What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Sack the whole team thread

Messages
2,640
For me, this week is the most important of our season, not even the game next weekend but the week of prep leading up to it. Clearly something has gone wrong over the last month or so and it needs to be rectified immediately before our season is on life support.

AOB needs to sit them all down in a room and do a good old fashioned honesty session. Get it all out there and then hit the training paddock with renewed vigour. He probably needs to send a message and drop an experienced player or two to get a response. Although I’m not sure who he can drop given our current situation with injuries.

I honestly think our season is on the line this week. It doesn’t necessarily mean we have to win next game but we can’t turn up and be listless again with the ball in hand.
 

Woody90

Bench
Messages
3,789
There is a deep, deep rot at the club. Leaders have to take responsibility for it, both on and off the field.

Problem is we don’t have any leaders.

The closest seem to be Lucas and Elliott and we’re planning on getting rid of one of them.
 

Alex28

Coach
Messages
12,253
Gagai and Friz are both past it if we are being honest.

Lucas, KPP and Elliott makes a great back row. The depth is an issue - I think Cant can be a really good player - his defence is an issue…
 

Old dog

Bench
Messages
2,827
Gagai and Friz are both past it if we are being honest.

Lucas, KPP and Elliott makes a great back row. The depth is an issue - I think Cant can be a really good player - his defence is an issue…
Not confirmed but Cant had high tackle count but I don’t think he is regular 1st grader
 

macavity

Referee
Messages
21,084
Is Dylan Lucas actually that important to us in both attack and defence?

we were missing Lucas, Saf, Elliott and Heatho from the pack.

The kids trying to step up were physically dominated and Tyrone is so far off the pace conditioning wise it’s embarrassing for all of Rugby Union.

Our depth in the forwards is truly awful.

Schiller was a big loss too, mostly because Marz tried to pick up the donkey work slack and has hands like flippers.
 

Knight Tales

Bench
Messages
3,421
I want some angry people playing for this club. We are injury riddled in the worst spot. Our pack. But none can come in and just physically make a problem of themselves for opponents. Royce Hunt types. Limited ability but are not afraid to get in and cause chaos.
 
Messages
2,640
I want some angry people playing for this club. We are injury riddled in the worst spot. Our pack. But none can come in and just physically make a problem of themselves for opponents. Royce Hunt types. Limited ability but are not afraid to get in and cause chaos.
Wasn’t Hetherington sort of supposed to be that (albeit with more talent?) but he’s basically just an error/penalty machine.
 

Knight Tales

Bench
Messages
3,421
A big side across the park who just wants to physically run over opponents would be a big success in Newcastle. The Sharks squad would be an enormous hit here with Newy jersey on. You cannot keep sides like that quiet for 80 mins. They are simply too big and powerful. Errors are their main downfall. If AOB wants a direct low risk attack, and low error count, he has to have the side to make it work. we are simply too small to do it on a dominant level. You have to be able to constantly punch holes to create space with our style. Our backs are strong. The forwards seem to work completely seperate to one another.
 

Alex28

Coach
Messages
12,253
This in Danny Weidler’s column today in smh:

Rugby league’s most exciting attacking weapon Kalyn Ponga is being stymied by a player feud that is making it impossible to pick one of the Knights’ big-name playmakers.

Newcastle’s stuttering attack is one of the talking points of the league, as is their persistent swapping of halves. An obvious solution to their problems, purely on the playing front, would be the selection of Jackson Hastings, who has previously helped bring Ponga to life.

However, Hastings appears to be the last person the Knights would pick to play first grade, and it has been difficult to work out why he is on the outer.

This column has been made aware of a falling out largely between one of the team’s leaders and Hastings. The matter relates to their wives not seeing eye to eye over a comment Hastings’ partner made. As a consequence, the player has told people at the club of his feelings and the club has backed one of their most respected players.

The club has knowledge of the dispute but says that is not why Hastings is being left out of the team.

That is difficult to accept given the halves crisis.

There have been other minor issues with Hastings, but it seems that one is the most difficult for the club to overcome. The result is the Knights’ best halfback, who is paid about $800,000 this year, has not been given a chance in the top grade by coach Adam O’Brien.

It’s an ugly situation and this column is not aware of attempts to resolve it, but if the Knights’ season continues to spiral out of control, and they continue to struggle to score points, it may have to be addressed. Especially now it is in the public domain.

There are also growing concerns about Hastings’ welfare. Expect this to become an issue.

This column has been told that a handful of players have made the case for Hastings to be selected, to put the team first before personality clashes.

This column is aware that Hastings has had issues at other clubs. I also have not been told exactly what happened between the players’ partners, so I can’t comment on whether the matter can be resolved. But we do know Hastings isn’t being selected, and the impact it’s having on the team.

Not many people outside the Knights are aware of this issue, and it was interesting to hear the club’s greatest player, Andrew Johns, calling for Hastings to be reinstated to the first grade side.

I assume Johns is not aware of the issue, but he made the following comments in a Sydney Morning Herald subscribers newsletter about the Knights and Hastings.

“Whatever faults he’s got as a player, Jackson will get them around the field,” Johns said. “His kicking game is up there with one of the best. I don’t know what’s happened there, but I don’t see Tyson Gamble as a halfback. He’s a good club five-eighth, but I don’t see him as a week in, week out halfback option.”

When asked about potential issues with senior players, Johns said: “For the good of the team, you have to put that aside. That’s a job of whoever is within the club. Whether it’s the CEO or someone else, you’ve got to get them all together and sort it out. The attack has been dull and they haven’t looked like penetrating defences.

“Everyone knows if Kalyn isn’t firing, then the Knights are pretty easy to handle.”

*****

This explains a fair bit. FFS, if the guys are getting mixed up in the issues of the Real Housewives of Newcastle, the leadership needs some serious shaking up - top to bottom.
 
Top