He's definitely not the most in-depth commentator, nor is he the most perplexing one. I see him more of an average day dude who loves his footy. His a big kid when it comes to his passion for the game, he'd run out on field if he could lol.
He does dribble on sometimes but they all do. He is like MG. Love him or hate him, he was a past Australian Captain and has won Origins and Premierships with 2 clubs. Not to mention he was a decent ball runner and play maker towards the end of his career. Remember his step early on at the Panthers? Or his kicking game at the Roosters? He likes the odd drink and can say the wrong thing/do the wrong thing at the wrong time but eh, he's human.
IMO the best commentators are Sterlo, Gus, Rabs, Wazza, Vossy and Brandy. Whilst the short insights from Freddy, Dell & MG are welcomed. I think the Joey Johns should've had some time to clear his head instead of continuing TV media work after his stints in the badside.