Cameron Smith’s stunning call for NRL to return Melbourne’s stripped titles

[Miller was a legend]

That’s how I read it.

Just find it amusing hat you would bother with illegal TPA’s when you still have room in the cap. Between that and doing so badly in the year that they were using PED’s, it means the club is pretty crap at cheating.

They should leave it to the experts. (Insert rich clubs names here).

Absolutely, useless flogs! Lol

 

[RedVDragon]

Totally agree with Cameron. Give the Storm their title or strip the premiership off the Sharks.

 

[Miller was a legend]

Totally agree with Cameron. Give the Storm their title or strip the premiership off the Sharks.

And take 2010 also, since the premiers were over the cap?

 

[RedVDragon]

I get the feeling this merkin will make it his post playing and refereeing career mission to get the NRL CEO job and hell overturn the stripped titles and present the trophy to himself

Hell do a far better job than the current mob.

 

[RedVDragon]

And take 2010 also, since the premiers were over the cap?

To me the scum still haven’t won a premiership. Just keep buying players idiots

 

[Miller was a legend]

To me the scum still haven’t won a premiership. Just keep buying players idiots

Congrats, as long as it works for you

 

[myrrh ken]

Just keep buying players idiots

And you can keep your idiot players

 

[RedVDragon]

And you can keep your idiot players

You such an idiot I would be here forever naming your scumbags. Go away idiot

 

[myrrh ken]

Did you say something?

 

[TheFrog]

Cameron Smith has sensationally called for the NRL to consider handing back Melbourne the two titles they had stripped for salary-cap rorts after cheating rivals Cronulla escaped a premiership sanction.

Be thankful you got to keep your ill-gotten premiership rings.

 

[SBD82]

Why are Dragons and Sharks fans fighting in this thread?

Surely this is the one place we can find common ground: Cam Smith is a piece of shit, and the Storm are cheating merkins.

 

[Miller was a legend]

Why are Dragons and Sharks fans fighting in this thread?

Surely this is the one place we can find common ground: Cam Smith is a piece of shit, and the Storm are cheating merkins.

You are my hero SBD

 

[SBD82]

You are my hero SBD

Ha. Happy to do my bit against the common enemy, then we can go back to kicking each other’s arses.

 

[Frailty]

Has an amount the Sharts cheated by been stated? I haven’t seen or heard it, but as far as how serious it was, Cameron isn’t wrong.

Cronulla cheated as far back as 2013, so 5 years. It was systematic like the Storm. They set up a private company to cover up bogus 3rd party payments ffs.

How they got away with only a $350,000/year for 2 years fine is a joke. Barry Russell could have been hired just to be a scapegoat.

$700K is the reported amount in total over the number of years through irregular 3rd Party payments (some not even made). For 2016, the third party amounts added to the salary cap still meant the club was below the salary cap.

There is no evidence of an external private company being set up until 2017 - NOT the entire time.

This is comparing to the Storm salary cap breaches totalling $3.78M over the 5 years. Funnily enough they were not fined that amount.

 

[Miller was a legend]

$700K is the reported amount in total over the number of years through irregular 3rd Party payments (some not even made). For 2016, the third party amounts added to the salary cap still meant the club was below the salary cap.

There is no evidence of an external private company being set up until 2017 - NOT the entire time.

This is comparing to the Storm salary cap breaches totalling $3.78M over the 5 years. Funnily enough they were not fined that amount.

Can that be fixed retrospectively?

 

[jc155776]

Do people realise the only thing that made the TPAs illegal for the sharks was that the club went out hunting for them with it all recorded as TPAs?

Big difference between that and paying players secretly with fake contracts.

 

[Jerkwad2000]

Can only go by the NRL’s own words mate.

Greenberg also said this:

"It is not on the scale of some of those other ones. It's not like we've seen previously. It's not a systematic approach."

So, you can't take much that moron says at face value

https://www.nospam47.com/au/league/...dal-todd-greenberg/11unde6oixxkb1vi0svx19m0qi

 

[Miller was a legend]

Greenberg also said this:



So, you can't take much that moron says at face value

https://www.nospam47.com/au/league/...dal-todd-greenberg/11unde6oixxkb1vi0svx19m0qi

Lol WTF

 

[taipan]

Cam should be nominated also for a Logie.Best performer in a comedy act.

 

[GongPanther]

Smith is being shifty again as needs to correct his stance. Two wrongs do not make a right,and if anything Smith should have been calling for the Sharks to be stripped, if the penalty fits the crime. So Smith should stop with the pulling of wool over everyone's eyes and call it how it should be and not what benefits his club's cheating.