You seriously cannot comprehend the only reason Chad was reasonably OK in 2016 was because of Maloney, Barba and Ennis? I could have been an OK halfback with those three around me.

The guy is in the bottom 4 halfbacks in the NRL. He is the issue, not Moylan.

 

[Birdee_Num_Num]

blind freddy could see chad was a foil half.
and he does it pretty well.
how many times did we see chad punch through the line in 2016 or back up and score under the sticks?
remove all the other attacking threats i.e. barba, maloney and ennis and he is exposed.
what a brilliant idea to pair him up with an inexperienced 6 and a 9 that is on a leash and a 1 that is learning his craft.
need to put an order in for more eskys I think.

 

[Birdee_Num_Num]

The guy is in the bottom 4 halfbacks in the NRL. He is the issue, not Moylan.

rank them then.
this will be fun.

 

[sharkman73]

rank them then.
this will be fun.

Chad? He'd get a game at halfback at Storm and Dogs.

That's it.

 

[Birdee_Num_Num]

Chad? He'd get a game at halfback at Storm and Dogs.

That's it.

rank all the nrl 7s.

 

[sharkman73]

rank all the nrl 7s.

I said he's bottom 4, I have said who I believe which clubs he'd get a game at. Any other club he's depth.

If you want them all ranked, you do it.

 

[1990 sharkie]

rank all the nrl 7s.

Thurston
Cronk
Reynolds
Dce
Johnson
Cleary
Hunt
Brooks
Sezer
Taylor
Pearce
Moses

Marshall-king
Hughes (both played a handful of games so let's no compare him to them)

Chad
Nikorima

Worst one is nikorima but he is make shift so give those other younger 2 a couple more years and we have the worst regular half in the comp

 

[Birdee_Num_Num]

I said he's bottom 4, I have said who I believe which clubs he'd get a game at. Any other club he's depth.

If you want them all ranked, you do it.

I'm not the one making the claim I can't back up.

Thurston
Cronk
Reynolds
Dce
Johnson
Cleary
Hunt
Brooks
Sezer
Taylor
Pearce
Moses

Marshall-king
Hughes (both played a handful of games so let's no compare him to them)

Chad
Nikorima

Worst one is nikorima but he is make shift so give those other younger 2 a couple more years and we have the worst regular half in the comp

kudos to you.
you lost me after cleary.

 

[sharkman73]

I'm not the one making the claim I can't back up.

I've backed it up. Comprehension obviously isn't your strong point.

 

[Birdee_Num_Num]

I've backed it up. Comprehension obviously isn't your strong point.

oh no it's just fine thanks.
I just want to laugh at who you have above chad lol.

 

[sharkman73]

oh no it's just fine thanks.
I just want to laugh at who you have above chad lol.

Let's see.

You rate Chad ahead of Pearce.

Chad is better than Moylan because he's won a premiership. Great logic. You obviously think Shane Perry was a better halfback than Stacey Jones.

Yep, you're the one having a laugh alright.

 

[coolumsharkie]

This might go straight to the hotdog stand

 

[1990 sharkie]

I'm not the one making the claim I can't back up.

kudos to you.
you lost me after cleary.

We aren't comparing value for money or what they have to be paired with to be good.
Overall skill set those that I have mentioned are more skilled than Chad.

Tell me why you think Chad is better than those after cleary

 

[bluefox68]

Thurston
Cronk
Reynolds
Dce
Johnson
Cleary
Hunt
Brooks
Sezer
Taylor
Pearce
Moses

Marshall-king
Hughes (both played a handful of games so let's no compare him to them)

Chad
Nikorima

Worst one is nikorima but he is make shift so give those other younger 2 a couple more years and we have the worst regular half in the comp

Well done.
I started doing a list earlier today, but gave up when i couldn’t remember Dogs and Eels...!!!