What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Chalk lines up on late scratching Spleen injury floors Frawley

aussies1st

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,154
Canberra Raiders coach Matt Elliott has backed utility Marshall Chalk to handle the added pressure of a starting position in Saturday night's qualifying final against the Bulldogs.

A spleen injury yesterday robbed winger Craig Frawley of his starting role, forcing Elliott to elevate Chalk from the bench into the starting 13.


Eighteenth man Ben Jones has come onto the bench as a result of the enforced reshuffle.

Frawley ruptured his spleen when attempting to mark a high ball during Canberra's 26-24 victory over the Sharks last Saturday night.

Feeling "sore and sorry" after the contest, Frawley vomited on and off the following day and felt pain when having to take deep breaths.

He requested scans with Raiders doctors yesterday and expected the results to show a bruised or even possibly a broken rib.

But the result was worse than he had hoped for, with the spleen injury ruling him out for the Raiders' entire finals campaign.

"I remember getting hit and was no good the next day but I came good Monday, except for the pain when breathing, and thought I'd be sweet," Frawley told The Canberra Times yesterday.

"When I got the scan results back, I just couldn't believe it. It wasn't what I was expecting.

"I'll be okay for next year but as for this year, no matter how far the boys get, you can't really stuff around with this type of thing because of possible internal bleeding."

Frawley joins teammates David Howell, Tom Learoyd-Lahrs, Andrew Lomu, Trevor Thurling and Josh Miller on the sidelines until 2007.

Despite having to change his starting line-up three days before kick-off, Elliott remained confident his replacements had enjoyed enough experience with the senior side this season to successfully cover Frawley's absence.

"In some ways I'm excited about what Chalky will bring to us," the coach said.

"He's actually got a little bit of a dimension to his play that we miss when he's not out there.

"Frawls is a loss but Marshall Chalk has been in outstanding form.


"The team has a huge amount of faith in Chalky and the boys don't allow me to not have him in the team so I feel very confident about that."

Chalk has played 19 NRL games this season, the majority off the bench. He started the year playing in the backline before the Raiders' coaching staff developed him into a back-rower.

But his return to the wing, where he will link with Adam Mogg on the right-side defensive line, had the 25-year-old excited.

"Last time I played on the wing I had a bit of success so if I get options again, I can take advantage of that," Chalk said.

"Over the past five or six years I've played a lot in the outside backs and it doesn't take much to fall back into that roll. "

In early markets issued yesterday, the Raiders were rank outsiders at $3.30 to beat the heavily favoured Bulldogs outfit, rated $1.30.

Jones, who played his first NRL match last weekend since the Raiders lost to Melbourne in round 15, was shocked yesterday when told of his inclusion into Saturday night's side.

Jones was initially on standby for Kris Kahler, who is hopeful of overcoming a knee injury in time for Canberra's do-or-die contest.

"I've got the cold sweats now. This is the first I've heard of it. I'm sure once I get out on the field I'll be right," Jones said.

"The Bulldogs do have a very dominant forward pack but I think we'll have a good game plan to try and get over the top of them."

The Bulldogs will also be without their share of talent for the contest with Reni Maitua, Tony Grimaldi, Roy Asotasi and Willie Tonga sidelined with injury.

http://canberra.yourguide.com.au/de...ry_id=507725&category=Rugby League&m=9&y=2006

Looks like Chalk will be the winger for however long our final series goes on for.
 

hrundi99

First Grade
Messages
8,414
It's easy to bag Frawls but gee whiz, he has bad luck.

He's obviously quite injury prone, so in a way it's quite an acheivement to have made it to the NRL to begin with.

The value of his contract does need to be questioned though.
 

Walt Flanigan

Referee
Messages
20,727
Chalk's defence better be up to scratch this week. A repeat of the Souths game and we'll get smashed by the likes of El Masri and Utai.
 

dubby

Bench
Messages
3,005
Where are those who were quick to bag the guy for dropping the ball now?

