Match review committee Charges

[getsmarty]

JUDICIARY


Lawrie charged by the NRL Match Review Committee
Author
Dragons.com.au dragons.com.au
Timestamp
Sun 27 May 2018, 03:15 PM

St George Illawarra prop Blake Lawrie has copped a grade one dangerous contact – other charge by the NRL Match Review Committee following the Dragons' loss to the Panthers on Saturday night.

Lawrie's hit on a kicking James Maloney midway through the second half has seen him pick up 75 demerit points.

The Dapto Canaries junior won't miss any football with an early guilty plea.


https://www.dragons.com.au/news/2018/05/27/lawrie-charged-by-the-nrl-match-review-committee/

 

[Frank Facer]

JUDICIARY


Lawrie charged by the NRL Match Review Committee
Author
Dragons.com.au dragons.com.au
Timestamp
Sun 27 May 2018, 03:15 PM

St George Illawarra prop Blake Lawrie has copped a grade one dangerous contact – other charge by the NRL Match Review Committee following the Dragons' loss to the Panthers on Saturday night.

Lawrie's hit on a kicking James Maloney midway through the second half has seen him pick up 75 demerit points.

The Dapto Canaries junior won't miss any football with an early guilty plea.


https://www.dragons.com.au/news/2018/05/27/lawrie-charged-by-the-nrl-match-review-committee/

I didn't even think it warranted a penalty.

 

[nontime111]

RANK! penalty at the MAX

 

[Lovemedragons]

Maybe I need to look at that again, I missed the elbow and head butt the first time I saw it.FFS the match review committee always seem to pick on the no names meanwhile 'lead with the head' Napa plays SOO.

 

[Coffs dragon]

I'm more surprised he got on the field!

 

[Bests Golden Boots]

Ahhh it’s good he won’t miss any football.......I mean no more than sitting on the bench for 77 minutes anyway.

 

[O'Sullivan]

I was pleased he tried to get to Maloney. We should have tried to put pressure on him all game.

 

[Bests Golden Boots]

I was pleased he tried to get to Maloney. We should have tried to put pressure on him all game.

I was pleased with his entire performance, he looked strong, hungry and eager to impress.
Given Mary’s bench policies he may have thought it was his only chance.

 

[blacksafake]

I thought he got him around the waist not the legs.Hell i've seen Widdop cop worse so far this year.
What about the guy who whacked Nighty around the melon?

 

[getsmarty]

DRAGONS


Sele charged by Match Review Committee
Author
NRL.com
Timestamp
Fri 6 Jul 2018, 11:56 AM

Dragons forward Hame Sele has been charged with a dangerous throw by the NRL Match Review Committee.

Sele's 29th-minute challenge on Storm winger Young Tonumaipea attracted a grade one charge, which carries 100 demerit points.

Sele has no prior offences or loading and can avoid a ban with an early plea but faces a week out with an unsuccessful challenge.

Player Hame Sele
Club Dragons
Time Minute of Match 29th minute
Charge / Incident Dangerous throw
Charge Grade 1
7yrs Incident free for discount No
Base Penalty for Charge 100
Penalty Points: Early Plea 75
Penalty Points: Guilty 100
Prior Non-similar Offences in last 2 years (50% loading) 0
Prior Non-similar Offences in last 2 years (20% loading) 0
Carry-over Points to be added 0
Misconduct on Whom? Young Tonumaipea

https://www.dragons.com.au/news/2018/07/06/sele-charged-by-match-review-committee/

 

[Gareth67]

Bluudy refs could had pulled over any number of Melbourne players , more so in their gang tackles , forever stifiling the Dragons attack . No team has any quick play the balls against the Storm , none . They are in my most humble opinion the cesspool of indecent football , if they ever played the game of rugby league in the true spirit they would lose more then they would win .

As for Sele there was nothing wrong with the tackle - that i could see .

