What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NRL Rookie Show

VillaTheGorilla

Juniors
Messages
508
I'm enjoying the show. A bit cheesy at times, but pretty entertaining to watch. Interesting to see that 2 of the kiwi boys and the english bloke are all rugby players, so you'd think the aussies have that edge over them when it comes to the crunch.
 
Messages
12,362
Why are there so many damn yawnion players on this show? Why select these useless twats? That Elias Power is a top notch wanker.

It's also a struggle to watch Erin Molan as host. I feel like I have to like her cos she's a Raiders fan, but she's such a f*ckin try-hard.
 

slammingsam

Juniors
Messages
833
I feel like the Ex Roosters under 20s guy is being built up to win - Goodwin or whatever.

I'd like to see more of Luke Frixou? Bob sled and ex union guy. Big frame and young.
 

VillaTheGorilla

Juniors
Messages
508
I feel like the Ex Roosters under 20s guy is being built up to win - Goodwin or whatever.

I'd like to see more of Luke Frixou? Bob sled and ex union guy. Big frame and young.

Yeah they showed him in the weight room last week, looks pretty powerful, but didnt show him almost at all this week?

Thought it was a bit soft how they got rid of the guy who was injured, after letting the other guy who was injured stay on last week. Danny seemed like one of the fitter ones in the challenges, and didn't put a foot wrong on the paddock even though he's a union player. Scored a good try too, from memory. I think Fittler's playing favourites
 

aqua_duck

Coach
Messages
18,339
Yeah they showed him in the weight room last week, looks pretty powerful, but didnt show him almost at all this week?

Thought it was a bit soft how they got rid of the guy who was injured, after letting the other guy who was injured stay on last week. Danny seemed like one of the fitter ones in the challenges, and didn't put a foot wrong on the paddock even though he's a union player. Scored a good try too, from memory. I think Fittler's playing favourites

What's even worse was the excuse that because he was trying to become a halfback the position would be too tough to learn, in that case why did you even bother with him as a halfback in the first case. The bloke played rugby 7s for England as an outside back, why not see how he goes as an outside back on the show?
 

TheRam

Coach
Messages
13,480
I think it is a shit show with shit potential NRL prospects. If that is the best available, then crikey, league is stuffed.

For starters, I wouldn't look at anyone over 23 yrs old unless they were exceptional and I mean exceptional.
 
Last edited:

Clifferd

Coach
Messages
10,805
Agree, I don't understand how a 28 year old can be considered a "rookie".

If they haven't already made it through the pathways by that age then it's simple, they're not good enough

Should only be 19-22 year olds
 

VillaTheGorilla

Juniors
Messages
508
Agree, I don't understand how a 28 year old can be considered a "rookie".

If they haven't already made it through the pathways by that age then it's simple, they're not good enough

Should only be 19-22 year olds

I guess that sometimes life gets in the way for people and they don't have a chance to go through the age systems. Lots of sports, even the NRL have stories of players who went down the wrong path, or because of family or other things wern't able to commit to sports in earlier on, only to become professionals at an older age. You're probably not gunna find the next JT or Inglis, but you could definitely get 2-5 years of solid service out of a player at a decent enough price too
 

nomis88

Juniors
Messages
715
Even though I put plus 20 on my IQ recording I missed the end of the show because Origin goes on forever. Can anyone tell me who was eliminated?
 

kdalymc

Bench
Messages
4,313
Agree, I don't understand how a 28 year old can be considered a "rookie".

If they haven't already made it through the pathways by that age then it's simple, they're not good enough

Should only be 19-22 year olds

probably the dumbest thing ever written on this forum.
think about it, jeeez
 
Messages
4,604
I hope David's bits will be unblurred on next week's show!

Pretty sure Nine aren't going to show meat and 2 veg at 7:30 on a family show. It isn't PornHub.

probably the dumbest thing ever written on this forum.
think about it, jeeez

How is he wrong? If someone that age is good enough they would have made it the normal way, they've had plenty of opportunity. How many 28 year olds do you see debut in the NRL each year? Or even in NSW Cup...
 
Messages
4,604
Roydon Gillett playing this week for Wenty in NSW cup

Is he allowed too? Thought it was part of the shows criteria they couldn't be.
Although I suppose all the filming (apart from the final) is finished.

It'd be boring though if he ends up winning and gets a Parra contract.
 
Top