NRL360 Jack Gibson vs Wayne Bennett

[POPEYE]

They should've given Jack a State, then he might've stayed in one place . . . possibly a premiership for every year he coached

 

[RazorRam0n]

I'm a dragons fan, & to say 'Bennett left St George Illawarra a mess' is complete bullshit.

Bennett isn't responsible for the club's complete ineptitude. He was brought to win the club a premiership - and he did that, after decades of frustration. What the club did after that is none of his responsibility.

If Wayne was in front of me right, I'd give him a rusty trombon.

is it a coincidence that every coach post bennett that was endorsed by him after he left, ended up looking like coaching buffoons?

henjak, price and rick stone.

 

[Spade]

I agree with Mick Malthouse, players make coaches. That's why I will never hold Bellamy that high, hasn't left Melbourne and tested himself.

 

[Generalzod]

I agree with Mick Malthouse, players make coaches. That's why I will never hold Bellamy that high, hasn't left Melbourne and tested himself.

His record in origin left a lot to be desired,

 

[The Mad Hatter]

His record in origin left a lot to be desired,

Bellamy's wasn't so crash hot either.

 

[The Mad Hatter]

Could have had 3 more cups if the curmudgeon had come to Redfern for 2012-2014.

f**k, Souths would be gunning for 6 in a row, or probably more likely their 5th in 6 seasons as we always seem to lose one in a golden run.

 

[Generalzod]

Bellamy's wasn't so crash hot either.

My reply was about Bellamy's origin record...

 

[The Mad Hatter]

My reply was about Bellamy's origin record...

I was being smart.

 

[Generalzod]

I was being smart.

Yeah no worries

 

[WaznTheGreat]

Cam Smith is the best coach of all time

 

[Barkley]

Cam Smith is the best coach of all time

And Referee

 

[POPEYE]

I agree with Mick Malthouse, players make coaches. That's why I will never hold Bellamy that high, hasn't left Melbourne and tested himself.

Bullshit . . . how many RL premierships has Malthouse won . . . he can't even coach a player on how to not knock a ball on

 

[RazorRam0n]

this is what happens when you give children access to the internet

should 100-0

 

[POPEYE]

I'd be surprised if the percentages represented were nothing more than a record of people who know what it takes to coach against those that don't

 

[King hit]

this is what happens when you give children access to the internet

should 100-0

I know Queenslanders who think Bennett is a Devine being and that nobody else comes close. Can't say it's surprising.

 

[POPEYE]

His record in origin left a lot to be desired,

Depends who you go for, Qld supporters think Bellamy's prodigal son input record is second to none . . . his effort in coaching inferior players to beat them in the time available would definitely not impress a f**kwit

Btw, how do other NSW coaches go against Qld when all Bellamy's prodigies are on deck

 

[The Mad Hatter]

And Referee

Wait til he's running the NRL.

 

[POPEYE]

Wait til he's running the NRL.

Won't be afraid to wrestle with the hard tasks

 

[Eion]

If Jack is better than Bennett, and the only other one being talked about is Bellamy....there's one bloke who should be discussed. He towelled Bellamy up in a GF and won the comp with a club Jack thought impossible.

Take a bow Shane Flanagan.

 

[kbw]

Bellamy has been incredibly lucky with Smith and Slater.
Give he has had some input into what they are now, but so would have most coaches.

Aside from that Bellamy makes robots. He has a team of 3 stars and 14 players very confined in what they are allowed to do. Its evident when one of the robots leave Melbourne they struggle in a big way.
He does it very well though, as does Slater (not Smith) coaching the more enjoyable part of melb's game