 

[Bests Golden Boots]

Bluudy refs could had pulled over any number of Melbourne players , more so in their gang tackles , forever stifiling the Dragons attack . No team has any quick play the balls against the Storm , none . They are in my most humble opinion the cesspool of indecent football , if they ever played the game of rugby league in the true spirit they would lose more then they would win .

As for Sele there was nothing wrong with the tackle - that i could see .

How many times did Smith come in as third tackler below the knees?

 

[Gareth67]

How many times did Smith come in as third tackler below the knees?

Well there is a good reason for that B.G.B . The bloke is still looking for his marbles that Lattimore lost for him in our previous match .

 

[getsmarty]

Fuimaono charged by match review committee

St George Illawarra forward Tyrell Fuimaono has been charged with a grade one dangerous contact charge following the Dragons' loss to the Rabbitohs on Sunday.

www.dragons.com.au

 

[blacksafake]

Fuimaono charged by match review committee

St George Illawarra forward Tyrell Fuimaono has been charged with a grade one dangerous contact charge following the Dragons' loss to the Rabbitohs on Sunday.

www.dragons.com.au

If this is for the high shot, First contact was with the ball & then his arm slipped up. Is this grounds for an appeal with it IMO being accidental, not dangerous.
He was also charged for the "very grey area" hip drop but I haven't seen it & fox didn't bother looking for it for a replay.
Having said that our success rate on fighting the charges are zilch.

 

[Jeremy Dragon]

If this is for the high shot, First contact was with the ball & then his arm slipped up. Is this grounds for an appeal with it IMO being accidental, not dangerous.
He was also charged for the "very grey area" hip drop but I haven't seen it & fox didn't bother looking for it for a replay.
Having said that our success rate on fighting the charges are zilch.

This must be it

 

[Gareth67]

Honestly I just wish the hell they would use the same level with all teams . It infuriates me to think of the crap that has been dished out to the Dragons this season by the judiciary.

J.W.Hargraves hit a opposition player to the head with his forearm only last week , the player was visibly shaken by the ‘ hit ‘ and would you believe not one word was said about it by the 9 commentators , why ? That so called ‘enforcer ‘ has gotten away with blue bluudy murder time and time again .

If Fuimanano is indeed guilty of the charge ( and I be damned if I can see how ? ) then penalize him by all means , but the judiciary MUST do exactly the same with EACH player from EACH club .

Some teams are untouchable , whereas the strugglers are fair game for the most minor of indiscretions .

A-holes !

 

[SGMax]

Lets see if Talakai gets charged for the shoulder charge in tonights game v Manly.
Again, commentators gasped at what a hard tackle it was but not a suggestion of the shoulder charge that it was.
Poor Ravs targeted for wearing the redV.

 

[SnowDragon]

Honestly I just wish the hell they would use the same level with all teams . It infuriates me to think of the crap that has been dished out to the Dragons this season by the judiciary.

J.W.Hargraves hit a opposition player to the head with his forearm only last week , the player was visibly shaken by the ‘ hit ‘ and would you believe not one word was said about it by the 9 commentators , why ? That so called ‘enforcer ‘ has gotten away with blue bluudy murder time and time again .

If Fuimanano is indeed guilty of the charge ( and I be damned if I can see how ? ) then penalize him by all means , but the judiciary MUST do exactly the same with EACH player from EACH club .

Some teams are untouchable , whereas the strugglers are fair game for the most minor of indiscretions .

A-holes !

its ridiculous. I’ve trouble enjoying games these days. I keep asking myself (or anyone stupid enough to be close at the time) why the hell some players are penalised and others aren’t. Takes the focus and enjoyment away

 

[epDragon62]

Lets see if Talakai gets charged for the shoulder charge in tonights game v Manly.
Again, commentators gasped at what a hard tackle it was but not a suggestion of the shoulder charge that it was.
Poor Ravs targeted for wearing the redV.

I'm glad you posted this as I noted the Talakai tackle as well and can not see how it gets no mention whereas Rava's beautiful hip height table warrants any suspension.

I don't know if we are targeted or if we are considered push overs but we certainly are not coming off well in the justice stakes...