GongPanther
Referee
- Messages
- 28,372
Wed 12 Jul, 2017, 10:25pm
By Martin Gabor, National Correspondent, NRL.com
@MartinJGabor
1. James Tedesco
Put down an early kick but was safe as houses after that. Ran for a team-high 180 metres and threatened to poke his nose through the line a number of times only to be reeled in by Queensland's swarming defence. 6/10
2. Brett Morris
Came up with a magical try-saving tackle on Cooper Cronk when Queensland had all the momentum in the first half but was given no opportunities to showcase his wares in attack. 6.5/10
3. Josh Dugan
Came up with two first-half errors when the Blues were in rare attacking position but redeemed himself with the Blues' only try with a flying effort to give them a sniff. Was their most threatening player with ball in hand but didn't receive enough support from those around him. 6.5/10
4. Jarryd Hayne
He was touted as the man who could break the game open for the Blues but he never left first gear. The hero of the 2014 series was given no room to work with and simply could not find a way to get into the contest. 5.5/10
5. Blake Ferguson
Has now gone seven matches without an Origin try. It's a worrying stat when you consider Queensland duo Dane Gagai and Valentine Holmes scored for fun this series. There's no doubting his willingness to produce the tough carries but was found out several times by Holmes in defence. 4.5/10
6. James Maloney
Came up with some huge plays including a terrific chase to bring down Tim Glasby when he looked certain to score. Put in the kick for his side's sole try but also came up with nine missed tackles. 7/10
7. Mitchell Pearce
Rushed out of the line and forced Cameron Munster to run the ball; not a good tactic given the rookie's blinding speed and it led to Holmes's match-winning try. Game Three was seen as a make-or-break match for the highly-scrutinised halfback and unfortunately he didn't produce the sort of footy that he has at club level. Too many kicks were reeled in on the full and he didn't run it as much as he should have. 5/10
8. Aaron Woods
Delivered the sort of game we've come to expect from him on this stage with 80 metres and 23 tackles. Queensland did well to limit his offloads. 6/10
9. Nathan Peats
Led the team with 40 tackles but ran for just three meters, including none in the first half. It's difficult for a hooker when his side is on the back foot but Peats needed to ask more questions of the opposition's ruck defence. 5.5/10
10. Andrew Fifita
Produced one of the greatest Origin performances in the series opener but hasn't looked the same since. His trademark footwork, offloads and tackle busts went missing in Game Three with the Maroons blunting his impact from start to finish. 4.5/10
11. Boyd Cordner
Raced the clock to prove his fitness for the decider and produced a typically brave captain's knock with 149 metres and 22 tackles. Played the full 80 minutes but missed the tackle on Cameron Munster that led to Queensland's match-sealing try. 6.5/10
12. Josh Jackson
His poor play the ball in good field position paved the way for Queensland to march down field and open the scoring through Valentine Holmes. Got through plenty of work in the first half but didn't get back on until the game was well and truly over. 6/10
13. Tyson Frizell
You wouldn't have known he was playing busted given the way he put his body on the line. The lock forward came up with 31 bruising tackles and it was his tough carries to start the second half that got the Blues on the front foot. 7/10
Interchange
14. David Klemmer
Averaged 173 metres in the first two games so it was fitting he would rack up that figure on Wednesday with another powerhouse performance off the bench. His battering ram approach had the Maroons reeling at times and he was clearly NSW's best forward. 8/10
15. Wade Graham
Troubled the Maroons with his changes of angles and powerful carries but conceded a stripping penalty when the Maroons were on the ropes to let them off the hook. 6/10
16. Jake Trbojevic
He looks destined to be an Origin star for the next decade and is the glue the Blues can rely upon when the going gets tough. It won't be long until his brother joins him in the team. 7/10
17. Jack Bird
Was desperate for more minutes and had his prayers answered when he was thrust on early in the second half. Went looking for the ball and threatened to wreak havoc around the ruck but the opportunities did not present themselves. 5.5/10
http://www.nrl.com/origin-iii-nsw-player-ratings/tabid/10874/newsid/109902/default.aspx
Queensland player ratings
Wed 12 Jul, 2017, 10:20pm
By Chris Kennedy, National Correspondent, NRL.com
@CKennedy80
1. Billy Slater
As good now as he ever was. Brilliant in defence and a constant threat in attack with two line breaks. 9/10
2. Valentine Holmes
Scored a memorable hat-trick in just his second Origin with a good grounding for the opening try and fingertip work for his third. Did get outjumped by Dugan for Blues' only try. 8.5/10
3. Will Chambers
