I must say that as a player, I never understood all the raps Barrett received back in the day. I can honestly say that I don't recall him ever tearing an opposition side apart like some of his contemporaries did before or since. Hell, I reckon Chris Sandow probably won more games off his own bat for Parra last year alone without even seeing out the season than Barrett did in his whole career. It probably happened once or twice , I didn't see every game Barrett played but I dunno, his performances in big games always left me cold, unconvinced, disappointed....
And now, for all the raps we heard him getting as he was doing his coaching apprenticeship, the reality seems a long way removed from being the best young coach we were lead to believe he was going to be. Early days, plus injuries haven't helped. But I certainly wouldn't be expecting miracles if I was a Manly fan in the short to medium term.