Judiciary charges from semis

[TheViking]

Jackson probably should have gone for at least 1, but with Guerra getting bugger all (and many times worse than the Jackson one) the precedent was set.

Sad really, Guerra should have been 3-4 weeks, and Jackson at least a week.

I know people are saying it was unlucky as he was just trying to get him on his back, but a suspension could be the start of eradicating the excessive wrestle from the game.

I completely agree with this.

If Guerra had of got the 3-4 weeks which would of been fair then I'd think that Jackson getting 1 week would of been expected. That said so should of the tackle on Eastwood around 19 minutes.

 

[Alderley Rooster]

For mine Jacksons and Guerra were both identical. Guerra too was just trying to roll him. Its what the "wrestle" is all about and it needs to be eradicated.

Jackson getting off is a f**king disgrace and no doubt the work of Greenburg.

In all honesty Ennis should have been charged also as the hit was late and high.

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

Funny how you say animals that follow his team!

Your supporters are by far the biggest animals. That's a clear fact..... Besides Manly your supporters are known for being disloyal and not turning up. Watching other sports instead while Chooks are on. Won't get more than 10k there this Friday.

Your team are getting a clear leg up from the refs. Even though it may have been a bit hard to see the past 2 weeks you are getting all the crucial little calls going your way.

Seems like that's how it was planned give it bad to the Chooks most of the year but in the finals give them a leg up. What a bloody disguised plan. No doubt Politis is involved.

And that makes our supporters the biggest animals? You real are Soft Sydney.

 

[Tommy Smith]

Jackson getting off is f**king outrageous.

Especially on the back of the Te'o and Guerra incidents.

Some backroom dealings going on there.

 

[ouwet]

Jackson getting off is f**king outrageous.

Especially on the back of the Te'o and Guerra incidents.

Some backroom dealings going on there.

PLEASE... The Guerra and Te'o incidents were miles worse! Guerra only getting one week meant they had no choice but letting Jackson off, Guerra should've got 3 weeks minimum!

 

[ek999]

For mine Jacksons and Guerra were both identical. Guerra too was just trying to roll him. Its what the "wrestle" is all about and it needs to be eradicated.

Jackson getting off is a f**king disgrace and no doubt the work of Greenburg.

In all honesty Ennis should have been charged also as the hit was late and high.

Guerra

Te'o

Jackson

f**k off they are identical

 

[TheViking]

Guerra

Te'o

Jackson

f**k off they are identical

Guerra should of got 3-4 weeks looking at that.

 

[POPEYE]

From day 1 no-one in their right f**king mind would truly believe players are trying to incapacitate each other, it's merely time wasting that may turn into a battle of strength or at worst a get square.

What is far more despicable is that Greenberg may be influencing the judiciary either directly or indirectly

 

[Danish]

I'm not sure those screenshots are proving what dogs fans think they are proving, even though they've been taken at the most opportune moment possible to make Teo and Guerra look as bad as possible and Jackson look as good as possible.

It was a grade 1 without question.

 

[Nice Beaver]

Honestly, is anyone mildly surprised that Jackson got off?

Phone calls would have been made first thing Sunday morning. Joshy was always going to get off.

 

[Cockadoodledoo]

Honestly, is anyone mildly surprised that Jackson got off?

Phone calls would have been made first thing Sunday morning. Joshy was always going to get off.

He was no chance of being suspended as was Ennis. It doesn't matter anyway, if they make it to the Grand Final we could see Manly's 40-0 record go.

 

[ek999]

I'm not sure those screenshots are proving what dogs fans think they are proving, even though they've been taken at the most opportune moment possible to make Teo and Guerra look as bad as possible and Jackson look as good as possible.

It was a grade 1 without question.

Well then maybe you could provide a screenshot with Jackson pulling his arm back any further than that.

