Worst player to have won a premiership?

[Son of Minto]

Daniel Fitzhenry

 

[adamkungl]

Daniel Fitzhenry

/thread

 

[orochimaru]

clint newton

 

[East Coast Tiger]

What I think is a more interesting questions is, which player won a premiership but played the least amount of first grade games? There is bound to be some blokes who played only a handful of first grade games in their career yet managed to jag a spot in a grand final side that won. And I'm not talking about union converts in the early days or blokes who came from the old BRL who were essentially first graders but in a different comp. I mean blokes who got promoted from reggies for a few games but just happened to do it at the right time.

 

[Ausguy]

Benji Marshall

 

[some11]

What I think is a more interesting questions is, which player won a premiership but played the least amount of first grade games? There is bound to be some blokes who played only a handful of first grade games in their career yet managed to jag a spot in a grand final side that won.

Will Hopoate? Played only 19 games and played State of Origin... what a waste of talent to leave.

 

[Lambretta]

2002 Premiership game had Andrew Lomu (replaced Kidwell who was unavailable) on for the Roosters and Mark Tookey on for the Warriors

That's a pile of shite on both sides

 

[FiTzHaNrY_FaN]

Daniel Fitzhenry

shut up u twat

/thread

u too

 

[CrazyTiger]

Benji Marshall

Andrew Ettingshausen

 

[East Coast Tiger]

Will Hopoate? Played only 19 games and played State of Origin... what a waste of talent to leave.

Yeah but his career isn't over.

There was a bloke in the Bulldogs side in 1985 that i found that only played 11 games.

 

[thorson1987]

Andrew Ettingshausen

And when the f**k did ET win a premiership.

And some_11 beat me to it except I was goin to say finch.

 

[gypsy]

shut up u twat



u too

You can't be that big of a Fitzhenry fan if you can't spell his name.

The correct answer is Jamie Buhrer.

 

[CrazyTiger]

And when the f**k did ET win a premiership.

And some_11 beat me to it except I was goin to say finch.

Oh fu@#ck, my bad, Cronulla has never won a premiership.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Fitzhenry by a mile, although he did a few decent things in the GF

 

[Brutus]

What I think is a more interesting questions is, which player won a premiership but played the least amount of first grade games? There is bound to be some blokes who played only a handful of first grade games in their career yet managed to jag a spot in a grand final side that won. And I'm not talking about union converts in the early days or blokes who came from the old BRL who were essentially first graders but in a different comp. I mean blokes who got promoted from reggies for a few games but just happened to do it at the right time.

John Rheinberger wins that award hands down.

His one and only first grade game was the Roosters' 1975 Grand Final win over the Dragons (38-0).

 

[Loudstrat]

What I think is a more interesting questions is, which player won a premiership but played the least amount of first grade games? There is bound to be some blokes who played only a handful of first grade games in their career yet managed to jag a spot in a grand final side that won. And I'm not talking about union converts in the early days or blokes who came from the old BRL who were essentially first graders but in a different comp. I mean blokes who got promoted from reggies for a few games but just happened to do it at the right time.

Easy. John Rheinberger, Easts 1975 GF - his only first grade match.

 

[KiamaSaint]

Snap!

 

[CrazyTiger]

Easy. John Rheinberger, Easts 1975 GF - his only first grade match.

Loudy, I thought you cracked it, and had taken your wooden spoon and gone home til next year.

 

[Fufu Andronez]

Jarrod Saffy!

 

[KiamaSaint]

Jarrod Saffy!

He was very good in the gf.