What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Taylor has lost his job

God-King Dean

Immortal
Messages
46,614
Anyone think Aaron Woods is undermining Taylor?

Says the Big 4 (f**king lol) will wait to see who the coach is. Watching Woods play, it was the softest I've seen him play. Always passing, & his actual hit ups were half hearted.
 

Pedge1971

First Grade
Messages
5,898
If MacGregor and Taylor swapped clubs I wonder which set of fans would be most disappointed.

One bloke gets done dui. The other pisses i a cup with mates, throws it on a crowd @ scg. Remind me why they both struggle in a leadership role?
 

Vozzy

Juniors
Messages
1,689
Anyone think Aaron Woods is undermining Taylor?

Says the Big 4 (f**king lol) will wait to see who the coach is. Watching Woods play, it was the softest I've seen him play. Always passing, & his actual hit ups were half hearted.

Big 4 to me are Tedasco, Noufaluma, Sue and Elijah. The rest can earn it or show more pride.

Woods last 2 games he needs to run harder.Yes stat wise woods makes a lot of meters but games like yesterday where he is slow and milking penalties but knocks it on his mind seems elsewhere.
 

Triple H

Juniors
Messages
24
Ya see here's the thing Tigers fans-uhh.

You have a skinnyfat vanilla midget at 5/8. Your halfback is a tubby lil vanilla midget too. Both of them have no muscle definition whatsoever-uhh. Your coach is also a longtime vanilla midget who never picked up a dumbell during his playing career-uhh. How are the halves supposed to look up to a man without pecs? You will never be successful with this formula.
 
Messages
14,796
Depressing when you see what Newcastle had to work with last year and look to be improving after identifying the right young talent and some smart recruiting. We had the potential to begin with and only look to be going the other way and seem to pin our hopes on second chance signings like Austin, Taupau and ET, only for them all to show their wares for us and move on because we're too incompetent to hang on to them.

The whole organisation just stinks from the top to the bottom.

There's no doubt we'll throw the kitchen sink at Teddy to stay, but his family are already loaded and I don't think he'll think twice at taking the second largest contract on offer if it's at Melbourne, Easts, Canterbury or Brisbane. If we lose him we have literally nothing going for us.

Wests Ashfield took over another quarter share to fund this abortion? Surely they cannot be happy with their return on investment and they'll be looking to swing the axe if nothing changes soon...
 

Sea_Eagles_Rock

First Grade
Messages
5,216
They are so patchy. I think defending size is a huge problem for them. Especially wide. Paulo and PapaliI both exposed them. As mentioned above, they are both small, and you can usually hide one, but two becomes a massive challenge. They seem to also have massive issues reforming a line after a break. I keep hearing how Tedesco is the NSW fullback, but he really isn't closing down much at the back. He might be an attacking weapon, but that's only half the battle at origin. Tom T still has a lot to learn this area too. Fullbacks always get the raw end of the deal making a tackle as they are often up against someone at speed. The great ones find a way to make the try saver and brink them to ground or at least slow them to allow defenders to catch up. I'm not suggesting Teddy isn't a good player, most clubs would love him on the books. But he won't be great until he can close them down consistently. Yesterday was pretty difficult though, as most of the stuff happening was real close and soft, as well as being either poor reads or poor tackle attempts with adequate numbers.

Ball control against Canberra is essential. You need to complete, make them work hard and turn the around a lot with good long kicks that are chased hard. If you do that well for 60, you can chase them down quickly for the last 20.

After all the crap that happened the last few seasons between Farah and Taylor, I think they would have been wise to get rid of both of them. And anybody else who got seriously involved in that stuff. You need a united team. That whole Simona mess is hard to believe. 'I didn't know anything was wrong. I asked and he said he was fine.' The guy was inconsistent for ages. More often than not, there usually something going on outside that causes that. Wouldn't you take the time to work it out? If you see he has a few issues domestically offer help to them. The whole jersey and betting stuff is hard to tell, but I don't think working out that something was up with the way things worked in his relationship would have been hard. That's what a good coach would do. Take the guy under the wing and get to know him a bit better. Give him some help to be a better person.

Its not all doom and gloom, they played well in round 1 I thought. And Souths aren't a small side. I think if they can find a way to get Moses and Brooks defending well, perhaps on the wing, they would be a lot better placed. If they are going to defend 3 in, make sure whoever is on their inside is prepared to help cover.
 
Messages
13,982
Agreed but the most shocking stat of the game is that Canberra were also crap having a completion rate in the 60s for most of the game. Canberra were poor and beat us by 40.

Canberra completed 31 of 42 sets for a 74% completion rate. That is quite a deal better than the Tigers 20 out of 34 for a 59% completion rate.
 

God-King Dean

Immortal
Messages
46,614
Ya see here's the thing Tigers fans-uhh.

You have a skinnyfat vanilla midget at 5/8. Your halfback is a tubby lil vanilla midget too. Both of them have no muscle definition whatsoever-uhh. Your coach is also a longtime vanilla midget who never picked up a dumbell during his playing career-uhh. How are the halves supposed to look up to a man without pecs? You will never be successful with this formula.

I don't know why this made me laugh, but it did.
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
23,496
They are just soft defensively around the edges. Brooks is the worst defender in the comp and Moses is a poor defender, as is Naiqaima and from the little of seen of Chee-Kam he seems to struggle with defending the centres as well, atleast the decision making. Add to that their backrowers are nothing special defensively and you have problems.
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,897
Rothfield reporting the board will sack him within 24-48 hours.

 

Pommy

Coach
Messages
14,657
The mind boggles.
They let him force Farah out then sack him after a couple of games.
Now I'm not a huge fan of Farah but he's not the NSW hooker because he's shite. To have that much of your cap space playing for another side is just crazy.
They've stuck with Taylor despite everyone else's better judgment and they need to give him until the end of the season and see where they stand, in my opinion anything else is just crazy.
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
17,649
They will do much better under a new coach, there is some talent there but their attitude takes a nose dive when things get tough and that has to be a coaching thing.

Possibly the 'big 4' have believed their own hope, it is more like a big 1.5. Tedesco is a genuine star in the making and Moses is a decent 5/8. Brooks has to be the most overrated player in the comp, what a dud.

That leads me to the 4th member of the big 4. Who is it supposed to be? Surely not Woods.
 

Clifferd

Coach
Messages
10,805
Ive heard from reliable sources The board forced Farah out, not the coach

hence why Farah is bitter to this very day
 
Top