What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

New Zealand 2 will deal a massive blow to NZ rugby

titoelcolombiano

First Grade
Messages
8,255
Thanks


Article also talks about how the New Zealand rugby union has plans to stop kids playing rugby league

Gobs and Tito will be very interested in this as we were told by people on here there is no code war in nz and union are the good guys
Nah mate, it's just a forever war that is in our heads. Everywhere outside of Australia, RU is perfectly cooperative with RL and the two sports actually help each other out. That's what I'm reliably informed anyway
 

Matiunz

Juniors
Messages
1,725
I don't really understand either. Union training could undermine League training and vis versa.. I could see the conflict of interest. It's not controversial to me.
I'd rather the South Island Mana.
Curious if you even know what Mana means? Not sure it would go down too well and would probably go down like the pukana curse of the Warriors lol
 

Gobsmacked

First Grade
Messages
5,930
I’d be happy with either brand, both have ties to the area.
Finally good to see the NRL putting serious focus into NZ, wonder what will happen if their goals ever conflict with the NZRL though? I would like to see NZ producing players for NZ teams rather than generic NRL though
In all honesty, the biggest strength of the NRL is the diversity of squads. There's not really any teams that have a disproportionately local talent in their top 30.
This is a strength as it allows the brands to cross boarders, race and ethnicity.

Having a South Island team will create pathways and opportunities for players without leaving the Island but that doesn't necessarily mean that's where they'll stay.

Hopefully it results in more Kiwis playing League and a stronger national team, well it obviously will!

A big part of a players development for some, is leaving their comfort zone.
Aussies have been finding their best footy at the Warriors and obviously Kiwis have come of age in Australia.

A South Island team will give locals a solid start!
But it'll probably be similar to the GC where they produce lots of local talent and they all come of age some place else.
It's actually pretty rare you get a Johnson, Jones or Cambell.
 

Matiunz

Juniors
Messages
1,725
In all honesty, the biggest strength of the NRL is the diversity of squads. There's not really any teams that have a disproportionately local talent in their top 30.
This is a strength as it allows the brands to cross boarders, race and ethnicity.

Having a South Island team will create pathways and opportunities for players without leaving the Island but that doesn't necessarily mean that's where they'll stay.

Hopefully it results in more Kiwis playing League and a stronger national team, well it obviously will!

A big part of a players development for some, is leaving their comfort zone.
Aussies have been finding their best footy at the Warriors and obviously Kiwis have come of age in Australia.

A South Island team will give locals a solid start!
But it'll probably be similar to the GC where they produce lots of local talent and they all come of age some place else.
It's actually pretty rare you get a Johnson, Jones or Cambell.
Yeah as the Warriors proved the local talent soon went elsewhere , however from a selfish pov enjoying both sports I’d be fine with league getting the players for a local team but if they were going to an Aus team I’d rather they stayed with the local union team
 

Matiunz

Juniors
Messages
1,725
Im guessing lots of kiwi expats on the Gold Coast.

should have been Fiji in Christchurch and Cook Islands on the Gold Coast.
Tends to be more Fijians in Aus than NZ I believe? There’s been plenty of political tensions between NZ and Fiji last 20 odd years. Cookies I guess it’s closer if they wanted to come from Raro- knew a few n North Island but not sure there’s a heap in CHCH?
 

Gobsmacked

First Grade
Messages
5,930
Curious if you even know what Mana means? Not sure it would go down too well and would probably go down like the pukana curse of the Warriors lol
It means different things to different people. Everyone I met in NZ gave me a different answer and they were all just as cool. Can mean prestige, a spirit or force that lives in everything or pride.
To me and my translation in English I would say Heart.
My favorite word of any language.
There's the Melbourne Heart in A League and to me this is in that style of name with a distinctily Kiwi flavor.
I think it would be cool . But I'm sure the resident Kiwis will disagree because.. I'm Gobsmacked and I don't understand..bla bla bla
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
48,866
In all honesty, the biggest strength of the NRL is the diversity of squads. There's not really any teams that have a disproportionately local talent in their top 30.
This is a strength as it allows the brands to cross boarders, race and ethnicity.

Having a South Island team will create pathways and opportunities for players without leaving the Island but that doesn't necessarily mean that's where they'll stay.

