Desert Qlder
First Grade
- Messages
- 9,113
The referees are pretty good - they aren't going to get any better.
The thing to do is change the rules a bit to reduce the impact of referees.
Like for instance: the recipient of a penalty should not get to kick for touch - this is just a gift of territory (usually about 30 metres) and makes these arbitrary often erroneous decisions of the referees more influential on the game than actual plays made by players. I would prefer that on a penalty the tackle count restarts and on the first tackle play an advantage so if there is an error the penalty recipient still gets the scrum feed.
Additionally increase the ways in which the players can make momentum swinging plays for example fully legitimise stripping in a one man tackle so that there are no knock-on calls or tackle count restarts in attempting the strip (these risks are what stop players attempting to make a strip). Also attempted charge downs or intercepts (even when a knocked on) should not restart the tackle count if the dispossessed team comes back up with the ball.
Sean Fagan was onto this idea at least five years ago, possibly more. A kick for touch is just unnecessary in the era of ten metre defensive line.
At the time he suggested that it be just a simple penalty tap restart, which is something I could agree with after successful trialling.