R19 vs Broncos

[martielang]

Milford could/should of been sin binned 3 times.

Last min of first half when he kicked the ball in the play the ball when we should of scored, after Kikaus line break when we would of scored & the hair pull.

You’d think the good old sin bin for professional foul would apply when a player you know maybe commits a professional foul? Or 3?

 

[OldPanther]

Maloney might be in a spot of bother for his shoulder charge in the first half. Milford also might get a contrary conduct charge for hair pulling but it'll only be a fine.

If Luai isn't injured long term get him at 5/8.

 

[TheFrog]

He is getting past it. That pass should not have been thrown.

Both the intercepts should not have been thrown. Nikorima was waiting for the pass both times. Maloney's was marginally worse and it ended our comeback.

 

[umina panther]

Milford could/should of been sin binned 3 times.

Last min of first half when he kicked the ball in the play the ball when we should of scored, after Kikaus line break when we would of scored & the hair pull.

You’d think the good old sin bin for professional foul would apply when a player you know maybe commits a professional foul? Or 3?

Really hard for me to get mad about shit like this when we actually got off lightly on the scoreboard. We deserved to lose that by 70

 

[TheFrog]

How on earth Milford wasn’t binned when he yanked CHN to the ground off the ball by his hair? Why wasn’t it put on report? If you did that in a junior league game you’d be sent off.

Roberts grabbing Yeo on the kick chase as well.

 

[The Realist]

TheFrog's Player Ratings

Maloney 3

If there was a case for a ZERO or even Negative points this performance would be it!

 

[TheFrog]

If there was a case for a ZERO or even Negative points this performance would be it!

He needs a rest I think. Maybe play May in the 6 next game.

 

[Karnivayne]

TheFrog's Player Ratings

Luai 4
Mansour 6
Blake 6
Whare 5
Crichton 3
Maloney 3
Cleary 6
Merrin 5
Katoa 5
Tamou 6
Yeo 7
Kikau 7
Fisher-Harris 6

Peachey 7
Harawira-Naera 6
Hetherington 5
Leota 4

Referee Rating Klein (4)

Luai, had nothing in attack and was caught out once but apart from that cant really blame him for much
Mansour, didnt get into any hard stuff until we were on the front foot so the 12 weeks we were waiting for didnt amount to much nor should it after 3 months out
Blake, was our only output restricted by a super potato in defense
Whare, wasn't great but was his usual self, ok in defense ok in attack
Crichton, terrible
Maloney, living off those few games without Cleary
Cleary, Bomb, pretty much it
Merrin, After 1 offload i dont recall seeing him play
Katoa, Not bad after his 15th drop ball or hospital pass
Tamou, 1 run
Yeo, Played ok
Kikau, our only attacking option
JFH, Ok but nothing special
Peachey, Only spark
CHN, was ok but hair was a massive issue
Hetherington, 1 good game out of 10.... thats why Roosters let him go
Leota, Played ok, saved a try, didnt do much else

 

[Frankus]

Really hard for me to get mad about shit like this when he actually got off lightly on the scoreboard. We deserved to lose that by 70

Yep. Yet our boys were all smiles and rainbows at the end of the game. Go figure. They should be embarrassed.
There should be no smiling, no hugging, no beers. They should have been stone cold Wayne Bennett after the game and apologising to the fans and Yeo for the piss poor effort.

Let’s see an apology in the post match presser.

 

[martielang]

Really hard for me to get mad about shit like this when he actually got off lightly on the scoreboard. We deserved to lose that by 70

Nah, I still get pissed no matter what the score.

Momentum is a big thing with such a young team. I think tonight is the first time this year we broke mentally & Those calls (+ TPJ try, penalty against Maloney for Kahu pushing him into the ruck etc etc) were a factor even if minimal.

 

[cain3y]

Milford 4 penalties conceded WTF how was there no sin bin.

 

[forby]

It is good to see the tradition of death riding the team after a bad game continues. Doesn't show any faith in what is a good bunch of kids!
Come on! Shake it off and get back to supporting the boys not deriding them. Haven't all of you had a day where nothing goes right and the harder you try the worse it gets?
The sun will rise tomorrow and the boys will get stuck into the SeaEagles next week!

