Your top 5 overrated players of all time?

[THE CHAMP]

I honestly don't get these takes by some fans. Cordner is easily the best second rower of the last decade, and it shouldn't take being a one eyed rooster fan to realise this.

Last decade? f**k me thaiday was at his best in 2010 and Cordner is nowhere near that. I do rate Cordner but he’s nowhere near Sam at his best

 

[gerg]

Last decade? f**k me thaiday was at his best in 2010 and Cordner is nowhere near that. I do rate Cordner but he’s nowhere near Sam at his best

As far as second rowers go I can't rate Thaiday any higher than third place.

 

[King hit]

Last decade? f**k me thaiday was at his best in 2010 and Cordner is nowhere near that. I do rate Cordner but he’s nowhere near Sam at his best

Look at Cordners results leading a team compared to Thaiday. Cordner is superior.

 

[myrrh ken]

The Kimmorley hate is something I will never understand

Probably cos he didnt ruin your team

 

[THE CHAMP]

Look at Cordners results leading a team compared to Thaiday. Cordner is superior.

Didn’t Cordner captain the first kangaroo team to lose to tonga?

 

[Dingo_dan]

Last decade? f**k me thaiday was at his best in 2010 and Cordner is nowhere near that. I do rate Cordner but he’s nowhere near Sam at his best

Jesus lol.

 

[gUt]

Mark Gasnier.

 

[Ashfield Panther]

Bryce Cartwright

 

[King hit]

Didn’t Cordner captain the first kangaroo team to lose to tonga?

Didn't Thaiday captain the Broncos to their worst season to date. Went missing in so many games that year. Didn't Lockyer also lose the world cup and 4 nations on home soil.

 

[THE CHAMP]

Didn't Thaiday captain the Broncos to their worst season to date. Went missing in so many games that year. Didn't Lockyer also lose the world cup and 4 nations on home soil.

Wtf does Lockyer have to do with this.

Some serious butthurt at your end by the sound of it

 

[Hutty1986]

Last decade? f**k me thaiday was at his best in 2010 and Cordner is nowhere near that. I do rate Cordner but he’s nowhere near Sam at his best

Oh dear

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Didn't Thaiday captain the Broncos to their worst season to date. Went missing in so many games that year. Didn't Lockyer also lose the world cup and 4 nations on home soil.

Didn't you support the Broncos up until 18 months ago?

 

[The_Frog]

Anyone who voted for Dylan Edwards over him eats shrooms for breakfast lunch and dinner.

I don't regard Dylan as superior to Gutherson but that doesn't mean he's not a damn good fullback. Edwards had a bad patch after his shoulder recon which is what everyone remembers. He's an integral part of a top 4 team right now, just like the King.

 

[King hit]

Wtf does Lockyer have to do with this.

Some serious butthurt at your end by the sound of it

Well you’re bringing up cordners captaincy of Australia so I thought it was appropriate

 

[Whip Whitaker]

Aaron Woods.

 

[Phil McGrawhan]

Aaron Woods.

Yep
Gota be one of the most overrated props in the history of RL

 

[Sphagnum]

Whatever happened to that Jarryd Haynes guy who used to play for the Titans. Think he was an NFL quarterback or something who decided to try his hand at rugba leeg.

never heard of the f**ker?

 

[Sphagnum]

Didn't Thaiday captain the Broncos to their worst season to date. Went missing in so many games that year. Didn't Lockyer also lose the world cup and 4 nations on home soil.

Didn’t that World Cup campaign sport the Ricky Stuart polish? Bit unfair blaming anyone else for that.

 

[BadnMean]

Woods

Hayne

Moses (one good season & a downhill skier)

Thaiday

Cordner I think is actually good & doesn't deserve to be on the list.

 

[Whip Whitaker]

Anthony Milford