Hopefully it results in more Kiwis playing League and a stronger national team, well it obviously will!

A big part of a players development for some, is leaving their comfort zone.
Aussies have been finding their best footy at the Warriors and obviously Kiwis have come of age in Australia.

A South Island team will give locals a solid start!
But it'll probably be similar to the GC where they produce lots of local talent and they all come of age some place else.
It's actually pretty rare you get a Johnson, Jones or Cambell.
I think the best teams going forward are ones that focus a lot on local juniors like Penrith

Titans look like doing that under Hannay

Always have imports but a good core of locals

If titans do it they are going to be such a strong club

Same for warriors or any club with a large junior catchment
 

Gobsmacked

First Grade
Messages
5,930
More kiwis on the Gold Coast and south east Queensland region likely to attend the game than in New Zealand sadly.
Kiwis on the GC have good high paying jobs and a modern stadium to attend.
Would have sold out in Christchurch but that's a smaller venue. Mt Smart host regular NRL games that are higher quality than seeing the Kiwis flog Fiji and that makes it a hard sell , Hamilton maybe but can be hit and miss. Eden Park is too big and so is the cake tin..

I don't think it's a bad choice.. or as they say on the GC.." Choice as bro.."
 

Gobsmacked

First Grade
Messages
5,930
I think the best teams going forward are ones that focus a lot on local juniors like Penrith

Titans look like doing that under Hannay

Always have imports but a good core of locals

If titans do it they are going to be such a strong club

Same for warriors or any club with a large junior catchment
Yeah things are moving that way and it's great for clubs to have that identity.
I cringe every time someone brings up having a draft.. I hate that idea! I like it how it is.
 

Matiunz

Juniors
Messages
1,725
It means different things to different people. Everyone I met in NZ gave me a different answer and they were all just as cool. Can mean prestige, a spirit or force that lives in everything or pride.
To me and my translation in English I would say Heart.
My favorite word of any language.
There's the Melbourne Heart in A League and to me this is in that style of name with a distinctily Kiwi flavor.
I think it would be cool . But I'm sure the resident Kiwis will disagree because.. I'm Gobsmacked and I don't understand..bla bla bla
Yeah you got some of the aspects, it’s one of those concepts that doesn’t have a direct translation. Just not sure it would be a popular choice due to how it’s obtained being a sports team? There was a stink (and a curse if you believe in such things) due to not getting the tongue right in the original Warriors Logo, might see it avoided for similar reasons
 

Matiunz

Juniors
Messages
1,725
I think the best teams going forward are ones that focus a lot on local juniors like Penrith

Titans look like doing that under Hannay

Always have imports but a good core of locals

If titans do it they are going to be such a strong club

Same for warriors or any club with a large junior catchment
Understand with professionalism sport players have become essentially mercenaries but I feel some of the community feel was lost and keeping as much of that as you can is beneficial. Otherwise it’s just x number of players that happen to play in a particular location this year
 

Wb1234

Immortal
Messages
48,866
Understand with professionalism sport players have become essentially mercenaries but I feel some of the community feel was lost and keeping as much of that as you can is beneficial. Otherwise it’s just x number of players that happen to play in a particular location this year
It’s lost a lot of it but league used to be you grew up in that area idolising the players and wanted to grow up and emulate them

A lot of the Penrith boys are proud of growing up in (a dump lol) like mt druitt or rooty hill

Most nrl clubs pay lip service to juniors only a few really use it properly

And hopefully they will dominate

Titans are a rabble and yet two of the best league schools in the country are on the Gold Coast

They don’t identify with the club and would rather play for the broncos or even a Sydney club
 

Gobsmacked

First Grade
Messages
5,930
Yeah you got some of the aspects, it’s one of those concepts that doesn’t have a direct translation. Just not sure it would be a popular choice due to how it’s obtained being a sports team? There was a stink (and a curse if you believe in such things) due to not getting the tongue right in the original Warriors Logo, might see it avoided for similar reasons
You can't please everyone. You can take many sports franchises around the world and how some people would have complained to begin with... Yankees, 49ers..
Usually as a rule, if you've upset people, you're probably on the right track!

You can't follow the " Crusaders" and complain about Mana..lol
 

Latest posts

Top