Team list Tuesday - Round 11 vs Manly

[I'm a loser baby...]

*Kakatoa

 

[hindy111]

Russell in for Simonssen and Sivo in for Perham.

Simmonson defense is good. He won't be dropped. Russels proven not much yet. He will gave to wait for injuries.

 

[The Predictor]

Somebody tell me why Oregan is a permanent fixture this year, considering he is gone, and playing shit?

 

[Gronk]

So why even pick him in the 17 then?

When ? Who else was available that day ?

 

[King-Gutho94]

Gutho?

Yeah Gutho signed a 2 year extension in April 2015 with Manly. After he did is ACL.

Manly re-sign trio, close in on Elgey

Manly is closing in on Titans playmaker Kane Elgey after re-signing Tom and Jake Trbojevic and Clint Gutherson.

www.abc.net.au

5 months later Barrett was appointed and one of his first moves as coach was to get rid of Gutho.

By November 2015 Gutho was with the Eels.

 

[Gronk]

Unlike you to misrepresent what someone was saying...

I did nothing of the sort. Lingard was claiming that when BA was forced to pick Carty because of injuries, that was wasn't given a fair go and that has eroded the guy's confidence.

Carty is not a teenager. He's an experienced NRL player and knows what it takes to be an NRL player. Facts are that if we had a full roster he wouldn't have been picked. Same goes with Rein. Both were bought as fill-ins, outside the top 17 by far.

Why sign him ? Because we need 30 players and might need to use them subject to injuries.

 

[Happy MEel]

Ok so we agree that there is no place for him.

Sorry but I don't buy your chicken vs egg justification with Carty. When you are in a roster of 30, you need to make a compelling argument to be selected. That includes your training, personal preparation and hitting any benchmarks that are given to you.

Somehow you are suggesting that he should get a spot without earning it ?

Well he wouldn’t be the first.

 

[TheParraboy]

I hope we win whoever Manlys 17 are..

 

[hineyrulz]

Well he wouldn’t be the first.

Hmmmmmmm, and who could that be

 

[I'm a loser baby...]

I did nothing of the sort. Lingard was claiming that when BA was forced to pick Carty because of injuries, that was wasn't given a fair go and that has eroded the guy's confidence.

Carty is not a teenager. He's an experienced NRL player and knows what it takes to be an NRL player. Facts are that if we had a full roster he wouldn't have been picked. Same goes with Rein. Both were bought as fill-ins, outside the top 17 by far.

Why sign him ? Because we need 30 players and might need to use them subject to injuries.

Complete revisionist bullshit. Lingard suggested he should have been given time in games which you turned into him claiming he should have been given a spot he didn't deserve.

 

[hindy111]

Makatoa

Agree. We have 4 x middles on the bench. Yes Marata can cover 2nd row. But Bryce is a better player then Makatoa.

 

[hindy111]

Ok so we agree that there is no place for him.

Sorry but I don't buy your chicken vs egg justification with Carty. When you are in a roster of 30, you need to make a compelling argument to be selected. That includes your training, personal preparation and hitting any benchmarks that are given to you.

Somehow you are suggesting that he should get a spot without earning it ?

All up played about 85mins. Has 3 LBAS and 2 x TAs. Tackling at 94%
I'd be prepared to give him a better run. Makatoa is a huge plodder. Yes he does a job. BUT WITH BROWN,MARATA AND KAFUSI on the bench not needed.

 

[hindy111]

AND Hindy111 does it again. Was it not I who was calling for Brown to be dropped to the bench and start Matterson? Then the peanuts come and threw bullshit stats at me.
Well look what BA has done now?

Carry on people.

 

[The Predictor]

Agree. We have 4 x middles on the bench. Yes Marata can cover 2nd row. But Bryce is a better player then Makatoa.

 

[lingard]

Ok so we agree that there is no place for him.

Sorry but I don't buy your chicken vs egg justification with Carty. When you are in a roster of 30, you need to make a compelling argument to be selected. That includes your training, personal preparation and hitting any benchmarks that are given to you.

Somehow you are suggesting that he should get a spot without earning it ?

Not at all. I'm simply making the observation that when you have an erratic player like Cartwright (who looks to me like 'confidence' player) it doesn't seem to make a lot of sense to sit him on the bench and give him hardly any game-time. It seems counter-intuitive to me.

 

[lingard]

AND Hindy111 does it again. Was it not I who was calling for Brown to be dropped to the bench and start Matterson? Then the peanuts come and threw bullshit stats at me.
Well look what BA has done now?

Carry on people.

Are you boasting that a bald dick-head, who has under-achieved for ten years, bases his selection decisions on your thinking?

 

[Gazzamatta]

I see we have no need for a back on the bench this week just in case of injury.
So who plays half if we lose Moses or Drown I wonder?

 

[strider]

AND Hindy111 does it again. Was it not I who was calling for Brown to be dropped to the bench and start Matterson? Then the peanuts come and threw bullshit stats at me.
Well look what BA has done now?

Carry on people.

Hail hindy. Hail the great man!!!

 

[hineyrulz]

AND Hindy111 does it again. Was it not I who was calling for Brown to be dropped to the bench and start Matterson? Then the peanuts come and threw bullshit stats at me.
Well look what BA has done now?

Carry on people.

Cough cough i said the same as well.


Hiney/Hindy combo>>>>>>>>>>>> Gronky poo.

 

[hineyrulz]

I see we have no need for a back on the bench this week just in case of injury.
So who plays half if we lose Moses or Drown I wonder?

OMG what will happen if we looooooose a half??? Wot will we do???