2017 Elim Final, Sat - Sea Eagles 10-22 Panthers @ Allianz

[Cherry_poppins]

If it collectively wasn't for Rugby League subscriptions oeriod,there would have not been AFL on paytv.

The fair minded AFL fans are aware of this.Look the shit up,and research before spouting shit you parasite.

You're gimp club is partly to blame for afl

 

[blaza88z]

If it collectively wasn't for Rugby League subscriptions oeriod,there would have not been AFL on paytv.

The fair minded AFL fans are aware of this.Look the shit up,and research before spouting shit you parasite.

The Port Adelaide/West Coast game was a cracker tonight, you really missed out on an unbelievable game

 

[GongPanther]

Poor delusional Panfers fan. Do you really think Cartwright still scores that try if the Peachy try is correctly ruled a knock on?

F**king redneck d**khead

How do you know a Panther still wouldn't have?

Take the loss like two balls on the chin.

 

[GongPanther]

Herbersham?

Hahahahahahahaha!

LOL!!

 

[TheFrog]

it remains to be seen if he can make the most of a squad that he can claim as his own

Reaching the last 6 standing two years running must be getting close.

 

[GongPanther]

I'm not your mom kid

But you're the cuck,manchild.

 

[cain3y]

One more for mary poppins

Let's go fly a kite
Up to the highest height
Let's go fly a kite
And send it soaring
Up through the atmosphere
Up where the air is clear
Oh, let's go fly a kite

 

[GongPanther]

what a response....you f**kers really are dumb. you dopey bogans could barely fill 2 and a half bays.

Manly=Westies by the Sea.

 

[Sime_11]

To the cocky Manly fans tonight - Get it up ya!!!! Fk off till next season

The genuine manly fans - commiserations, great season, exceeded expectations and will be a top 8 team next year.

Go the Panthers!!!!

 

[TheFrog]

Manly will do them slowly

Next year?

 

[OldPanther]

Sorry we just spell it how you toothless merkins pronounce it

Very nice of you to come down to our level. True gentleman. I hope your boys aren't too upset with being knocked out by a shit team of dumb westies.

Wtf?! How does Uate dropping a ball with 2 mins to go DECIDE a game and an incorrect awarding of 6 pts (and denial of 6 pts earlier) not?
I hate the Broncos with a passion so i hope Pantherz kick em out the back door but they wont get the 50/50s and bunker help in Brisbane and therefor theure f-----

That was probably the wrong thing to point out but Manly did bomb multiple opportunities throughout the game. That call could very well have been meaningless if they took said opportunities.

what a response....you f**kers really are dumb. you dopey bogans could barely fill 2 and a half bays.

We had the bigger crowd lol. If Manly fans showed up properly it would have been a really good crowd.

Anyways it was a good game and Congrats Manly fans on making the 8. Most people thought you wouldn’t make it and your boys still tried tonight.

 

[oval]

Penrith are normally my second team - my father is a supporter and took me to Penrith (and Manly cos we lived on the beaches) games as a kid. So I'm still hoping they go all the way.

However, that was some grade-A bullshit tonight. Not dirty on the Panthers players, but the bunker well and truly rammed us up the date tonight. Cnts.

Still, our loss has brought a lot of joy to those who dislike Manly tonight, so enjoy the spoils while they last. The mighty Sea Eagles will be back, no doubt about that.

 

[Nice Beaver]

Well....what a f*cking farce that was.

Absolute JOKE of a decision that did our season in.

Screw these referees. Have not bothered to read this thread as it will be no doubt filled with "suck shit Manly blah blah blah".

2 games tonight butchered by ref calls.

Thanks NRL 2017. Nice to know ya. I am out for this year.

 

[OldPanther]

Well....what a f*cking farce that was.

Absolute JOKE of a decision that did our season in.

Screw these referees. Have not bothered to read this thread as it will be no doubt filled with "suck shit Manly blah blah blah".

2 games tonight butchered by ref calls.

Thanks NRL 2017. Nice to know ya. I am out for this year.

It really wasn't decided by the refs. Just because a controversial call happens at the end seems to effect people's opinion. Every other bunker decision was on point and that one was 50/50. If manly didn't knock on in goal or be offside they are favourites to win.

 

[OldPanther]

I just listened to Barrett’s press conference. The entire thing was having a complain about the Peachy try. I agree with him that "try/no try" has too much influence BUT he talks like it costs them the game when they had a set on Penrith’s line in the last 5 and completely stuffed it with a knock on. That's 2 tries if they don't knock it on another one if Walker is 1 step back. Uate knocks on again which leads to Cartwright try. At half time Mal spoke about Manly’s poor discipline which we've been pointing out all year which is costing them penalty counts and ultimately possession. Where is the accountability for your own boys?

 

[beave]

Would hate to lose a finals game over a rubbish knock on call.

 

[mave]

Would hate to lose a finals game over a rubbish knock on call.

Agreed.
Can we whine like btches for the next 5 years like Thurston now ?

Western Sydney NSW conspiracy!!!

 

[Lebbo73]

On board, as in playing? what the f**k was the point in sitting out this week? they could've easily got beat, then what? he spends the best part of the year training with his mates, the captain of the club etc.. then sits out their most important game of the year?

If he is suffering from depression or something along those lines, I retract everything just mentioned but if he comes out next week and plays, he shouldn't be asking for a release, Penrith should be demanding he leave, horrible figure to have as your leader with that sort of attitude

Exactly. If Moylan can't handle a little bit of criticism from the coach in the change rooms, he's a f**king soft cock.

 

[Lebbo73]

I couldn't make it out either way.But I could understand,that after observing that the ref viewed a "not absolutely sure he knocked on",he judged a try.

After looking at the replay on the HD 9 shots,there was no way he could have 100% ruled a knock on.

I agree with this but the on field ref shouldn't be sending that to the bunker as a Try. It should have been a No Try call from the ref and stayed that way in the bunker. It couldn't have been overturned. However, the refs should only say Try when they are fairly confident it is.
Peachey looked like in the run of play too have knocked that on. It should be ruled that way. The multiple replays didn't show a knock on but some doubt. I am confident that the ball hit his chest and then went down and hit just above his knee. However, it could have and some replays suggest that the ball then hit his fingers and shot straight forward.

 

[umina panther]

The issue is the ref needs a "I have no f**king idea option"