What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

South Sydney almost blows it against Manly

Messages
14,937






286581-11-04-01-dylan-farrell.jpg

South Sydney's Dylan Farrell goes over to score his third try against Manly. Picture: Brett Costello Source: The Australian



IT was the performance South Sydney fans had been waiting to see. At least, it was for 71 minutes. The final nine minutes at Bluetongue Stadium last night reminded us why the Rabbitohs are far from the finished article.

When William Hopoate - playing fullback for Manly after Brett Stewart was a late scratching with a hamstring injury - scored with less than two minutes remaining, rookie halfback Daly Cherry-Evans had the chance to send the game to golden point extra-time. His kick sailed to the left of the posts and South Sydney fans raised the roof.
By the time the Rabbitohs had returned to halfway, the siren had sounded. What should have been a convincing win turned into a lucky escape.
For the vast majority of the game, the Rabbitohs looked the better side.
Halfback Chris Sandow, so often the target for the club's passionate supporters, produced the sort of controlled display the Rabbitohs have been crying out for. Centre Greg Inglis was quiet but exploded with one scything run in the second half as winger Nathan Merritt scored two tries in two minutes.
Centre Dylan Farrell scored his second hat-trick in only his ninth first grade game before leaving the game in the 55th minute with a shoulder injury. Everyone contributed on a night when Souths spent 70 minutes showing everyone why it can win a premiership.
Unfortunately for coach John Lang, the Rabbitohs then spent the final nine shambolic minutes showing everyone why a premiership may be beyond their reach.
"I said to the boys, 'I think it's a step in the right direction'," Lang said. "We're not quite finishing them off. I knew they weren't going to put up the white flag when we got the lead."
The sides went tit for tat in the opening 55 minutes, but the game swung the Rabbitohs' way when they crossed for three tries in nine minutes midway through the second half. Until that point, Manly five-eighth Kieran Foran almost single-handedly kept his side in the game.
Souths' lead was out to 18 points after Merritt's two tries, the second backing up an Inglis break, to give his side a 32-14 lead. But nerves started fraying when Manly forward Anthony Watmough was given the benefit of the doubt by video referee Sean Hampstead. After Fetuli Talanoa had a try disallowed for Souths, Manly was within six points with five minutes remaining when winger Michael Oldfield scored. The comeback was complete when Hopoate crossed in the corner, leaving Cherry-Evans with the chance to extend the game.
"Souths were really disciplined in the first half," Manly coach Des Hasler said. "I think that's the best they have played all year. We probably left our run a little late. We're disappointed they put 32 points on us."
Much of the damage was caused by Sandow, who obeyed a pre-game plea from Lang to shed the shoulder charge and put his shoulder to the wheel.
"He's been on fire the last six weeks with his training and preparation," Lang said.
In an exciting opening half of swinging fortunes, no one enjoyed more of a roller-coaster ride then Souths debutant winger Kane Morgan. The 21-year-old had a hand in three tries - two for Souths and one for Manly. He made a dream start in only the eighth minute when he produced a freakish piece of skill to create a try for centre Dylan Farrell.
Six minutes later he undid that good work with a calamitous error. Foran's kick seemed innocuous but Morgan made a hash of it. Fullback Merritt couldn't clean it up either. Jamie Buhrer had the simplest of tasks to open his account for the season and level the scores.
Souths went back in front in the 18th minute after Morgan's piece of freakish skill was matched by big backrower Dave Taylor. The 120kg forward produced a perfectly weighted kick, his touch matched by Talanoa's dexterity as he managed to get the ball down with his legs only millimetres from the sideline.
South Sydney 32 (D Farrell 3 N Merritt 2 F Talanoa tries; I Luke 2 C Sandow 2 goals)
Manly 30 (J Buhrer 2 D Harrison W Hopoate M Oldfield A Watmough tries; D Cherry-Evans 3 goals) at Bluetongue Stadium. Referees: Adam Devcich, Ashley Klein. Crowd: 18,108.


http://www.theaustralian.com.au/new...it-against-manly/story-e6frg7mf-1226032317092
 

boo_boo

Juniors
Messages
1,819
Well any win is a good win.
Sure we have area's to work on but there were positive signs out there last night.
I love it how Greg Inglis is just doing his bit without overplaying his hand.
He is developing combinations with Merrit, Farrell & Sutton & it's all falling into place.
 

Ziggy the God

First Grade
Messages
5,240
It's obvious you won't beat any good teams.
Manly had 7 players unavailable and you still struggled.


Oh right, when we had a ton of injuries in the latter half of 2010, that was just bad luck on our behalf apparently.

Burgess, Geddes, Lowe, Wesser and Clarke from our side.
Two rookies also blooded.

