What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Rumoured/Confirmed Signings and General Drivel XV

Status
Not open for further replies.

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
Today I learned that of all the officials that have refereed more than 3 Origin games, only 1 of them has a record in favour of NSW. Qld has 6.
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
150,734
what do you mean by "a record in favour" ?

do you mean their mistakes favour a certain team ?
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
what do you mean by "a record in favour" ?

do you mean their mistakes favour a certain team ?

No opinion here, that's purely wins v losses. Manson is the only ref with more than 3 Origins who refereed more wins for NSW than Qld. There were 6 refs who oversaw more wins for Qld than NSW.
 
Messages
19,102
Today I learned that of all the officials that have refereed more than 3 Origin games, only 1 of them has a record in favour of NSW. Qld has 6.

Well, whoever told you that is wrong. As well as Manson, there is Kevin Roberts who refereed 6 games, 5 of which were won by NSW.

The only refs with a significant difference in Win/Losses in favour of QLD are Hayne, Gommersall and Archer. The other refs are 2/3 (NSW / QLD), or in the case of Harrigan 9/11/1, and there's a couple on 2/2.
 
Last edited:

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
73,538
Dally Ms

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...+dailytelegraphnrlndm+(Daily+Telegraph+|+NRL)

LEADERBOARD

18 J Hayne (PAR)
15 J Reynolds (CTB)
15 J Thurston (NQL)
12 D Cherry-Evans (MAN)
14 B Hunt (BRI)
10 C Cronk (MEL)
10 G Widdop (STI)
11 M Gillett (BRI)
10 S Burgess (SOU)
9 A Milford (CAN)
9 A Woods (WST)
9 T Hodkinson (CTB)
9 G Bird (GC)
9 P Wallace (PEN)
9 G Inglis (SOU)
9 C Sandow (PAR)
9 R Farah (WST)
8 J Graham (CTB)
8 L Brooks (WST)
8 G Burgess (SOU)
8 M Scott (NQL)
8 C Smith (MEL)
7 T Merrin (STI)
7 J Tedesco (WST)
7 M Pearce (SYD)
6 J Bromwich (MEL)
6 S Thaiday (BRI)
6 E Taylor (PEN)
6 S Johnson (NZ)
6 B Slater (MEL)
6 N Myles (GCT)
6 A Kelly (GC)
6 S Tomkins (NZ)
5 N Peats (PAR)
6 B Matulino (NZ)
5 W Graham (CRO)
5 S Matai (MAN)
5 K Foran (MAN)
5 A Sezer (GC)
5 J Mansour (PEN)
5 J Croker (CAN)
5 D Walker (SOU)
5 S Radradra (PAR)
7 J Soward (PEN)
4 B Cordner (SYD)
4 SB Williams (SYD)
4 J Lillyman (NZ)
4 J Waerea- Hargreaves (SYD)
4 T Carney (CRO)
4 B. Scott (NEW)
7 S Mannering (NZ)
4 J Leilua (NEW)
4 A Tolman (CTB)
4 D Mead (GCT)
4 J Jackson (CTB)
4 M Morgan (NQL)
3 W Mason (NEW)
3 Robert Lui (NQL)
3 J Friend (SYD)
3 S Moa (SYD)
3 A Glenn (BRI)
3 B Hampton (MEL)
3 M Ma’u (PAR)
3 T Campese (CAN)
3 J Taumalolo (NQL)
3 S Fensom (CAN)
3 J Dugan (STG)
3 K Hurrell (NZ)
3 M Moylan (PEN)
3 M Gordon (CRO)
3 T Williams (CTB)
3 J Wighton (CAN)
3 C Parker (BRI)
3 A McCullough (BRI)
3 P Gallen (CRO)
3 T Peachey (PEN)
2 C Norman (PAR)
2 F Nuuausala (SYD)
2 B Stewart (MAN)
2 G Stewart (MAN)
3 D Tupou (SYD)
2 B Thompson (WST)
2 T Sims (NQL)
2 J Tamou (NQL)
2 J Buhrer (MAN)
2 A Watmough (MAN)
2 S Perrett (CTB)
2 A Guerra (SYD)
2 D Gagai (NEW)
2 A Minichiello (SYD)
2 A Fifita (CRO)
2 M Taupau (WST)
2 T Roberts (NEW)
2 M Rein (STG)
2 P Hiku (MAN)
2 B Lawrence (MAN)
2 J Segeyaro (PEN)
2 B Barba (BRI)
2 D Taylor (GCT)
2 A Reynolds (SOU)
1 D Copley (BRI)
1 B Takairangi (GCT)
1 M Jennings (SYD)
1 L Maranta (BRI)
1 N Plum (PEN)
1 J Papalii (CAN)
1 J Lyon (MAN)
1 M Ballin (MAN)
1 D Shillington (CAN)
1 M Dobson (NEW)
1 D Farrell (STG)
4 J Maloney (SYD)
1 N Stapleton (CRO)
1 A Koriosau (SOU)
1 J Sutton (SOU)
1 J Gavet (WST)
1 W Chambers (MEL)
1 A Blair (WST)
1 J Taufua (MAN)
1 R Rochow (NEW)
1 B Kite (PEN)
1 P Carter (GCT)
1 W Hopoate (PAR)
1 B Tate (NQL)
1 G Buttriss (CAN)
1 J McCrone (CAN)
1 N Friend (NZ)
1 E Taylor (PEN)
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
Well, whoever told you that is wrong. As well as Manson, there is Kevin Roberts who refereed 6 games, 5 of which were won by NSW.

Stupid Wiki had Roberts down for only 2 games so I missed it. That makes it NSW 2, Qld 5. Still quite a lopsided number.
 
Last edited:

Forty20

First Grade
Messages
7,677
Someone on FB believes we have already approached Michael Liccha to come over for the remainder of the season.

I have a suspicion that this rumour may have started simply due to someone floating the idea of signing Lichaa for the remainder of 2014 over on nospam07.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Top