What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Future Signings

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,364
Yeah and when have they all been on the field together?

Add a great hooker to that side and we look real good. Injuries are the reason we are where we are. Not shit players, not shit coaches, not recruitment. INJURIES.

Carney and Robson are woefully out of form. All play making duties have fallen on Morris' head, which he isn't good at.

The coach has not addressed Carney's defensive issues.

So I'd be blaming coaching and out of form players as much as injuries, if not moreso.

The application isn't there like it was last year and it's hard to instill that among players when the coach doesn't want to be the coach.
 

chewsta

First Grade
Messages
6,958
Does he?

The few times he has been on the field this year I have hardly noticed him.
Whilst Ennis is a pest and a grub his presence is always known on the field. His a leader.


Totally agree, I love Lewis and I know he is a great player, but I have also wondered why he has left the field during a number of games, only to find out he was on the field the whole time. we just dont use him properly at all.
 

chewsta

First Grade
Messages
6,958
Yeah Cardy, only twice this year.
I was also referring to last year too. when he gets the ball he is fantastic. he just doesnt see it enough though.
 

DJDL

First Grade
Messages
6,071
Yeah and when have they all been on the field together?

Add a great hooker to that side and we look real good. Injuries are the reason we are where we are. Not shit players, not shit coaches, not recruitment. INJURIES.


Precisely.

If you look at the total games we've gotten out of our starting pack, plus Heighington, Taga and Toops off the bench and Carney/Robson and Ryan from the halves and backs you've got a total of 69 games played out of a possible 110. Take Wade and Heighno out and it's 50 of 99.

That's 9 of the best players in the squad missing for half the year.

Throw in the injuries to Gal, Fifita and Carney all happened early in their respective games and it's 47 out of 99.

I defy any team in the comp to perform any better under those circumstances.

Carney's form has been horrendous when on deck, no question. But I think that is far from the major contributing factor to what is happening this year
 

ghoti

Bench
Messages
3,529
Yeah, the excuses we've got for performing badly are pretty friggin good...as much as some of us have wanted certain players in/out of the squad, you can't reeeally fault the selections based on just doing whatever you can with what we've got. Whether it was De Gois, Holdsworth, Ayshford and Wright or Lichaa, Penani, Gagan and Stapleton wouldn't have mattered when the rest of your squad is missing...
 

Big Bloke

Juniors
Messages
873
Precisely.

If you look at the total games we've gotten out of our starting pack, plus Heighington, Taga and Toops off the bench and Carney/Robson and Ryan from the halves and backs you've got a total of 69 games played out of a possible 110. Take Wade and Heighno out and it's 50 of 99.

That's 9 of the best players in the squad missing for half the year.

Throw in the injuries to Gal, Fifita and Carney all happened early in their respective games and it's 47 out of 99.

I defy any team in the comp to perform any better under those circumstances.

Carney's form has been horrendous when on deck, no question. But I think that is far from the major contributing factor to what is happening this year

Agree with all that but have you noticed after Origin 1 how all the media darlings have been lamenting the poor fortunes of the Storm and how they have been hit by injury and how they should get some cap relief. Not a mention of us at all! This is what makes my blood boil. We have had issues all year but no one wants to talk about our hardships. But as soon as Melbourne lose a few players it's all "oh the poor darlings."
 

blacktip-reefy

Immortal
Messages
34,076
Precisely.

If you look at the total games we've gotten out of our starting pack, plus Heighington, Taga and Toops off the bench and Carney/Robson and Ryan from the halves and backs you've got a total of 69 games played out of a possible 110. Take Wade and Heighno out and it's 50 of 99.

That's 9 of the best players in the squad missing for half the year.

Throw in the injuries to Gal, Fifita and Carney all happened early in their respective games and it's 47 out of 99.

I defy any team in the comp to perform any better under those circumstances.

Carney's form has been horrendous when on deck, no question. But I think that is far from the major contributing factor to what is happening this year

Hey hey hey hey!!!!! You got your maths right here? You don't want the "count" jumping down your throat for getting a number wrong.
Double check or you will have the forum mongs onto it as well.
 

madunit

Super Moderator
Staff member
Messages
62,364
Hey hey hey hey!!!!! You got your maths right here? You don't want the "count" jumping down your throat for getting a number wrong.
Double check or you will have the forum mongs onto it as well.

still crying about the fact you can't tell the difference between 8 and 11?

ffs man, move on with your life!:lol:
 

Ads

First Grade
Messages
5,169
So what I take out of that is another issue to look at is our medical and recovery team.
 

DJShaksta

First Grade
Messages
7,226
Agree with all that but have you noticed after Origin 1 how all the media darlings have been lamenting the poor fortunes of the Storm and how they have been hit by injury and how they should get some cap relief. Not a mention of us at all! This is what makes my blood boil. We have had issues all year but no one wants to talk about our hardships. But as soon as Melbourne lose a few players it's all "oh the poor darlings."

Yeah I heard that crap on the radio last week.
3 injuries and they want cap concession.
f**k off they didn't have a cap for 5 years between 06 and 11!
We had 2/3's of our top 17 out and got no concession.

Poor Melbourne...........
 

Vin Fizz

Bench
Messages
2,907
I hear what everyone is saying but why didnt we ask for it? That's a big part of the difference between us and the mightier clubs. We act like the victims to much. Let's grab the bull by the hagotts and be the purps for a while. Start acting like we belong (and we do and we will be a fegging strong rich club soon). Fugg I wish Toovs was born on the south side.
 
Last edited:

Big Bloke

Juniors
Messages
873
I hear what everyone is saying but why didnt we ask for it? That's a big part of the difference between us and the mightier clubs. We act like the victims to much. Let's grab the bull by the hagotts and be the purps for a while. Start acting like we belong (and we do and we will be a fegging strong rich club soon). Fugg I wish Toovs was born on the south side.

How do we know we didn't ask for it?
 

betcats

Referee
Messages
24,311
Ennis cops a lot be he would be a good pickup for you guys imo, kinda short term solution but he is still the best hooker you guys have had for years.

Edit: re the salary cap thing, did you guys need an exemption? a lot of injuries doesnt automatically mean you need one.
 
Top