The Game 2021 Judiciary Charges

[macnaz]

Hand between the legs, lifting, above the horizontal and following through the tackle with downward force.. if lame crusher tackles get a week then that tackle has the ingredients to cause equal or a more extensive injury. Not expecting a suspension but it deserves one.

 

[gerg]

It didn't even deserve a penalty. He wasn't lifted above the horizontal. Landed on his back. You blokes must lap up the Daily Telegraph drama.

 

[guyver78]

It didn't even deserve a penalty. He wasn't lifted above the horizontal. Landed on his back. You blokes must lap up the Daily Telegraph drama.

lol which game were you watching? So what did you think of the Aloiai tackle that got him 3-4 weeks on Friday night?

 

[gerg]

lol which game were you watching? So what did you think of the Aloiai tackle that got him 3-4 weeks on Friday night?

NRL news: Manly forward Josh Aloiai charged, set to miss start of next season

Cleary to play in GF after escaping charge over lifting tackle

Big Panthers boost as Cleary cleared for GF but three stars charged

www.google.com

I don't think Aloia's deserves 3-4 weeks but comparing the two tackles, Cleary's isn't even close. Nicholls is dropped from a greater height, lands on his shoulder and neck and goes beyond the horizontal. Three things which didn't occur with the Cleary tackle.

 

[guyver78]

NRL news: Manly forward Josh Aloiai charged, set to miss start of next season

Cleary to play in GF after escaping charge over lifting tackle

Big Panthers boost as Cleary cleared for GF but three stars charged

www.google.com

I don't think Aloia's deserves 3-4 weeks but comparing the two tackles, Cleary's isn't even close. Nicholls is dropped from a greater height, lands on his shoulder and neck and goes beyond the horizontal. Three things which didn't occur with the Cleary tackle.

Disagree. I don’t think there was much difference between the Aloiai and Cleary tackles.

 

[no name]

Lol, the Aloiai tackle is far worse than Cleary’s.
Bromwich’s foot barely leaves the ground and then he lands on his back.
He rubs his head to get the tackle on report for a free interchange.

 

[Bazal]

Lol there's 3-4 weeks difference between Aioli's and Clearys tackles.


And the Aioli charge is pretty much right

 

[guyver78]

Lol, the Aloiai tackle is far worse than Cleary’s.
Bromwich’s foot barely leaves the ground and then he lands on his back.
He rubs his head to get the tackle on report for a free interchange.

So you’d give Cleary nothing for that???

what about the Isaac Luke tackle in 2014, nothing in that but he was still suspended.

 

[Last Week]

It'll be grade 1 at most. So a fine.

 

[Last Week]

So you’d give Cleary nothing for that???

what about the Isaac Luke tackle in 2014, nothing in that but he was still suspended.

He was charged with a grade 1. If that was today, Luke would only have had to pay a fine.

 

[no name]

So you’d give Cleary nothing for that???

what about the Isaac Luke tackle in 2014, nothing in that but he was still suspended.

Lol, Issac Luke cartwheeled SBW’s legs over his head.
That far was worse than Aloiai’s which was worse than Cleary’s.

 

[guyver78]

Hand between the legs, lifting, above the horizontal and following through the tackle with downward force.. if lame crusher tackles get a week then that tackle has the ingredients to cause equal or a more extensive injury. Not expecting a suspension but it deserves one.

Gents, this pretty much sums it up..
Hope he gets off tho

 

[Valheru]

It didn't even deserve a penalty. He wasn't lifted above the horizontal. Landed on his back. You blokes must lap up the Daily Telegraph drama.

Dude his leg was vertical facing the sky.

I don't think he should cop a suspension but don't pretend it wasn't a penalty that has been given consistently for years now.

 

[guyver78]

Dude his leg was vertical facing the sky.

I don't think he should cop a suspension but don't pretend it wasn't a penalty that has been given consistently for years now.

They’re off their heads lol
above the horizontal, forceful and the guy lands on the back of his neck.

 

[gerg]

Dude his leg was vertical facing the sky.

I don't think he should cop a suspension but don't pretend it wasn't a penalty that has been given consistently for years now.

I don't think it was beyond the horizontal and his other foot was on the ground. If anything, in this sort of situation it is the bloke grabbing the upper body that contributes negatively to the tackle.

 

[guyver78]

He’s free to play. The inconsistencies in the NRL continue…

 

[lockyno1]

We all know they will let the chin off

 

[guyver78]

We all know they will let the chin off

lol it’s complete bullshit hay

 

[soc123_au]

He’s free to play. The inconsistencies in the NRL continue…

 

[lockyno1]

lol it’s complete bullshit hay

No shock one bit