 

[Pierced Soul]

i've never really believed all the conspiracy theories etc but geez the dogs have escaped from a lot of shit this year. there was the dodgy fifita contract, i dont think they got into any trouble for continually leaving graham on the field after he was in disneyland several tiems, reynolds kicks barba and gets a week in the worst "trip" i can recall, williams almosts decapitates sezer and isnt charged, jackson does a classic chicken wing (he's so geniused he cant even rip it as far as guerra), and ennis contacts cherry evans with a shoulder and nothing's said...

 

[Whoosh]

It's not his go....

 

[ouwet]

i've never really believed all the conspiracy theories etc but geez the dogs have escaped from a lot of shit this year. there was the dodgy fifita contract, i dont think they got into any trouble for continually leaving graham on the field after he was in disneyland several tiems, reynolds kicks barba and gets a week in the worst "trip" i can recall, williams almosts decapitates sezer and isnt charged, jackson does a classic chicken wing (he's so geniused he cant even rip it as far as guerra), and ennis contacts cherry evans with a shoulder and nothing's said...

1. Fifita dodgy? How so? He announced he was coming before the Dogs did! We offered him a contract, it's hardly our fault the idiot thought none of it was 3rd parties!

2. You are missing the point sunshine, Reynolds got suspended... Ennis got kicked in the face and nothing happened to Isaac Luke!

3. Look at the Sezer tackle you goose! Didn't hit his head, his arms were wrapped around; I didn't know you can get suspended for hurting a smaller player? It was a joke that was penalised let alone on report!

4. The Graham on the field incident has been mirrored by a lot of clubs this year. Some have been fined (Bulldogs got fined for Jackson earlier in the year) MOST HAVE BEEN LET OFF AFTER THE CLUB EXPLANATION!

5. Regarding Jackson - You just conveniently ignored the pictures of the other incident and said yourself he didn't rip it as much as Aiden G (WHO GOT ONE WEEK FOR A WORSE TACKLE), you killed your own argument.

6. Ennis ARMS WERE WRAPPED AGAIN! He hit him high, yes, we see it every game... FMD JWH got let off for a worse high hit last week.

KEEP ALL THE HATRED EVERYONE COMING... DOGS OF WAR!

 

[McNulty]

i've never really believed all the conspiracy theories etc but geez the dogs have escaped from a lot of shit this year. there was the dodgy fifita contract, i dont think they got into any trouble for continually leaving graham on the field after he was in disneyland several tiems, reynolds kicks barba and gets a week in the worst "trip" i can recall, williams almosts decapitates sezer and isnt charged, jackson does a classic chicken wing (he's so geniused he cant even rip it as far as guerra), and ennis contacts cherry evans with a shoulder and nothing's said...

Josh Reynolds out for 6 weeks this year...

 

[Sime_11]

let him play, the Panthers want him to play, just means Dogs fans cant make excuses up when the Panthers stay alive for another week at Canterbury's expense

 

[grouch]

Thought it was as obvious a chicken wing as you're likely to see. Can't believe it completely avoided charge.

Wrestling is a major blight, and the game continues to fumble any attempt to remove it

 

[Fat Krion]

Bulldogs will probably be without Josh Jackson despite Des Hasler's confidence of no charge for that chicken wing. Were there any others from last night or Friday ? Someone said Jared Warea-Hargreaves might be in strife, but can't remember anything he did.

I like revving up Doggie supporters , i treat it as a hobby but seriously Josh Jackson having no case to answer is an utter disgrace.

I'll ignore the blatant shoulder charges by T Rex and Ennis as they caused no harm and it's a stupid rule.

However with so many players suspened this season there is precedent, something to compare the Jackson tackle with.

The Josh Morris tackle wasn't a chicken wing but Jackson's was there is no doubt abut that.

Haslers confidence that Jackson would get off is a concern.......

 

[Valheru]

Guerra was charged with a grade 2 and got 1 week only due to the early plea and 0 carry over points. Anyone who thinks Jackson's wasn't worthy of a grade 1 is kidding themself.