Not his most dominant Origin but did his job in attack and defence and quietly racked up an impressive 149 running metres. 7.5/10
4. Michael Morgan
If you hadn't seen him play before this game you'd have no clue he was not a regular centre. Wonderful work to set up the opening try of the night 7.5/10
5. Dane Gagai
A fine finish to a dominant series. Safe under the high ball, a massive handful on kick returns and team-high 168 run metres plus four tackle busts. 8.5/10
6. Cameron Munster
If there was a word that means "being overawed on Origin debut", Cameron Munster is the opposite of that. An inspired choice at five-eighth, pulled off a quality line break and pair of try assists to close out the game with a match-high six tackle busts. Best on ground. 9.5/10
7. Cooper Cronk
His cross-field kick for the second try of the game was crystallised perfection though he did have a try of his own knocked from his grasp. Controlled the match to a tee. 8.5/10
8. Dylan Napa
Massive involvement from the new leader of the Queensland pack though 61 metres and 26 tackles doesn’t capture the work he got through. Was a big part of Queensland's early rock-solid defence and charging line-speed. 7/10
9. Cameron Smith
Utterly pulled the Blues apart in the first half. He did completely bomb a try in very un-Smith-like fashion but was momentous otherwise. 9/10
10. Jarrod Wallace
Given far more minutes than in his understated debut; did his job to a tee in Queensland's early dominance and jagged a well-deserved try to seal the game late. 7/10
11. Gavin Cooper
Momentous in defence with a match-high 43 tackles and marshalled the Maroons' left edge brilliantly. 8.5/10
12. Matt Gillet
What Cooper did on the left, Gillett matched on the right; only Cooper bettered his 41 tackles. 7.5/10
13. Josh McGuire
A stack of work in the middle and continues to get under the Blues' skin. 7.5/10
Interchange
14. Ben Hunt
Given just eight minutes once the game was sealed. Did his best to get involved but no opportunity to impact the match. 3/10
15. Josh Papalii
Responded to his coach's criticism with arguably his best game of the series. Immediate impact after being injected early but limited to half an hour on field. 6.5/10
16. Coen Hess
Brought on earlier than in his muted Game Two debut but didn't finish with much more in the way of minutes or involvement. 6/10
17. Tim Glasby
Opportunistic line break early was the highlight of a steady half hour on the pitch. 5/10
http://www.nrl.com/origin-iii-queensland-player-ratings/tabid/10874/newsid/109903/default.aspx
Hayne,Woods and Cordner over 5's?
By Martin Gabor, National Correspondent, NRL.com
@MartinJGabor
1. James Tedesco
Put down an early kick but was safe as houses after that. Ran for a team-high 180 metres and threatened to poke his nose through the line a number of times only to be reeled in by Queensland's swarming defence. 6/10
2. Brett Morris
Came up with a magical try-saving tackle on Cooper Cronk when Queensland had all the momentum in the first half but was given no opportunities to showcase his wares in attack. 6.5/10
3. Josh Dugan
Came up with two first-half errors when the Blues were in rare attacking position but redeemed himself with the Blues' only try with a flying effort to give them a sniff. Was their most threatening player with ball in hand but didn't receive enough support from those around him. 6.5/10
4. Jarryd Hayne
He was touted as the man who could break the game open for the Blues but he never left first gear. The hero of the 2014 series was given no room to work with and simply could not find a way to get into the contest. 5.5/10
5. Blake Ferguson
Has now gone seven matches without an Origin try. It's a worrying stat when you consider Queensland duo Dane Gagai and Valentine Holmes scored for fun this series. There's no doubting his willingness to produce the tough carries but was found out several times by Holmes in defence. 4.5/10
6. James Maloney
Came up with some huge plays including a terrific chase to bring down Tim Glasby when he looked certain to score. Put in the kick for his side's sole try but also came up with nine missed tackles. 7/10
7. Mitchell Pearce
Rushed out of the line and forced Cameron Munster to run the ball; not a good tactic given the rookie's blinding speed and it led to Holmes's match-winning try. Game Three was seen as a make-or-break match for the highly-scrutinised halfback and unfortunately he didn't produce the sort of footy that he has at club level. Too many kicks were reeled in on the full and he didn't run it as much as he should have. 5/10
8. Aaron Woods
Delivered the sort of game we've come to expect from him on this stage with 80 metres and 23 tackles. Queensland did well to limit his offloads. 6/10
9. Nathan Peats
Led the team with 40 tackles but ran for just three meters, including none in the first half. It's difficult for a hooker when his side is on the back foot but Peats needed to ask more questions of the opposition's ruck defence. 5.5/10
10. Andrew Fifita
