What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Best Queensland test cricketer

Desert Qlder

First Grade
Messages
9,113
Difficult one really. Here's my Made in Queensland all-time XI:

1-M.Hayden
2-B.Brown*
3-P.Burge
4-T.Vievers
5-S.Watson
6-K.Mackay
7-I.Healy+
8-M.Johnson
9-R.Archer
10-B.Ironmonger
11-C.McDermott

Bit light on the batting - next three up were Martin Love, Ken Archer and Greg Ritchie. Picking Brown is a bit cheeky - but he was born in Queensland before moving to NSW in his early teens and always considered himself a Queenslander (he returned there to finish his FC career). If ineligible, you'd have to sub in Ken Archer.

Decent pace bowling stocks with Kasper, Bichel, Rackemann, Dale and Dymock missing the cut. I feel like if he'd ever been given a crack in a baggy green, Eddie Gilbert would have been a lay down misere for the side.

The 'spinner' is nominally Ironmonger - would be my pick of one of the two best players in the side alongside Brown - but so many sources vary as to whether he was a left arm orthodox tweaker or a slow-medium swing bowler. He's backed up by Vievers, who was a batting all-rounder. In any case the options after him are Hauritz, Hohns and Murray Bennett. Hardly inspiring.

Keeping was tough - three Australian greats available in Healy, Grout and Tallon. Healy just cinched it from Grout.

Adam Dale was originally a Vic, pretty sure.

Law, Love and Maher could all easily have played for Australia and had successful careers. Circumstances, personalities and just bad luck conspired against this however, so we will never know. It was a very competitive time for middle order batsmen in Shield cricket.

Love was probably the pick of the three, who all contributed to a golden age of Queensland cricket.
 

Meth

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
34,668
Wasn't Border a Queenslander?

Or played the majority of his cricket for QLD at least.
 
Top