Ditto:Chalks defence. He needs to be switched on this time.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
as ive said elsewhere, i think everyone is a little concerned about chalks defence on the wing after that souths game, but he'll likely mark up on Utai, id think anyways, logically that makes sence, two pretty ordinary positioning wingers on each other, Chalk is a strong defender when he gets them too, which we'll need on utai
 

paulquinn49

Bench
Messages
3,410
Raider_69 said:
as ive said elsewhere, i think everyone is a little concerned about chalks defence on the wing after that souths game, but he'll likely mark up on Utai, id think anyways, logically that makes sence, two pretty ordinary positioning wingers on each other, Chalk is a strong defender when he gets them too, which we'll need on utai

Damn, I must have missed that tackle.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Quinn i know your not a fan of chalk, but no need to be silly about it
Chalk is generally pretty poor reading defence, ala Adam Mogg back in the days, but when he gets a handle on them (again like mogg, it has become rare atm) they rarely brush him off to score. He either makes the tackle or gets no where near it, this season, in particular the souths game, more often then not, he's got no where near it!
 

dubby

Bench
Messages
3,005
Chalk cannot read the defence very well; he has to be one of the worst..Often enough he is stood up and is made look ordinary.
Against Utai he should go ok tho, Utai is not elusive; he's a power runner who likes to run over people. Chalk likes to put a hit on, so it should work out.
 

woodgers

Bench
Messages
3,569
hahaha, people who support Howell throwing stones about positioning in defence and tackling ability. Now i've heard everything.
 

aussies1st

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,154
Defence is what he needs to work on this off season, he was shown up last week tackling Mr Invisible. But I'm sure he will more than want to make up for his last shocker on the wing.
 

paulquinn49

Bench
Messages
3,410
woodgers said:
hahaha, people who support Howell throwing stones about positioning in defence and tackling ability. Now i've heard everything.

Difference being one cops it and the other doesnt. Simply because a majority choose not to like the other.

I think youll find most would agree Howell is superior to Chalk now days anyway. :cool:
 

dubby

Bench
Messages
3,005
woodgers said:
hahaha, people who support Howell throwing stones about positioning in defence and tackling ability. Now i've heard everything.

And who would that be Uncle Woody Woodgers?
 

woodgers

Bench
Messages
3,569
paulquinn49 said:
Difference being one cops it and the other doesnt. Simply because a majority choose not to like the other.

I think youll find most would agree Howell is superior to Chalk now days anyway. :cool:

Hardly. One missed a few tackles against Souths and it is still being talked about, the other cost us countless tries and games through complete inept defensive skills for over 2 bloody years. One couldn't break the line of the Queanbeyan Blues, the other puts his body on the line every time he runs the ball.

Not in a million years is Howell superior mate. And if people do, it proves that there are complete morons watching the Raiders.
 

Edwahu

Bench
Messages
3,697
Chalky is about the best line runner in the team. He always looks dangerous running off Smith and Carney and comes looking for the football. Like Elliot said he adds another dimension to our attack.

Yeah, his defense isnt great but it isnt great wherever he plays. At least on the wing he can add more to our attack then off the bench.
 

woodgers

Bench
Messages
3,569
dubby said:
And who would that be Uncle Woody Woodgers?

I'm sure people can remember what players they rate.

I'm not in the mood to argue with you this week Dub. There are more important things to think about.
 

skeepe

Immortal
Messages
48,303
I rate Howell, and I'm not that huge on Chalk... I suppose that makes me a moron
 

Macko8

Juniors
Messages
1,369
It makes me feel a bit more confident of winning on saturday night with chalk being named on the wing. Shame about frawley but at least chalk charges at the line and doesnt drop bombs. Lets hope for our sake that his defence in the souths game was a one off.
Im really confident chalk can do a good job.
 

Latest posts

Top