What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

See ya Slater

MilkShark

First Grade
Messages
5,155
Slaters judiciary record.


*2005 Contrary conduct (head slam) grade 2, early plea. Suspended 1 week


*2006 kicking, grade 5, guilty at panel, suspended 7 weeks.


*2006 dangerous throw, grade 1, guilty at panel, suspended 2 weeks


*2006 striking, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 2 weeks.


*2008 contrary conduct (fighting) grade 2, guilty at panel, suspended 1 week.


*2010 dangerous conduct (legs/feet) grade 1 guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2010 careless high tackle, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2013 dangerous conduct, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2018 shoulder charge, grade 1, not guilty at panel, suspended 0 weeks.
 

Canard

Immortal
Messages
34,147
Slaters judiciary record.


*2005 Contrary conduct (head slam) grade 2, early plea. Suspended 1 week


*2006 kicking, grade 5, guilty at panel, suspended 7 weeks.


*2006 dangerous throw, grade 1, guilty at panel, suspended 2 weeks


*2006 striking, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 2 weeks.


*2008 contrary conduct (fighting) grade 2, guilty at panel, suspended 1 week.


*2010 dangerous conduct (legs/feet) grade 1 guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2010 careless high tackle, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2013 dangerous conduct, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2018 shoulder charge, grade 1, not guilty at panel, suspended 0 weeks.

So compared to Andrew Fifita, its not that bad.
 

King hit

Coach
Messages
13,756
Isn't it wonderful to see a decision which upsets all the right people - the whingers, wallys and wankers.

Can't wait to see Paul Gallen's reaction, nobody does sandy vag like that bloke.

Gallen isn't even related to the topic and the inbreeds need to bring him up.
 

no name

Coach
Messages
19,081
NRL reports on the goings on at clubs as if it is a tv mini series, secretly they like it. I'm sure they believe any exposure is good exposure, that couldn't be less true.

It's absurd that the one game I know most about due to playing it entire life, watching it whole life, supporting it my whole is the one game I would never place a single dollar on because I know the game will be decided more often than, not by the players, but by the hidden agenda the NRL / media agreed on.

I really hope everyones see how much of a coincidence it is not that the storm and roosters are playing each other when its slaters final year, up against his old mate cronk. The refereeing in the finals series was so one sided, only 2 teams were ever going through to the GF.
NRL is not Rugby League.
Two totally different games.
 

Storm80

Juniors
Messages
212
Slaters judiciary record.


*2005 Contrary conduct (head slam) grade 2, early plea. Suspended 1 week


*2006 kicking, grade 5, guilty at panel, suspended 7 weeks.


*2006 dangerous throw, grade 1, guilty at panel, suspended 2 weeks


*2006 striking, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 2 weeks.


*2008 contrary conduct (fighting) grade 2, guilty at panel, suspended 1 week.


*2010 dangerous conduct (legs/feet) grade 1 guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2010 careless high tackle, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2013 dangerous conduct, grade 1, guilty early plea, suspended 0 weeks.


*2018 shoulder charge, grade 1, not guilty at panel, suspended 0 weeks.

What’s his record got to do with whether he was charged for a shoulder charge?? Match review thought it was a shoulder charge. Nrl judiciary reviewed the evidence and determined (for various reasons) it was not a shoulder charge.

How obsessed are you with this? It’s pretty clear the ref made the wrong call. As did the match review panel. Nothing wrong with the rule either. If anything, the NRL judiciary has proved the system works. In the end the correct decision was made.

You should be praising Billy. After all, had he not had a season ending shoulder injury in 2016, your club wouldn’t have had a chance in hell of winning its first premiership. Only reason storm lost that GF was cause it’s most influential attacking player was on the side lines
 

MilkShark

First Grade
Messages
5,155
What’s his record got to do with whether he was charged for a shoulder charge?? Match review thought it was a shoulder charge. Nrl judiciary reviewed the evidence and determined (for various reasons) it was not a shoulder charge.

How obsessed are you with this? It’s pretty clear the ref made the wrong call. As did the match review panel. Nothing wrong with the rule either. If anything, the NRL judiciary has proved the system works. In the end the correct decision was made.

You should be praising Billy. After all, had he not had a season ending shoulder injury in 2016, your club wouldn’t have had a chance in hell of winning its first premiership. Only reason storm lost that GF was cause it’s most influential attacking player was on the side lines
hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
 

Valheru

Coach
Messages
17,509
What’s his record got to do with whether he was charged for a shoulder charge?? Match review thought it was a shoulder charge. Nrl judiciary reviewed the evidence and determined (for various reasons) it was not a shoulder charge.

How obsessed are you with this? It’s pretty clear the ref made the wrong call. As did the match review panel. Nothing wrong with the rule either. If anything, the NRL judiciary has proved the system works. In the end the correct decision was made.

You should be praising Billy. After all, had he not had a season ending shoulder injury in 2016, your club wouldn’t have had a chance in hell of winning its first premiership. Only reason storm lost that GF was cause it’s most influential attacking player was on the side lines

Why are you still trying so hard? You got the result you wanted.

It was a shoulder charge. I know it, you know it and Billy knows it. He got off because of who he is, that is the only reason.

Just accept it for what it is and move on.
 
Top