The Game 2021 Judiciary Charges

[guyver78]

No shock one bit

If that was Sam Burgess today, 3 weeks guaranteed..

 

[fourplay]

Of course they let the golden boy off.

Hands between the players legs: Ignored
Player passed the horizontal: Ignored
Player landed forcefully: Ignored
Dangerous and careless: Ignored
It's Nathan Cleary and it's grand final week: Taken into consideration.


If it was any other player it would have been a suspension. If it was reviewed as if it was Jack Hetherington in round 6 it would have got a few weeks minimum.

 

[guyver78]

Of course they let the golden boy off.

Hands between the players legs: Ignored
Player passed the horizontal: Ignored
Player landed forcefully: Ignored
Dangerous and careless: Ignored
It's Nathan Cleary and it's grand final week: Taken into consideration.


If it was any other player it would have been a suspension. If it was reviewed as if it was Jack Hetherington in round 6 it would have got a few weeks minimum.

100%

 

[wittyfan]

Lol! What a surprise that Crater Face is allowed to play!

 

[Bazal]

The number of people fooled by Kenny's acting is testament to his dramatic ability lol

His feet went up in the air but he landed square on his back. Grade one.

 

[Vic Mackey]

There was nothing in the Cleary tackle, however to me it looked identical to the Aloiai one. I don’t understand how one can be charged but the other let go?

 

[guyver78]

The number of people fooled by Kenny's acting is testament to his dramatic ability lol

His feet went up in the air but he landed square on his back. Grade one.

He wasn’t even charged at all though which is why a lot of people were baffled

 

[guyver78]

There was nothing in the Cleary tackle, however to me it looked identical to the Aloiai one. I don’t understand how one can be charged but the other let go?

Aloiai and Cleary should have both received nothing but yeah 1 is facing a suspension of 4 weeks and 1 is free to play

 

[Diesel]

As long as they’re consistent then it’s fine. But there is a group of players, each year, about 5 of them that get away with a lot more. Those 5 or so do change but it’s whoever is the media darlings at the time

 

[Babyface O'reilly]

There was nothing in the Cleary tackle, however to me it looked identical to the Aloiai one. I don’t understand how one can be charged but the other let go?

That’s pretty much been footy since V’landys took over

 

[Vic Mackey]

Aloiai and Cleary should have both received nothing but yeah 1 is facing a suspension of 4 weeks and 1 is free to play

Exactly, I’d rather they both get 0. They were good tackles that went slightly wrong, however both landed on their backs so no harm done.

3-4 weeks difference is beyond laughable

 

[Diesel]

Is it a fine or 1 week unless it’s challenged? I think he’s got loading too so it would be a trip to the judiciary. Two ex-Panthers and one NSW Origin great on the panel

Edit: just saw he got off. No problem with that call

 

[guyver78]

Is it a fine or 1 week unless it’s challenged? I think he’s got loading too so it would be a trip to the judiciary. Two ex-Panthers and one NSW Origin great on the panel

Edit: just saw he got off. No problem with that call

I don’t either but if you’re going to suspend others why should he play next week? They robbed Isaac Luke in 2014

 

[Maximus]

They’re off their heads lol
above the horizontal, forceful and the guy lands on the back of his neck.

No he didn't. He landed on his back and then his head bounced onto the ground.

 

[Maximus]

Exactly, I’d rather they both get 0. They were good tackles that went slightly wrong, however both landed on their backs so no harm done.

3-4 weeks difference is beyond laughable

Aloiai should really only have been a grade 1 as Nicholls landed shoulder first. With Cleary first point of contact was his back, so no charge would be fine then.

Wouldn't Aloiai only be facing 2 weeks though if not for prior charges.

 

[Someguy]

I am fine with Cleary not missing a game but surely it’s a grade 1 charge, just like his shoulder charge a few weeks ago.

We are seeing players cop big suspensions due to having prior offences. Seems pointless to hold priors against someone when others just don’t get those low grades charged against them.

 

[yobbo84]

Grade 1, a fine, surely was all they had to do to keep everyone happy.

 

[skeepe]

The bigger joke is JFH only copping a fine for a head slam. That’s a far more dangerous tackle than what golden chin did, and he gets a slap on the wrist.

 

[forby]

Did Munster or Grant get charged?

 

[guyver78]

The bigger joke is JFH only copping a fine for a head slam. That’s a far more dangerous tackle than what golden chin did, and he gets a slap on the wrist.

You reckon?