7 tackle try - NQ dudded again!

[Ronnie Dobbs]

Refs are incompetent. Can't really blame them. The whole game is Mickey Mouse bullshit.

 

[Bretto]

I wont comment on the incident,as a cows fan I was glad for the extra week that was a longshot 2 months ago.
My beef is the refs .
Anderson you brainless f**ktard ,go & watch any JRL game & watch how 1 ref keeps it simple & game flows.

Easily fixed at NRL level(Jesus a Pom can come over & ref a test all by himself) & the game is fine.
Simplify the ruck ,forget the surrender/dominant or anything else you can think of.
Call HELD/TACKLED & OFF .If they don't get off penalise them .
Will fix the wrestling/holding down problem.

Don't call players out for offside..Penalise them .You are taught in under 7 to get back onside.
You dimwits are out there to REF games not coach grown men,& if they are too stupid to get back 10 then do your job.
Go back to One ref,i believe the game flows more & it would be a massive help if the touchies actually did their job.

Like. Go back to 1 ref. Games in the QLD Cup flow very nicely with 1 ref.

 

[Dave_]

Dave is a hater lmfao

Not at all. If the Sharkies had won the game fair and square I'm happy for them. The thing I don't like is Sharks fans acting like they deserved the victory and telling Cowboys fans they had all game to bounce back like it's their own fault they didn't win.

Simple fact is the game was won by 2 points. Take the dud call out of the game and the Cows win. There's not that much to be proud of for Sharks fans. Just remember your team shouldn't even be there.

 

[Ziggy the God]

Aah no, that's not what I said nor implied anything like that, and you know it.

Souffs fans and chips on their shoulders.
TRULY AMAZING.

Don't get upset when your bias is pointed out, this isn't the first time.

A seven tackle try is different to interpretations, as the former is a clear mistake.

Like the Slater no try and the Tupou 'push' the prior week. Or Burgess getting binned vs Maloney staying on the field last night for doing the same.

You see what you want in these situations, but we all know what you will point out.

 

[Helmet Man]

Matty Bowen deserved more. Disgraceful the refs are. How can they let something this big slip away?

Cows fans right now would be furious. I would be. Ironically if the refs were doing there job properly throughout the whole season then the Titans would have made the 8, not the Cows.

So Cowboys fan should be a little happy that incompetent reffing got them to the finals in the first place. But karma acts geniusedly sometimes

 

[Eion]

Simple fact is the game was won by 2 points. Take the dud call out of the game and the Cows win. There's not that much to be proud of for Sharks fans. Just remember your team shouldn't even be there.

Good point. I'm not going to even bother watching next week. Those sharkies can get f**ked because the refs can't count.

 

[Canard]

Matty Bowen deserved more. Disgraceful the refs are. How can they let something this big slip away?

Cows fans right now would be furious. I would be. Ironically if the refs were doing there job properly throughout the whole season then the Titans would have made the 8, not the Cows.

So Cowboys fan should be a little happy that incompetent reffing got them to the finals in the first place. But karma acts geniusedly sometimes

Yes because only your club was dudded during the season nobody else was....

 

[Pig Champion]

Not at all. If the Sharkies had won the game fair and square I'm happy for them. The thing I don't like is Sharks fans acting like they deserved the victory and telling Cowboys fans they had all game to bounce back like it's their own fault they didn't win.

Simple fact is the game was won by 2 points. Take the dud call out of the game and the Cows win. There's not that much to be proud of for Sharks fans. Just remember your team shouldn't even be there.

So Dave, you think that had only 6 tackles been called at that moment instead, nothing else in the game would have changed in the next 70 or so minutes? Once something changes there are infinite possibilities.

If it occurred in the last 2 minutes to give the sharks a 2 point win then yes it would have definitely been the reason on team won and one team lost.

 

[Canard]

So the message from LU is , Dud calls don't matter unless its in the last 2 mins of the game.

Glad that is sorted out now.

 

[Miller was a legend]

Dud calls matter and the officials should pay the price. Not our supporters.

 

[DC_fan]

So the message from LU is , Dud calls don't matter unless its in the last 2 mins of the game.

Glad that is sorted out now.

David Smith and the NRL will be very happy to hear that

 

[KeepingTheFaith]

Simple fact is the game was won by 2 points. Take the dud call out of the game and the Cows win. There's not that much to be proud of for Sharks fans. Just remember your team shouldn't even be there.

No.

The break that led to the try was the sixth tackle, if they had known that it would've been a kick, so already that's changed. From there the entire game changes. You can't just say that the Sharks lose six points and the remaining 50-60 minutes of the game remain the same.

The call was bad, but in the end it wasn't the winning and losing of the game. To say there's nothing for the Sharks to be proud of and they shouldn't even be there is pretty sad.

 

[Pig Champion]

So the message from LU is , Dud calls don't matter unless its in the last 2 mins of the game.

Glad that is sorted out now.

No the message is all outcomes are affected by any decision, change the decision and you change the outcome but not necessarily the way you assume. However in the final moments of a match there is no time afterwards for it to alter. Easy.

 

[Pig Champion]

No.

The break that led to the try was the sixth tackle, if they had known that it would've been a kick, so already that's changed. From there the entire game changes. You can't just say that the Sharks lose six points and the remaining 50-60 minutes of the game remain the same.

The call was bad, but in the end it wasn't the winning and losing of the game. To say there's nothing for the Sharks to be proud of and they shouldn't even be there is pretty sad.

That concept seems so clear yet some are struggling with it.

 

[Canard]

Yep so Dud calls are OK in the first half and most of the 2nd half, got it mate

 

[STORM.99/07]

seriously, could you imagine if this was the grand final?

One year it's going to be.

2006

 

[Bretto]

Yep so Dud calls are OK in the first half and most of the 2nd half, got it mate

If a call that affects the outcome of the game is made with no time left on the clock, for either team to play any Rugby League to change the result, then the call would have directly lead to the outcome of the game. As it stands, it affected the outcome indirectly.

Is that the gist?

 

[Pig Champion]

Yep so Dud calls are OK in the first half and most of the 2nd half, got it mate

Where did I say they are OK? They happen every game, at every level, big dud calls, little dud calls, anytime of the game. It was a big dud call, but if it wasn't made can you categorically state the cowboys would have won?

 

[Canard]

Yep, so the referees can go mental until the 78 minute and it doesn't matter.

It's only if it's in the last 2 mins that referees decisions matter.

 

[2012....Sharks Year]

While I feel for the cows...... How many games are won or lost in the 7th minute.