Produced one of the greatest Origin performances in the series opener but hasn't looked the same since. His trademark footwork, offloads and tackle busts went missing in Game Three with the Maroons blunting his impact from start to finish. 4.5/10
11. Boyd Cordner
Raced the clock to prove his fitness for the decider and produced a typically brave captain's knock with 149 metres and 22 tackles. Played the full 80 minutes but missed the tackle on Cameron Munster that led to Queensland's match-sealing try. 6.5/10
12. Josh Jackson
His poor play the ball in good field position paved the way for Queensland to march down field and open the scoring through Valentine Holmes. Got through plenty of work in the first half but didn't get back on until the game was well and truly over. 6/10
13. Tyson Frizell
You wouldn't have known he was playing busted given the way he put his body on the line. The lock forward came up with 31 bruising tackles and it was his tough carries to start the second half that got the Blues on the front foot. 7/10
Interchange
14. David Klemmer
Averaged 173 metres in the first two games so it was fitting he would rack up that figure on Wednesday with another powerhouse performance off the bench. His battering ram approach had the Maroons reeling at times and he was clearly NSW's best forward. 8/10
15. Wade Graham
Troubled the Maroons with his changes of angles and powerful carries but conceded a stripping penalty when the Maroons were on the ropes to let them off the hook. 6/10
16. Jake Trbojevic
He looks destined to be an Origin star for the next decade and is the glue the Blues can rely upon when the going gets tough. It won't be long until his brother joins him in the team. 7/10
17. Jack Bird
Was desperate for more minutes and had his prayers answered when he was thrust on early in the second half. Went looking for the ball and threatened to wreak havoc around the ruck but the opportunities did not present themselves. 5.5/10
http://www.nrl.com/origin-iii-nsw-player-ratings/tabid/10874/newsid/109902/default.aspx
Queensland player ratings
Wed 12 Jul, 2017, 10:20pm
By Chris Kennedy, National Correspondent, NRL.com
@CKennedy80
1. Billy Slater
As good now as he ever was. Brilliant in defence and a constant threat in attack with two line breaks. 9/10
2. Valentine Holmes
Scored a memorable hat-trick in just his second Origin with a good grounding for the opening try and fingertip work for his third. Did get outjumped by Dugan for Blues' only try. 8.5/10
3. Will Chambers
Not his most dominant Origin but did his job in attack and defence and quietly racked up an impressive 149 running metres. 7.5/10
4. Michael Morgan
If you hadn't seen him play before this game you'd have no clue he was not a regular centre. Wonderful work to set up the opening try of the night 7.5/10
5. Dane Gagai
A fine finish to a dominant series. Safe under the high ball, a massive handful on kick returns and team-high 168 run metres plus four tackle busts. 8.5/10
6. Cameron Munster
If there was a word that means "being overawed on Origin debut", Cameron Munster is the opposite of that. An inspired choice at five-eighth, pulled off a quality line break and pair of try assists to close out the game with a match-high six tackle busts. Best on ground. 9.5/10
7. Cooper Cronk
His cross-field kick for the second try of the game was crystallised perfection though he did have a try of his own knocked from his grasp. Controlled the match to a tee. 8.5/10
8. Dylan Napa
Massive involvement from the new leader of the Queensland pack though 61 metres and 26 tackles doesn’t capture the work he got through. Was a big part of Queensland's early rock-solid defence and charging line-speed. 7/10
9. Cameron Smith
Utterly pulled the Blues apart in the first half. He did completely bomb a try in very un-Smith-like fashion but was momentous otherwise. 9/10
10. Jarrod Wallace
Given far more minutes than in his understated debut; did his job to a tee in Queensland's early dominance and jagged a well-deserved try to seal the game late. 7/10
11. Gavin Cooper
Momentous in defence with a match-high 43 tackles and marshalled the Maroons' left edge brilliantly. 8.5/10
12. Matt Gillet
What Cooper did on the left, Gillett matched on the right; only Cooper bettered his 41 tackles. 7.5/10
13. Josh McGuire
A stack of work in the middle and continues to get under the Blues' skin. 7.5/10
Interchange
14. Ben Hunt
Given just eight minutes once the game was sealed. Did his best to get involved but no opportunity to impact the match. 3/10
15. Josh Papalii
Responded to his coach's criticism with arguably his best game of the series. Immediate impact after being injected early but limited to half an hour on field. 6.5/10
16. Coen Hess
Brought on earlier than in his muted Game Two debut but didn't finish with much more in the way of minutes or involvement. 6/10
17. Tim Glasby
Opportunistic line break early was the highlight of a steady half hour on the pitch. 5/10
http://www.nrl.com/origin-iii-queensland-player-ratings/tabid/10874/newsid/109903/default.aspx
Hayne,Woods and Cordner over 5's?
