DCE in 2013 and Simple Jack in 2019 anyone?
A lot of people reckon Luke Phillips should have received it in 2000.
I've already mentioned this.
When media darlings like JT get it for just showing up, the least they could do is give it to someone from the winning team.
2013 in particular, the roosters won the last 25 minutes 18-0. How on earth you find a winner from the losing team in that situation is beyond me.