What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

2026 Super League Discussion

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,379
That's not the wording thats been used all off season.
York get a blockbuster start in front of a sold out stadium and play the comps best team who]ll have one eye on the following week and the other on Vegas, Rovers get an easier game than could have been without much travel. Everyone's a winner.
Last Year Cas came within 1 point of us in first game, by time we played them again in the return fixture we were up to speed and smashed them 48-0!
 

Billythekid

First Grade
Messages
7,183
Sports purists will argue P&R is intrinsic to meaningful competition. Business purists will argue it makes no financial sense to have teams changing divisions when theres a massive economic gulf between the two divisions.
English RL has tried both many times, cant say Ive seen one has really performed better than the other over the history of the game.
The main problem is that football is a fundamentally different game than league. Things like P&R amd even things like the champions league work so much better in football. A physical sport like league just doesn’t work as well IMO.

I also think it’s a way to be different to football in the UK.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,379
The main problem is that football is a fundamentally different game than league. Things like P&R amd even things like the champions league work so much better in football. A physical sport like league just doesn’t work as well IMO.

I also think it’s a way to be different to football in the UK.
It’s not just football, most sport has p&R model in uk. It’s part of the sporting culture of Europe, where as franchising/licensing is more in the Australian and American sports culture.
Both have their pros and cons.
 

Taking The Two

Juniors
Messages
843
Rugby League has had longer periods of history without P&R than it has with P&R. Many will only remember a time where we have had it, so it feels like it’s a must because that’s what people have always known.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,379
Rugby League has had longer periods of history without P&R than it has with P&R. Many will only remember a time where we have had it, so it feels like it’s a must because that’s what people have always known.
But was it better without it? I’ve seen both models in play and can’t say I saw much difference in club performance or performance of the sport. Img grading system is the first in my 46 years following the game I’ve actually seen clubs lift their game off the field En masse.
 

Taking The Two

Juniors
Messages
843
But was it better without it? I’ve seen both models in play and can’t say I saw much difference in club performance or performance of the sport. Img grading system is the first in my 46 years following the game I’ve actually seen clubs lift their game off the field En masse.

That’s what the sport has to define; whether the sport is better off with or without it? Off field, we’ve seen more in 5 years collectively than I can remember in my lifetime and while that has enhanced clubs commercially, we’re yet to really see how it affects onfield and fan support because we’ve not really had a period where those clubs in Super League have been “locked in” for any sort of length of time, though we won’t be far away from that as we only have 5 B grade clubs in SL under IMG and Bradford, Cas and Huddersfield are less than 0.5 points from hitting 15 points and becoming an A.
 

Billythekid

First Grade
Messages
7,183
It’s not just football, most sport has p&R model in uk. It’s part of the sporting culture of Europe, where as franchising/licensing is more in the Australian and American sports culture.
Both have their pros and cons.
But only 1 of those sports is a behemoth like football. The other sports having it doesn't necessarily mean it's the best option for those sports.
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,379
3 seasons as head coach
100 games
74 wins
5 finals
3 trophies

and all with a club that hadnt won a trophy for 40 years!

yeh SuperCoach!
 

Coastbloke

Bench
Messages
4,325
Sitting here in Oz watching a Doco on English SL Club Hull KR where they interview French RL Star Theo Fage signing autographs. See where I’m going?

Las Vegas coming up. Australian and English teams. USA v Scotland.

How much money and effort to give this game a nudge and stare down union..
 

Perth Red

Post Whore
Messages
75,379
At least 1300 away fans predicted at Hull, this so why clubs are pleased to see Bradford back in SL!
 
Top