What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Team v Dragons

SmashEmBro

Juniors
Messages
638
Perham has not been named in Dolphins or Warriors. Injured? Or a number 6 conspiracy?

I do love a good conspiracy...
But, I would hope that with Turner so close to the team at the moment, and with him potentially heading off (has he actually signed with the Broncos?), if there’s going to be a swap that it would be him.

However I would gladly take a reshuffle with him in the backline with one of the others dropping out
 
Messages
2,564
I think JTB being out of the side is the right call. Good upcoming player but i think hes become overrated somehow

He's pretty solid. JTB had a good rookie season. He's finding his way and seems to know his role. With more experience via game time the better. He is blooding very well considering Warriors are known to make most players go backwards when they come here. I don't think anyone is overrating JTB among the fans / media.
 
Messages
2,564
On Kodi...to a league doesn't know it all like me, what's the reason he's not running when it's obvious that's when he's at his best and in turn we are? Gun shy? Doing too much work on D? I always wondered the same about Shaun.

I think its because they don't want to get smashed. Other hard halves such as Wighton, Cleary, Hughes etc. are not afraid taking on the line getting smashed some times.

I think in an interview Johnson mentioned he doesn't like the contact.
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
31,779
I think its because they don't want to get smashed. Other hard halves such as Wighton, Cleary, Hughes etc. are not afraid taking on the line getting smashed some times.

I think in an interview Johnson mentioned he doesn't like the contact.
I realise it’s different contact but Johnson usually did his bit defensively

I find it weird tbh, he would have been so much more effective if he went to the line more... all the great halves do... surely he understood that
 

Meth

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
34,669
This is a WTF team for mine.

Hiku needs to play centre.

Harris needs to play in the second row. Piss Curran off. If you don’t want Katoa, bring in Ale or JTB FFS

Don’t get the Katoa dropping.
 

Penrose Warrior

First Grade
Messages
8,637
I realise it’s different contact but Johnson usually did his bit defensively

I find it weird tbh, he would have been so much more effective if he went to the line more... all the great halves do... surely he understood that

Yeah, that's exactly why I asked. Johnson was actually a pretty good defender in his latter years with us, but had a real disinterest in taking on the line. I guess the broken leg v Manly played a part in that. Kodi, I guess just doesn't like the contact.
 

Penrose Warrior

First Grade
Messages
8,637
And yeah, I'm not fond of that side he's picked. Hiku is our centre. Harris has excelled playing in the 12, not as a prop. And Curran, I hope he's improved on last year because he was Jazz last year without any actual football impact (ie just a penalty-causing dick).

We'll see how Evans goes, a Parra mate has maintained we've inherited a looks like Tarzan plays like Jane sort of scenario.
 

Rich102

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
11,549
On Katoa. I think he has a bit of skill and is suited to 13, Brown is playing him as a defensive second rower and this is taking it out of him.
I don't think anybody in the team is enjoying their football.
 

Big Marn

Juniors
Messages
2,353
i am wondering if Brown is remembering what a mess Bradman Best made of Hiku which lead to 2 tries that ended up costing us that game. Otherwise I agree he should be playing centre feeding our wingers as no one else has been up to that job.
 

Manu Vatuvei

Coach
Messages
16,739
Given the squad is pretty threadbare, seems bizarre to give Ale one game and then drop him? Thought he went well.
 

Manu Vatuvei

Coach
Messages
16,739
Also, Perham seems to be completely on the outer? What’s the go there? He may not be the elite talent he was touted as out of high school, but we really seem to be wasting him.
 

sup42

Juniors
Messages
1,994
I am ok with Brown transferring Katoa to reggies after reading his comments about building his confidence.

The flip side of that reveals they are concerned he has lost that confidence, and that can only be revealed by what a player themselves is saying about where they think their game is at.

He has a big future at the Warriors, so I think it is the right thing to protect him a bit in his development. It happens to so many players in that second year.

I guess I am feeling very philosophical about this year.
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
31,779
I hope I’m wrong, but I rated Brown as a blonde haired hooker, not so much as a bald coach... Hiku on the wing, ffs

Not as shit as Kearney but he’s working on a pretty awful NRL cv
 

nswarrior

Juniors
Messages
1,139
I hope I’m wrong, but I rated Brown as a blonde haired hooker, not so much as a bald coach... Hiku on the wing, ffs

Not as shit as Kearney but he’s working on a pretty awful NRL cv

not as shit as Kearney yet....

give him time, all shit things need some time
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
31,779
Brown is playing him as a defensive second rower and this is taking it out of him.
I don't think anybody in the team is enjoying their football.


Two very very salient points... need to find that balance, back in the day it's what Anderson managed - if we want a team of defensive bots, they should build the roster that way...
 
Messages
2,564
They wont go with that 17. I'm sure. I don't know why teams play the games for.

I am hoping this is what comes out

01. RTS (Needs to be support player not a battling ram)
02. Montoya (Though he was good at centre, his speed out wide is needed)
03. Pompey (Developing nicely. Really is starting to get his game on a roll now)
04. Hiku (The king has returned)
05. Maumalo (He will enjoy a try or 2 thank to the king inside him)
06. Nikorima / Turner (I know Turner will be on bench but praying for stint in the halves)
07. SOS (He gives it a dig all the time, need more support runners)
08. JTB (Late call up and starting, Evans drops to bench or out completely)
09. Egan (Needs to keep uninjured as we are in need of a good specialist hooker)
10. Ah Mau (Reliable no fuss forward)
11. Tohu Harris (Back @ 2nd Row)
12. Jack Murchie (Good hungry player love his dynamic)
13. Jazz Tevaga (His best position)

14. BMM (Beast)
15. Afoa (Energy off the bench)
16. Ale (Curran drops out, Ale to get another game for his good stint last week)
17. Turner / Nikorima (Utility Player)
 
Top