What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Cameron Smith is the greatest rugby league player ever.

AJB1102

First Grade
Messages
6,339
no ambiguity in my posts whatsoever and your reply , to one isolated post out of a series , has no relevance to my stance

so yeah, you lack basic comprehension skills

either that or you’re trying to be smart arse

Understood you pretty well I think (well for a bloke who can't read I think I did ok); you think Smith is a merkin of a bloke and believe that should be considered when discussing his RL legacy. I disagree. If I'm judging the character of a person I don't weigh in their footballing abilities, so when judging footballers I don't weigh up what I think they're like as a person.
 
Messages
13,942
It is stuff like these article as to why thge dislike continues - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/sh...ebrate-not-boo-cam-smith-20201022-p567lr.html

Show some respect, Sydney: NRL, Storm want fans to celebrate, not boo, Cam Smith
635402f1698dc5687fb8f98be5c093fe76cbc56f

By Christian Nicolussi
October 23, 2020 — 12.00am

NRL and Melbourne officials are banking on Cameron Smith receiving a warm Sydney welcome with no repeat of the ugly booing directed at the departing Billy Slater two years ago.

Slater himself could never understand why some sections of the game were critical of the Storm leader and declared: "If we had 400 Cameron Smiths running around as role models, our game would be in a handy spot."

The travel restrictions in place because of the COVID-19 pandemic will mean even fewer Melbourne supporters will be spotted at ANZ Stadium in what could be the legendary No.9's final game.

While the Storm know there will not be a love-in for Smith like there was at Suncorp Stadium last Friday night, they expect at the very least for Sydneysiders to celebrate arguably the greatest player in the game, regardless if it his swansong.

Slater was booed with every touch and even afterwards when he was interviewed after the 2018 grand final loss, which was largely driven by him avoiding suspension for a shoulder charge at the judiciary in the lead-up.

Smith was so incensed at the booing directed at his teammate he said later that night: "He [Slater] has only ever been someone good for the game, I think he deserved a bit more respect than that."

Slater was not fazed by the hostile send-off and quipped "even Wally Lewis got booed".

"But I do think the responsibility needs to start with the voices in our game that influence other people and our fans," Slater told the Herald.

"I don't hear Andrew Johns or Phil Gould – people who have played and coached or administrated at the highest level in our game – talk about one of our greats like that.

"I honestly don't know why [he cops it]. Those people who are critical of Cameron mustn't know him like I do.

"He's not selfish – he's as selfless as any one I've played with – and if we had 400 Cameron Smiths running around as role models, our game would be in a handy spot.

"I don't mind fans being patriotic and that's what makes our game great. We just need to be careful it doesn't turn into abuse. We've cracked down on racial abuse, which is fantastic, but abuse is abuse and we need to make sure everyone is respectful to our players and everyone in the game."

NRL chief executive Andrew Abdo did not believe there would be booing and said of Smith: "Cameron is a legend of the game, he's done what nobody else has done and that's bring up his 430th game – he is a player every fan would secretly love to have on their team.

"I'll be disappointed if he gets anything other than absolute respect and recognition. Regardless of who fans support, everyone respects the remarkable achievements of Cameron Smith. He is one of our greatest-ever players."

The Storm remain in the dark about Smith's next move. The 37-year-old has always polarised league fans in Sydney during the season and on the Origin arena. There have been the referee jokes.

And who can forget Paul Gallen walking off with some of his Blues players when Smith delivered a post-match series victory speech in 2016 at the same ground?

Storm chief executive Dave Donaghy loved the scenes last Friday with Melbourne and Canberra fans showing their appreciation for Smith.

"Nobody knows if it will be Cam's last game, but there should not be an occurrence of what happened with Billy again," Donaghy said.

"When Cameron walked off last weekend, seeing the whole northern end of the ground rise as one, regardless if they were wearing purple or green [Canberra] jerseys, they applauded him and it made me so proud to be involved in this game."

Penrith players, many of them who have played fewer career games than Smith has played finals, spoke glowingly this week about their grand final opponent.

Talk about hypersensitive. Wally Lewis got booed in every game he played in Sydney and never let it phase him. If the Storm or the NRL think this will stop the dislike of Cameron Smith they are dreaming. In fact talk like this will just encourage it.

In any realm you earn respect. You can't just demand it.To think you can ignores reality.
 

coolsteve

Juniors
Messages
1,555
Here’s what gonna happen . Smith won’t announce retirement until Ablett has his week of headlines in vic. Smith won’t get a mention but gets farewelled in origin. End of story
 
Messages
8,480
Given he couldn’t play at the storms home ground this year. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s plays one or two games next year down there as a sign-off then retires - Complexities no doubt with the cap etc..

If that actually happened - no doubt the hate brigade out there will howl it down but I’d be ok with it.
 

greenBV4

Bench
Messages
2,508
Given he couldn’t play at the storms home ground this year. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s plays one or two games next year down there as a sign-off then retires - Complexities no doubt with the cap etc..

If that actually happened - no doubt the hate brigade out there will howl it down but I’d be ok with it.
SBW set the precedent for contracts only involving a handfull of games
 
Last edited:

moffla

Bench
Messages
3,235
Given he couldn’t play at the storms home ground this year. I wouldn’t be surprised if he’s plays one or two games next year down there as a sign-off then retires - Complexities no doubt with the cap etc..

If that actually happened - no doubt the hate brigade out there will howl it down but I’d be ok with it.
Would definitely love to see it but simply won’t happen. Can you imagine the negativity around it?
 
Messages
12,687
It is stuff like these article as to why thge dislike continues - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/sh...ebrate-not-boo-cam-smith-20201022-p567lr.html



Talk about hypersensitive. Wally Lewis got booed in every game he played in Sydney and never let it phase him. If the Storm or the NRL think this will stop the dislike of Cameron Smith they are dreaming. In fact talk like this will just encourage it.

In any realm you earn respect. You can't just demand it.To think you can ignores reality.
I hope he goes out the same way as Billy Slater. Booed by a capacity crowd and on the receiving end of a loss.
 

Reflector

Juniors
Messages
2,307
It is stuff like these article as to why thge dislike continues - https://www.smh.com.au/sport/nrl/sh...ebrate-not-boo-cam-smith-20201022-p567lr.html



Talk about hypersensitive. Wally Lewis got booed in every game he played in Sydney and never let it phase him. If the Storm or the NRL think this will stop the dislike of Cameron Smith they are dreaming. In fact talk like this will just encourage it.

In any realm you earn respect. You can't just demand it.To think you can ignores reality.


"Leave Cameron alone!"

Lol
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
65,846
Looking forward to him lifting the trophy this week then announcing his retirement next week, but that he will join the coaching team of storm and will be mentoring grant to be the next greatest hooker of all time!
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,783
As much as I think he would be a great coach.

I see administration, perhaps NRL chairman one day.

He has ruled out coaching, correctly identified the 24x7, 7 day commintment it plays in a mans life, which he does not want, well now anyway.

Management and administration requires less commitment, but much smarts, which he has.

Just IMHO.
 
Top