Sths roster wasn't bad enough to get the results that Madge achieved under his watch in 2017. To win only 9 games & lose 15 with a differential of 100 pts ISN'T a big rap of a coaching performance,& to be honest,is a miserable effort. It certainly doesn't indicate that he has all the attributes of a great coach. Most coaches win comps because they happen to have a very,very good roster[or cattle] which Madge had at Wigan & at Sths in 2014. The true indication of a good coach is how he can get a lesser squad to perform. Madge hasn't lifted the players one iota over the past 2 seasons,& therefore,he received his marching orders. His sacking was appropriate considering all that has eventuated over the past two years!!