What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

LU Panthers Forum Player of the Year

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
I'm planning to do ratings again this season following every match, rating players 0 to 10 in accordance with the old RLW system. I prefer this to 3-2-1 as all players get points and its a fairer result. 3-2-1 favours playmakers over hard workers. Since a few people showed interest last year, others wanting to join in are free and welcome to do so. You don't have to use the RLW ratings method if you don't want, some people might not even know of it. Just a rating between 0 and 10 inclusive (no fractions, these will be rounded down) for each player who takes the field will be fine. I'll keep a spreadsheet and might even give progressive updates.

Just a couple of things-

1. Please post your ratings in this thread. Makes them easier to find.
2. Panthers fans only please.
3. Ratings for each match will close when the next one opens, which will be around kick off time or when the first post for the following round is made. If you post ratings for round 1 in the middle of round 6 posts, this will be very confusing.
4. When calculating the Panthers Player of the Year, only the best 20 ratings for each player will count, plus one for each final we play.
5. Don't post anything but player ratings in this thread after round 1 kickoff (you can post to say you're in).
 

age.s

First Grade
Messages
6,920
Good stuff Froggy. I'd be interested in contributing from time to time.
 

mxlegend99

Referee
Messages
23,004
Im in aswell. Although it might require a second viewing to rate everyone on a scale of 1-10. Easy for the wins. Not so much for losses.
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Round 1

Edwards 5
Mansour 5
Whare 5
Blake 5
Watene-Zelezniak 5
Maloney 6
Cleary 6
Tamou 7
Egan 6
Leota 6
Sele 3
Yeo 6
Fisher-Harris 7

Campbell-Gillard 6
Hetherington 6
Fuimaoiono 5
Luai 4
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
11,182
Well do it then.

Round 1

Edwards 0
Mansour 0
Whare 0
Blake 0
Watene-Zelezniak 0
Maloney 0
Cleary 10 (Gave a go)
Tamou 0
Egan 0
Leota 0
Sele 0
Yeo 0
Fisher-Harris 0

Campbell-Gillard 0
Hetherington 0
Fuimaoiono 0
Luai 0
 

age.s

First Grade
Messages
6,920
Edwards - 3
Mansour - 3
Whare - 3
Blake - 5
DWZ - 4
Maloney - 5
Cleary - 5
Tamou - 8
Egan - 6
Leota - 7
Sele - 5
Yeo - 6
JFH - 7

RCG - 5
Hetherington - 5
Fuimaono - 5
Luai - 6
 

Black Magik

Juniors
Messages
866
Edwards - 3
Mansour - 3
Whare - 5
Blake - 5
DWZ - 4
Maloney - 7
Cleary - 6
Tamou - 9
Egan - 6
Leota - 8
Sele - 5
Yeo - 6
JFH - 7

RCG - 7
Hetherington - 4
Fuimaono - 5
Luai - 6
 

mxlegend99

Referee
Messages
23,004
Round 1

Edwards 0
Mansour 0
Whare 0
Blake 0
Watene-Zelezniak 0
Maloney 0
Cleary 10 (Gave a go)
Tamou 0
Egan 0
Leota 0
Sele 0
Yeo 0
Fisher-Harris 0

Campbell-Gillard 0
Hetherington 0
Fuimaoiono 0
Luai 0
I think you gave a few of these guys a bit too many points.

Ffs. Didnt expect this to be so hard. I cant rate them just yet.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,135
I think you gave a few of these guys a bit too many points.

Ffs. Didnt expect this to be so hard. I cant rate them just yet.

I’d have to watch the full replay to give every player a match rating and frankly having watched the game live I can’t bring myself to watching a replay it was too painful.

Watching the game live at the game with a few beers on board I though James Tamou was clearly our best player. There were others who defended well but outside of Tamou it’s hard to put a wrap on too many others.
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Edwards - 3
Mansour - 3
Whare - 5
Blake - 5
DWZ - 4
Maloney - 7
Cleary - 6
Tamou - 9
Egan - 6
Leota - 8
Sele - 5
Yeo - 6
JFH - 7

RCG - 7
Hetherington - 4
Fuimaono - 5
Luai - 6
Could you edit your first post to say it's been updated, otherwise I might either count you twice or not at all. Thanks
 

Latest posts

Top