Roosters dilemma in 2019: Cordner, Crighton and Radley are the three best second rowers in the NRL

[David brown]

Yet you reply to them. To borrow a line from Star Wars "Who is more foolish - the fool or the fool who follows him?"

Your mum...

Booom

 

[Captain Apollo]

Your mum...

Booom

Considering my Mother is currently in hospital and is deathly ill, that's not a good line to use thanks

 

[TheFrog]

Considering my Mother is currently in hospital and is deathly ill, that's not a good line to use thanks

Dave reminds me of Mr Bull in Peppa Pig.

 

[MilkShark]

Really? How do you arrive at that conclusion. Remember, I was talking about 2019, when all three will be at the Roosters.

You know who the best backrowers are for next year already? Cool

 

[mxlegend99]

Are you disabled

No. You're thinking of Boyd Cordner.

 

[mxlegend99]

It's based on your blind hatred.

What about test matches?

Who hasn't carved up for Australia? Its nearly impossible to suck when your team are $1.01 favorites for every match.

 

[mxlegend99]

Must have been a different Boyd Cordner who was the sole try scorer and MOTM in the World Cup final.

Must have been a different Wade Graham who scored 4 tries in a world cup game.

Boyd Cordner is so shit Australia coild only score one try with him in the team.

 

[Tommy Smith]

It's based on your blind hatred.

What about test matches?

The hatred is hilarious.

Last year Cordner was in our top 3 players in every game. He was a peak Craig Fitzgibbon
clone; absolutely immense and - SBW 2013 aside - played as consistently well as any edge backrower I've seen.

It's why he was the Roos first forward picked and MotM in that World Cup final.

And yet if you listened to blind opposition fans you'd think he was at best a solid 1st grader like, say, Isaah Yeo, or at worst some random plodder like Jason Clark.

The stupidity is spectacular.

 

[betcats]

No. You're thinking of Boyd Cordner.

He looks a bit speshal doesn't he? Beady little eyes like a rat. Someone tell the merkin to have a shave he looks like a f**king garbo.

 

[betcats]

The hatred is hilarious.

Last year Cordner was in our top 3 players in every game. He was a peak Craig Fitzgibbon
clone; absolutely immense and - SBW 2013 aside - played as consistently well as any edge backrower I've seen.

It's why he was the Roos first forward picked and MotM in that World Cup final.

And yet if you listened to blind opposition fans you'd think he was at best a solid 1st grader like, say, Isaah Yeo, or at worst some random plodder like Jason Clark.

The stupidity is spectacular.

He is shit this year. You think Phil Gould doesn't know footy? He runs one line, he doesn't pass and his game hasn't developed at all over the years, that's straight from one of the greatest league minds alive today and a guy who loves the rorters. Boyd is an effort guy with not much in arsenal besides trying hard. But yeah its only dumb fans that don't rate him. Chooks fans are the only ones who still think he is elite.

 

[Tommy Smith]

He is shit this year. You think Phil Gould doesn't know footy? He runs one line, he doesn't pass and his game hasn't developed at all over the years, that's straight from one of the greatest league minds alive today and a guy who loves the rorters. Boyd is an effort guy with not much in arsenal besides trying hard. But yeah its only dumb fans that don't rate him. Chooks fans lol.

Phil Gould signed Tamou to a massive long term deal.

Clearly, he doesn't know everything.

Also his comments were clearly an intended rev up. But that probably went over your head.

 

[Tommy Smith]

He is shit this year. You think Phil Gould doesn't know footy? He runs one line, he doesn't pass and his game hasn't developed at all over the years, that's straight from one of the greatest league minds alive today and a guy who loves the rorters. Boyd is an effort guy with not much in arsenal besides trying hard. But yeah its only dumb fans that don't rate him. Chooks fans are the only ones who still think he is elite.

And you're right it is only dumb fans that don't rate him.

All the minds at the selection table clearly rate him very highly.

But betcats knows better right? Oh dear. That's vanity.

 

[betcats]

And you're right it is only dumb fans that don't rate him.

All the minds at the selection table clearly rate him very highly.

But betcats knows better right? Oh dear. That's vanity.

I'd back Goulds opinion over the selection panel every day of the week. But tommy knows better right? Lol you muppet. Freddy is a former roosters captain he got boyd in there obviously.

 

[betcats]

Phil Gould signed Tamou to a massive long term deal.

Clearly, he doesn't know everything.

Also his comments were clearly an intended rev up. But that probably went over your head.

Yeah signing tamou has really hurt Penrith, look at us struggle away in the top four with 5 or 6 regulars missing.

No it wasn't a rev up, it was far to personal and specific to be a rev up. It was a genuine opinion, Gus did not think he deserved to be selected. But hey Tommy knows better than Gus right? lol.

 

[MrBlack]

If all 3 are on the field together, the 2019 comp will be as good as over by mid season.

They are now favorites for the May Premiership 2019

 

[David brown]

Considering my Mother is currently in hospital and is deathly ill, that's not a good line to use thanks

I apologise mate.. Hope things work out for the best..

 

[Valheru]

Who hasn't carved up for Australia? Its nearly impossible to suck when your team are $1.01 favorites for every match.

If you can't find where he has been an elite 2nd rower over 138 NRL games from 2013 then I can't help you.

It's why he was the Roos first forward picked and MotM in that World Cup final.

Penrith fans like to pretend that didn't happen. There is something not right with that bunch.

He is shit this year.

He is currently leading the Roosters player of the year tally on the roosters sub forum (as of end of round 10)

 

[Lambretta]

He is shit this year. You think Phil Gould doesn't know footy? He runs one line, he doesn't pass and his game hasn't developed at all over the years, that's straight from one of the greatest league minds alive today and a guy who loves the rorters. Boyd is an effort guy with not much in arsenal besides trying hard. But yeah its only dumb fans that don't rate him. Chooks fans are the only ones who still think he is elite.

"I love all this talk about lines" - Andrew Johns (allegedly........ probably not)

 

[Lambretta]

I want to see a thread about what Trent Robinson will do when Cooper Cronk decides to make the move to second row - I mean I understand the comp will be over before it's begun, that goes without saying

But what does Trent think?

 

[betcats]

"I love all this talk about lines" - Andrew Johns (allegedly........ probably not)

Well played.