What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Queensland having a cry

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
BeGQU7cCIAAd4Bf.jpg


looks like they want to try and break the Origin rules again
 

Usain Bolt

Bench
Messages
3,729
They should just let players play for whatever state they want. The whole "where was he born" or "where did he play his first game" thing is a bunch of BS now. Just pick a state and be done with it
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...ate-queenslander/story-fni3fqyo-1226803583081

New South Wales will force Luke Keary to wear blue despite the half being passionate Queenslander

Todd Balym
The Courier-Mail
January 16, 2014 11:00PM

LUKE Keary was born and raised in Ipswich but will be forced against his will to represent NSW in State of Origin.

The South Sydney halfback idolised Allan Langer and Darren Lockyer as a youngster and was a member of Queensland's Emerging Origin squad last year, but will be absent when the young stars gather in Brisbane on Friday because NRL officials have ruled he must play for the Blues.

Keary told The Courier-Mail last year he wanted to play for Queensland, but desperate Blues officials have successfully claimed him as one of their own.

The Blues complained to the ARL Commission who ruled the 21-year-old was a New South Welshman because four of the six eligibility questions came up Blue, with only his place of birth being Maroon.

Keary was born in Ipswich but moved to Sydney when he was 10 and completed the majority of his schooling and junior football down south.

He played for the NSW Combined Independent Schools team in 2010 but he returned to Queensland in 2011 to make his senior football debut with the Burleigh Bears before joining the Rabbitohs.

Keary is such a prodigious talent that Souths extended his deal until the end of 2015 last year. He is likely to secure a permanent first-grade position ahead of Adam Reynolds and John Sutton.

Maroons coach Mal Meninga said Queensland would continue to support Keary's push to have his status returned to the Maroons.

"It's disappointing for Luke and for us,'' Meninga said. "I know Luke wanted to play for Queensland and we won't give up on him.

"Luke is a passionate Queenslander and wants to play for Queensland. He played his junior footy at Ipswich before moving to Sydney with his parents.

"I don't know if there is any way we can appeal it, I guess we will look at it and see where we can take it from here."

Queensland had two eligibility victories, with Manly prop Brenton Lawrence and Penrith hooker James Segeyaro both declared Maroons. They will join Friday's camp, taking the squad to 14.

Segeyaro was born in Papua New Guinea but qualifies for the Maroons after moving to Cairns as a child.

Lawrence was born in Mackay but played all of his junior league in Adelaide.

Even though he moved to Canberra in his late teens, Lawrence failed to register a single answer for NSW under the criteria and therefore remained a Queenslander.

It is an enormous boost for Lawrence, who at 29 is the oldest member of the Emerging squad and continues a remarkable career rise since he joined the Sea Eagles last season after two years battling to make first-grade on the Gold Coast.

"I think he deserves it. His last couple of years have been pretty impressive,'' Meninga said.

"I just want to see him in with the other guys and see how he handles it all.

"He is up there and deserves an opportunity in the Emerging squad.''

Meanwhile, Queensland great Kevin Walters is set to become a fulltime Maroons assistant coach this year, with Meninga seeking board approval to add another staffer to his team in their quest for nine straight titles.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
Maroons coach Mal Meninga said Queensland would continue to support Keary's push to have his status returned to the Maroons.

we will try to cheat in other words
 

Tone83

Juniors
Messages
1,225
The fact nswelshmen think it's a valid option to force someone to play for their state shows they lack the capacity to grasp what origin means to qlders. How absurd. I'm sure he'd rather drink a gallon of draino.

Luckily he'll never have to play for nsw anyway because he's not good enough, crisis averted there, but yeah the principal of it is outrageous.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
Keary learnt his footy in NSW

rules were changed because Queensland cheated with Inglis and now it's simple

now Queensland are trying to cheat again going off Meninga's statement
 

Son of Minto

Bench
Messages
3,114
The fact nswelshmen think it's a valid option to force someone to play for their state shows they lack the capacity to grasp what origin means to qlders. How absurd. I'm sure he'd rather drink a gallon of draino.

Luckily he'll never have to play for nsw anyway because he's not good enough, crisis averted there, but yeah the principal of it is outrageous.

Hes already good enough for NSW. He'll still never play for them though.
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
The fact nswelshmen think it's a valid option to force someone to play for their state shows they lack the capacity to grasp what origin means to qlders. How absurd. I'm sure he'd rather drink a gallon of draino.

Luckily he'll never have to play for nsw anyway because he's not good enough, crisis averted there, but yeah the principal of it is outrageous.

so 16 year old NSWelshman who move to Queensland should play for Queensland and 10 year old Queenlanders who move to NSW should also play for Quuensland?

riiiiiiight

is there anyone of any age in any state who shouldn't play for Queensland?
 

Son of Minto

Bench
Messages
3,114
"Provision on application may be made to players who were born and resided the majority of their life in one state but played all Rugby League in the other state."

Keary has lived the majority of his life in his home state of Qld. Seems pretty clear cut to me. Nice try NSW. He'll be back in Maroon by the end of the week.
 

BennyV

Referee
Messages
22,530
The fact nswelshmen think it's a valid option to force someone to play for their state shows they lack the capacity to grasp what origin means to qlders. How absurd. I'm sure he'd rather drink a gallon of draino.

Luckily he'll never have to play for nsw anyway because he's not good enough, crisis averted there, but yeah the principal of it is outrageous.

Lol yeah, every word the Courier Fail prints is gospel, no biased reporting there! I'm gunna go searching for the NSW torture dungeon where they brainwashed Keary...
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
"Provision on application may be made to players who were born and resided the majority of their life in one state but played all Rugby League in the other state."

Keary has lived the majority of his life in his home state of Qld. Seems pretty clear cut to me. Nice try NSW. He'll be back in Maroon by the end of the week.

so Sims will be in NSW then by your logic even though they have flat out said it won't happen

and by the time Keary would ever play Origin he would have lived most of his life in NSW
 
Last edited:

Kiwi

First Grade
Messages
9,471
I agree with el diablo and co even though I'm a qld fan. He is a blue the ruling has been made this just looks like sooking to me and I don't like it. It comes across as very two faced.
 
Top