 

[OldPanther]

It is good to see the tradition of death riding the team after a bad game continues. Doesn't show any faith in what is a good bunch of kids!
Come on! Shake it off and get back to supporting the boys not deriding them. Haven't all of you had a day where nothing goes right and the harder you try the worse it gets?
The sun will rise tomorrow and the boys will get stuck into the SeaEagles next week!

They deserve it. The Sharks loss was ok but this was disgusting.

 

[The Realist]

It is good to see the tradition of death riding the team after a bad game continues. Doesn't show any faith in what is a good bunch of kids!
Come on! Shake it off and get back to supporting the boys not deriding them. Haven't all of you had a day where nothing goes right and the harder you try the worse it gets?
The sun will rise tomorrow and the boys will get stuck into the SeaEagles next week!

We are upset because this team shows so much promise! It has the makings of a legitimate dynasty...but it is being flushed down the toilet by having an average coach and some curious (READ: DUMB!) key recruitment and retention decisions.

 

[cain3y]

It is good to see the tradition of death riding the team after a bad game continues. Doesn't show any faith in what is a good bunch of kids!
Come on! Shake it off and get back to supporting the boys not deriding them. Haven't all of you had a day where nothing goes right and the harder you try the worse it gets?
The sun will rise tomorrow and the boys will get stuck into the SeaEagles next week!

I think everyone on here is just frustrated as we have seen the potential of this side and were expecting a close contest. Whats more disappointing for me is seeing a penrith legend in Ryan Girlder continually tip against us. Never see Lockyer do this.

 

[Karnivayne]

It is good to see the tradition of death riding the team after a bad game continues. Doesn't show any faith in what is a good bunch of kids!
Come on! Shake it off and get back to supporting the boys not deriding them. Haven't all of you had a day where nothing goes right and the harder you try the worse it gets?
The sun will rise tomorrow and the boys will get stuck into the SeaEagles next week!

Why be complacent with that shit, thats why shit coaches keep coaching shit for so long.

With the half we have(cleary not maloney) why are we happy with that, everyone has been complaining about Tamou and Crichton for 6-8 weeks yest the same shit performances are band aided time after time, Merrin has been useless, Hetherington apart from 1 decent game has been pathetic. One coach has been able to get average players to seem decent and that s Bellamy, we have Griffin, seriously if we had a Coach 1/4 as good as Bellamy we would have won the comp already, Griffin is devoid of any tactical aptitude and absolutely no man management expertise, we will never win a comp whilst he is in charge, he got relegated to qld cup ffs, why was he even considered from the start....

 

[mxlegend99]

It is good to see the tradition of death riding the team after a bad game continues. Doesn't show any faith in what is a good bunch of kids!
Come on! Shake it off and get back to supporting the boys not deriding them. Haven't all of you had a day where nothing goes right and the harder you try the worse it gets?
The sun will rise tomorrow and the boys will get stuck into the SeaEagles next week!

You mean like they did a few weeks back?

Panthers have played one good game in the past 2+ months. We finslly get Origin behind us snd put in our worst effort of the year conceding 50 points which has long been yhr mark where teams are a write off. We're not good enough to rewrite history

 

[forby]

I get that people get frustrated, but they are OUR team, part of OUR family!
Get behind the boys, dont be like other clubs who deride their teams. Be proud of what they have done, and will do in the future!
Remember that this is the youngest team in the NRL, and inconsistency comes with that.

 

[OldPanther]

So how's Griffin's record against top teams going?

 

[TheFrog]

Why be complacent with that shit, thats why shit coaches keep coaching shit for so long.

With the half we have(cleary not maloney) why are we happy with that, everyone has been complaining about Tamou and Crichton for 6-8 weeks yest the same shit performances are band aided time after time, Merrin has been useless, Hetherington apart from 1 decent game has been pathetic. One coach has been able to get average players to seem decent and that s Bellamy, we have Griffin, seriously if we had a Coach 1/4 as good as Bellamy we would have won the comp already, Griffin is devoid of any tactical aptitude and absolutely no man management expertise, we will never win a comp whilst he is in charge, he got relegated to qld cup ffs, why was he even considered from the start....

It always helps to vent.