Oh yeah, it is Round 4, not Round 26.

Buuuuurp.
 
Messages
203
I think we where exposed with our young rookies as Manly where hammering them all night we needed a backrower to help with the defence with them. Sandow had a blinder I thought Merrit at fullback was what we needed back there and must stay there.

Stand And Be Counted
View attachment 3104
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,789
It's obvious you won't beat any good teams.
Manly had 7 players unavailable and you still struggled.
How many players did Newcastle have unavailable plus the long line of players they got injured during the game and Manly didnt dominate like they should have.

And it's not like we didn't have our own injuries. 2 on debut, our best forward gone. Imagine if you replaced whoever was our worst forward last night with the worlds best forward. Yeah exactly.

I think we where exposed with our young rookies as Manly where hammering them all night we needed a backrower to help with the defence with them. Sandow had a blinder I thought Merrit at fullback was what we needed back there and must stay there.

Stand And Be Counted
View attachment 3104
Morgan did look like a rookie, but a bloody talented rookie. And he'll be better when Burgess comes back on that side. Burgess-Farrell-Morgan could be our right flank for the next 10 years. Farrell and Morgan already look like they have chemistry.
 

BunniesMan

Immortal
Messages
33,789
And another bright sign from last nights game, how impressive was Ben Ross? In the first game of the season he was regularly going backwards in a tackle, last night he made heaps of penetrating runs with at least 1 defender bouncing off him each time. And at the money we have him (near the minimum) with that kind of play he's great value.
 

Galeforce

Bench
Messages
2,602
it is going to be a long heart filled roller coaster based on the first 4 games. We are 2-2 , could have been 4-0 and could have been 1-3, with only eels game clear cut.
We definitely outplayed Manly for most of game , however scoreboard almost beat us ,like it did in our first two games , the last 5 minutes in those games have cost us two tries in each of those games.
Lang has to study these games and focus the team on controlled play to maintain the ball and suffocate the opposing teams preferable in their own quarterlines.

We should have gone for a field goal play instead of the risky Talonoa play which yielded nil points and ball back to Manly . Lang must also address our structure to accept balls from kickoffs.

Merrit in my mind displayed had a better fullback game than Wesser and should get the nod.
I like Mcqueen , he is a winger once we get our forwards back and he showed he has a good step , good speed and good size for defense. He is my preferred winger to replace Merritt , followed by Kane. Clear that Manly targetted Kane's side with success and they scored 12 points there , dropped ball and charge.
Asotasi and Luke Stuart had very solid games , well supported by Ross , happy with our props.
Sandow was outstanding , NO mistakes in my mind , showed great defense and a good kicking game. He could be in line for a Qld origin call up if he continues that performance as a back up to thurstan.
Farrell much improved game , hope he recovers quickly from the shoulder injury.
Sutton , Luke, Taylor , Inglis all had steady games showing some glimpses and clearly improvement to come.
Very happy that we got the 2 points , showed flashes of great attack ability and clearly have areas for the coach to focus the team on . We can build momentum as we march towards a top 4 in 2011.
 

JetRider

Juniors
Messages
326
It's obvious you won't beat any good teams.
Manly had 7 players unavailable and you still struggled.

What and Souths did not have any first team members out??? 5 for us as well and we still had enough to beat Manly who were made to look better than they were.
 

BranVan3000

Coach
Messages
12,297
5 out and lost two in the dying moments of the game, which not coincidentally is where the final try was scored
 

Mattyoh

Juniors
Messages
115
Oh right, when we had a ton of injuries in the latter half of 2010, that was just bad luck on our behalf apparently.

Burgess, Geddes, Lowe, Wesser and Clarke from our side.
Two rookies also blooded.

Oh yeah, it is Round 4, not Round 26.

Buuuuurp.


You forgot Pettybourne
 

Mattyoh

Juniors
Messages
115
Am I the only one worried about Farrell's defence?

I know he scored three tries but he is a liability. The opposition will be attacking our right side all season long and with much success. I had high hopes for the kid but I think he is a marshmellow.
 

boo_boo

Juniors
Messages
1,819
Time will tell Mattyoh.
He has only paid a handfull of NRL games so dont write him off yet.
 

hindyrabbit

Juniors
Messages
226
farrell will get better in defence the kid can tackle. its he's reading of the play thats letting him down.

my problem is the benefit of the doubt rule. is this just used so refs have an excuse with the decision?
watmough didn't look like he had downward pressure and i'm unsure how the ball went backwards.
i'm happy with the way the side played commited for 71 minutes but the few injuries at the end did almost cost us, looking forward to next week to see if sandow can put back to back controlled performances
 
Top