What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2025 NRL Draw news, venues, info

Saxon

Bench
Messages
3,179
Okay, so there are issues for many teams about an unfair draw.
I’ll start with the Storm.
How is it fair that they get 7 home games and 3 byes by Round 15?
It was the same in 2024. They are a great side and deserved Grand Finalists, but they were ahead of the pack most of the year on the ladder because they got on a massive roll of home wins. Success breeds success, so don’t tell me having the majority of your home games in the first half of the season is in any way a disadvantage.
The draw sucks.
Oh have a f**king whinge.
So they have 7 home games in the first 14 weeks (6 actually, because one of those "home games" is magic round in Brisbane. Hardly half an hour up the road.) and 5 in the last 13 weeks. How brutally unfair.
And two byes around Origin and one in week two (rather than late in the season where everyone could use a rest). Outrageous!

Also, if you don't understand that bye points are an artifice to comfort the hard of thinking who can't actually process the concept that a team that has played more games has the opportunity to accumulate more points but everyone will play the same number of games eventually, then there's no hope for you.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,036
This thread is moot
The only answer that is nessesary is PENRITH!!!!
That's all that matters, and all other clubs are just beneath them, your draw is automatically stuffed if you have to play them twice, even then they'll just beat you come finals even if you do
 

Scootsie

Juniors
Messages
184
The draw sucks and it is detrimental to the game. There are just too many holes in how it is managed. That’s the cold hard reality.
I haven’t read anything to say otherwise, the NRL have just stuffed up.
The only people having a whinge on here are those motivated by self interest and those lacking the intellectual capacity to see that the draw could be managed 100 better ways.
 
Messages
4,309
Don't get me wrong, not saying it's a conspiracy against the roosters. It just seems easy to me to ensure everyone has at least one bye directly before an origin week and then also spread them apart somehwat.

We have 3 byes from rounds 10 - 17 and you guys from rounds 11 - 18.
Re no byes during Origin player unavailable rounds, do we know if that was requested by the Roosters. I know the league takes those things into account.

But if not, that is horrible. I would be pretty p!ssed as a Roosters fans.

In terms of not having a bye in the last 10 rounds (both Penrith and Roosters), surely that is going to happen in a comp where for a majority of rounds there is only one team on the bye. The alternative would be to only play 7 games a week for a five weeks coming into the finals; might make the draw slightly fairer but the networks would not be happy.
 
Messages
15,025
The only problem I have with the draw is that teams who play each other twice do so too close together. Just 1 example:

Round 2: Bulldogs v Titans
Round 9: Titans v Bulldogs

Teams should play every other team before they play someone a second time.
We play the Knights and Eels twice each before ANZAC Day. That side of the draw is a little poor but the cream rises. No team has ever won or lost the premiership because of a draw.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,036
The only problem I have with the draw is that teams who play each other twice do so too close together. Just 1 example:

Round 2: Bulldogs v Titans
Round 9: Titans v Bulldogs

Teams should play every other team before they play someone a second time.
A conference or pool system, would solve that, play your pool of 4 (5 including you) then everyone else then your pool again, this would create an instant rivalry with teams in your pool, and reason to be playing them twice, and make those dead rubbers near end of season more intense
20 teams = 23 rounds... 8 inhouse pool games, 15 outhouse pool games, add a magic round for an even 24 rounds, 12 home 12 away, let the broadcasters choose the magic round line ups, top 2 from each conference enters finals
images-50.jpeg
 
Last edited:

Canard

Immortal
Messages
35,609
Well, start with how they used to do it - pull the teams out of a hat, and alternate each week between home and away games. That’s just one method that doesn’t involve Media and sponsorship moguls wanting to feather their own nests.
I don't believe it's ever been done like that. And the alternating H/A idea takes about 20 seconds of thought to realise its impossible.

It's an insane way to create a draw from a commercial perspective also.
 

Latest posts

Top