Penrith Panthers Rd 1 2010 Team

[Fibroman]

Maybe we need to start grooming Coote for the halves? Just a thought......

 

[franklin2323]

Josh Hannay isn't on the list according to Andrew Farrell over at PI.

Ok well Blair in centres and Paulo on the bench then

 

[Panthers_God]

1.Coote
2. We desperately need a quality winger...
3.Jennings
4.Lewis
5.Gordon
6.Graham
7.Walsh
8.Civenocieva
9.Romelo
10.Puletua
11.Waterhouse
12.Pritchard
13.Cooper

14.Iosefa
15.Laurie
16.Bell
17.Blair

 

[Pantha-Boy]

Now I can do a better team we have signed 4 more players And Hannay to come

Coote
Gordon
Jennings
Hannay Coming
Tighe
Graham
Walsh
Petero
Romelo
Bell
Waterhouse
Cooper
Lewis

Sammut
Blair/Paulo
Laurie
Pritchard

Depth is alot stronger with more options waiting better balanced plenty of impact with Laurie and Pritchard off the bench Plum is Good because he is a different style so good as a option.

Still plenty of workhorse now impact players coming looks better

Franklin you are a deadset twit. Firstly Hannay? Even if we did sign him he is hopeless. Sammut in the team? Seriously you must'nt have watched a game all year. Paulo? *edit*...Hopeless.

COOPER STARTING OVER PRITCHARD! YOU ARE A GALLOOT.

Seriously....

 

[murraymob]

Franklin you are a deadset twit. Firstly Hannay? Even if we did sign him he is hopeless. Sammut in the team? Seriously you must'nt have watched a game all year. Paulo? *edit*...Hopeless.

COOPER STARTING OVER PRITCHARD! YOU ARE A GALLOOT.

Seriously....

pantha boy you need to stop bagging our team with racist remarks its wearing pretty thin.It is one thing to bag a players ability but you are going way to far

 

[*Sandy*]

No more derogatory comments Pantha Boy or I will gag you for good.

And to everyone else, use your damn brains and don't quote comments that are derogatory. It just makes extra work for me. :crazy:

 

[mean_maori_mean]

Franklin you are a deadset twit. Firstly Hannay? Even if we did sign him he is hopeless. Sammut in the team? Seriously you must'nt have watched a game all year. Paulo? *edit*...Hopeless.

COOPER STARTING OVER PRITCHARD! YOU ARE A GALLOOT.

Seriously....

your certainly right with Hannay. Never was a highly talented players simply compentent - I dont see him being any better than what Cooper would offer at centre.

Same with sammut - I believe he could go well if the team has good structure and is firing but when they are struggling he simply digs himself a bigger hole.

Pritchard - needs to get fit bigtime. I would have him on the bench too.

Paulo - certainly not useless. He has plenty of talent however he needs to stay in one position and develop his game.

But seriously Elliot & some senior management need to go. simmons /elford and now hannay.

Who in there right mind - that right there means you a destined for mediocrity.

All those talented youngsters have you have to buy old hacks for outside backs.

Did watch them this year but pensese, sene-lenefao have FG written all over them.

 

[franklin2323]

Franklin you are a deadset twit. Firstly Hannay? Even if we did sign him he is hopeless. Sammut in the team? Seriously you must'nt have watched a game all year. Paulo? *edit*...Hopeless.

COOPER STARTING OVER PRITCHARD! YOU ARE A GALLOOT.

Seriously....

haha. Ok we need size in the outside backs Blair or Hannay have to shield Walsh in defence.

Sammut's best game of the year was against the Titans as interchange Hooker!

Cooper is good in defence. Pritchard is wasted making tackle early on. Breaks USUALLY get made as the 1/2 moves on. So he has his best performance later in the halves think how much damage he and Laurie will do as the game wears on.

As for Paulo he was decent this year compare him with Smith, Grant, McKendry. He held his own this year he is being converted to a prop give him an off-season under his belt and he will be better off.

If we sign someone better put them in

 

[age.s]

1. Coote
2. Tighe (improved alot 2nd half of this season)
3. Jennings
4. Gordon
5. Signing/McFadgeon/Simmons/Elford
6. Graham
7. Walsh
8. Petero
9. Romelo
10. Signing(still hopeful)/Bell
11. House
12. Plum
13. Lewis

14. Blair (Sammut if Romelo isn't up for the full 90)
15. Laurie
16. Pritchard
17. Bell/Grant

 

[Sleep]

After our recent signings...

