Vic Mackey
Referee
- Messages
- 24,589
Cartwright has far more talent than SBW from this biased Panthers fans point of view
Lol
Cartwright has far more talent than SBW from this biased Panthers fans point of view
Not Souths, so won't be a medical retirement I guess.
I know you're joking (and it's a good one), but he wasn't currently under contract, so he doesn't matter.
Scored the try that levelled the scores too.A match winning field goal on NRL debut... not bad at all.
Dunno about more than SBW but he was incredibly talented as a junior and that proved to be the problem. He didn't need to learn the basics of the game in order to win matches.
"Dunno", as in you think it's even somewhat debatable that he's more talented than SBW?Dunno about more than SBW but he was incredibly talented as a junior and that proved to be the problem. He didn't need to learn the basics of the game in order to win matches.
In terms of raw talent, it's debatable. But not even on the same planet as a footballer, for reasons I thought I made clear. I thought you'd understand the point being made here but it was too much to ask."Dunno", as in you think it's even somewhat debatable that he's more talented than SBW?
That's a good one.
There's no way he was better or more talented than SBW. I think some fans have a biased view of SBW's abilities due to the way in which he left league. It wasn't until I saw a Bulldogs game at the awful homebush stadium that gave a view of the whole game that I realised just how good he was."Dunno", as in you think it's even somewhat debatable that he's more talented than SBW?
That's a good one.
Merrin back in Oz and this guy coincidently gets a bleed on the brain. Oh this is too much.
Will Moylan fall ill too?.
For SBW, Lolo and Haas are probably the only comparable guys since. Maybe David Fifita.There's no way he was better or more talented than SBW. I think some fans have a biased view of SBW's abilities due to the way in which he left league. It wasn't until I saw a Bulldogs game at the awful homebush stadium that gave a view of the whole game that I realised just how good he was.
Anyway, back on topic, sad way for Martin to end his career.