Rammo said:
To call Federer the best player in history is such an overstatement imo.
Who has he beaten of any substance in this tournament?
Sampras nailed players who were Federer's standard to win his Grand Slams, Federer has had noone to beat.
He had to beat players like Agassi, Rafter, Courier, Chang, Becker, Edberg even.
Courier and Chang are nothing special. Courier and Chang did well for a short while in the changeover period. The same as when Hewitt was doing well a couple of years back. The changeover period. And Rafter was also not that good. His 1997 Slam as the biggest fluke as he didn't have to play anyone. His 1998 USO was given to him by the umpire in the 1st round when he was being hammered, down 2-sets to love and a break, the umpire decided to make an overrule that would have guarenteed victory to Arazi. Don't get me wrong - Courier, Chang, and Rafter weren't bad, but not superstars. They're equal to the likes of Roddick, Nalbandian, etc.
Sampras never had to beat Edberg to win a Grand Slam. The only 2 times Sampras-Edberg played at Grand Slams, Edberg won.
The only times Becker and Sampras played at Grand Slams was nearing the end of Beckers career. Same as when Federer plays Agassi at Grand Slams now.
Nalbandian and Safin are the only one's that can get anywhere near him.
- Safin yes on fast hardcourt, indoor hard, carpet and clay. Safin would be better than Federer on carpet.
- Nedal on slow hardcourt and clay. Nadal would be better on clay than Federer
Grass would be the only surface where no one can get close to him.
Nalbandian can't get anywhere near Federer. Federer has absolutly hammered Nalbandian the last few times
2005 US Open - 62 64 61
..........(Hardcourt - Decoturf)
2004 AO Open - 75 64 57 63
......(Hardcourt - Rebound Ace)
2003 Masters - 63 60
...............(Carpet)
2005 Masters Cup Federer was injured, but still won 1 of the 2 matches played
RR - 63 26 64
Final - 76 76 26 16 67
So take the 2005 MC out, since December 2003, Federer has totally dominated. At the same time Hewitt had a 7-2 winning record over Federer. Hasn't been close since. Federer has gone to another level since then.