1. Coote
2. Gordon
3. Jennings
4. Blair
5. Tighe
6. Graham
7. Walsh
8. Civoniceva
9. Iosefa
10. Puletua
11. Waterhouse
12. Pritchard
13. Lewis

14. Bell
15. Plum
16. Grant
17. Romelo

And I think Hannay would be a good signing. Low risk, possibly high reward. I read somewhere too that we were linked to Ray Cashmere. He'd be a great signing for us. I'd start him along side Petero. He was outstanding for the Cowboys in his last season there.

 

[Halycon]

I'd like to see something like this...

1. Coote
2. Gordon
3. Jennings
4. Lewis
5. Tighe
6. Graham
7. Walsh
8. Civ
9. Isofea
10. Puletua
11. Waterhouse
12. Pritchard
13. Cooper

14. Sammut (i'd like to see him play hooker off the bench)
15. Laurie/Grant
16. Bell
17. Plum

 

[franklin2323]

I'd like to see something like this...

1. Coote
2. Gordon
3. Jennings
4. Lewis
5. Tighe
6. Graham
7. Walsh
8. Civ
9. Isofea
10. Puletua
11. Waterhouse
12. Pritchard
13. Cooper

14. Sammut (i'd like to see him play hooker off the bench)
15. Laurie/Grant
16. Bell
17. Plum

At first I was against Lewis in the centre's now with our lack of recruiting a decent centre we may need him. He would create something other then this years plan of just giving it to Jennings to do something.

But the downside we would miss his defence around the ruck and wouldn't get enough ball. but need 10 or so tries from our other centre so maybe

 

[murraymob]

Romelo has to be in any starting side.It was clear back end of the year we where soft .No fire no balls.Our options to change that will not come from any of the players who played those final games .Romelo and plum give us some hitting power in defence

 

[Panthers_God]

At first I was against Lewis in the centre's now with our lack of recruiting a decent centre we may need him. He would create something other then this years plan of just giving it to Jennings to do something.

But the downside we would miss his defence around the ruck and wouldn't get enough ball. but need 10 or so tries from our other centre so maybe

We wont miss his defense. I don't think he did a very good job defending in the ruck. Made some poor decisions defensively in the last few rounds. He is naturally a back, always played as a back, never would we have defended in the middle of the ruck before this year. He wastes energy on defence, we need him for attack. Stick him out in the centres where he belongs.

 

[umina panther]

We wont miss his defense. I don't think he did a very good job defending in the ruck. Made some poor decisions defensively in the last few rounds. He is naturally a back, always played as a back, never would we have defended in the middle of the ruck before this year. He wastes energy on defence, we need him for attack. Stick him out in the centres where he belongs.

Lewis would have went close to winning the dally m if he didnt get hurt stop moving the bloke around all the time

 

[murraymob]

we have a load of back rowers next year and being serious pritchard unless he shapes up must be struggling to hold a spot in the team
The pritchard lovers will hammer me but less face facts he spends the whole game bludging out wide doing nothing in attack or defence.A re-think is needed on our forwards .We need more forwards getting us rolling up the middle giving room and space for it to get to jennings

 

[stretcher]

I'd like to see something like this...

1. Coote
2. Gordon
3. Jennings
4. Lewis
5. Tighe
6. Graham
7. Walsh
8. Civ
9. Isofea
10. Puletua
11. Waterhouse
12. Pritchard
13. Cooper

14. Sammut (i'd like to see him play hooker off the bench)
15. Laurie/Grant
16. Bell
17. Plum

you have got to be kidding yaself what games have you been watching jarrod sammut is the worst defender in the comp has missed more tackles than anyone else in the comp and thats from fullback and you wana put him at hooker please maybe the reason panthers are struggling is gooses like you must be part of the coaching staff.!!!!sammut holds the record for best in goal defender in the comp......

 

[umina panther]

we have a load of back rowers next year and being serious pritchard unless he shapes up must be struggling to hold a spot in the team
The pritchard lovers will hammer me but less face facts he spends the whole game bludging out wide doing nothing in attack or defence.A re-think is needed on our forwards .We need more forwards getting us rolling up the middle giving room and space for it to get to jennings

i agree mate we have been waiting too long for him to become the player he should be. maybe its best for the club and him if we could trade him or something before the start of next year

 

[Fibroman]

We need to find someone in the mould of Petero or marty Lang. Someone that takes the ball forward with no mistakes and doesn't miss tackles. Someone that gets over the advantage line. That someone is.....................


Blackett.

 

[murraymob]

We need to find someone in the mould of Petero or marty Lang. Someone that takes the ball forward with no mistakes and doesn't miss tackles. Someone that gets over the advantage line. That someone is.....................


Blackett.

is shane even playing next year.He is looking outside of football now