Horrie Is God
First Grade
- Messages
- 8,073
Gilly & Maher are worried about how stressful the captaincy will be for Watto..
http://www.foxsports.com.au/cricket/australia/former-players-adam-gilchrist-and-jimmy-maher-say-captaincy-could-be-too-much-for-shane-watson/story-fn2mcu3x-1226540222655#.UNEUyeQ3ufU
http://www.foxsports.com.au/cricket/australia/former-players-adam-gilchrist-and-jimmy-maher-say-captaincy-could-be-too-much-for-shane-watson/story-fn2mcu3x-1226540222655#.UNEUyeQ3ufU
Former players Adam Gilchrist and Jimmy Maher say captaincy could be too much for Shane Watson..
By Peter Badel The Courier-Mail December 19, 2012 10:50AM
Australian cricket fans have written off Shane Watson's captaincy credentials as Michael Clarke's battle to be fit for the Boxing Day Test ignited debate over Cricket Australia's leadership succession plan.
Vice-captain Watson will be officially ordained as Australia's 44th Test skipper if Clarke fails to overcome a hamstring complaint in time for the second Test against Sri Lanka at the MCG.
Watson was installed as Clarke's deputy in March 2011 after Ricky Ponting quit the captaincy, but doubts linger over his leadership ability given his already onerous responsibilities with bat and ball.
Among the concerns are Watson's tactical prowess and his own form issues with the bat after twin failures of 30 and 5 in the first Test against Sri Lanka at Blundstone Arena.
But former deputy Adam Gilchrist, who famously led Australia to a rare series win in India after an injury to skipper Ricky Ponting, believes the daunting job can bring out the best in Watson.
"It was a daunting challenge which ultimately I was glad to take on and I think Shane, if he was given the opportunity, would look at it in a similar light," said Gilchrist, who piloted Australia to their first series win in India for 35 years in late 2004.
"I expect he would be capable but we can't be sure until he does it.
"I didn't ever covet the position in a full-time role. When Ricky broke his thumb before India, almost immediately I felt sick in the stomach about having to take on the captaincy, not so much in leading the team but in a personal sense going to India where I had a few demons to bury myself going there.
"What makes it hard is the perception, even internally, that you might not be up to the job.
"I just tried to do it without making any big statements and I think Shane would adopt a similar approach."
Watson is not a complete captaincy novice. The dual Allan Border Medallist skippered the one-day side in eight matches earlier this year -- ironically after Clarke succumbed to a hamstring injury -- leading the side to four wins, three losses and a tie.
Former Australian one-day opener Jimmy Maher, who played with Watson at Queensland, said the 31-year-old faced a heavy workload juggling the captaincy with all-round duties.
"It is a huge burden for him, no question," he said.
"It's a huge load to carry. Australia has always been reluctant to make wicketkeepers captain for exactly the same reason.
"It will be a tough gig, but I think it's one that Shane Watson is up to.
"I captained Queensland as an opener and even then I had a lot to contend with.
"Doing it as a genuine all-rounder has got to present some enormous challenges, but Shane is one bloke who enjoys being directly in the game and this gives him another way to be involved."
Former Test selector Trevor Hohns believes Watson would not be daunted by the captaincy challenge.
"Shane knows his game, he knows what he has to do, it's not like he's a newcomer," he said.
"It is normal for the vice-captain to step up in those circumstances, if it is just a short-term thing normally the deputy should step up.
"He is a very experienced cricketer, one of the most experienced in the team with Michael Hussey.
"He should be able to handle the job, no doubts about that."