Chris Walker Try

[Liam]

bullsh*t.
Discuss.

 

[Red Bear]

that was quick

 

[Phillips]

Try.

 

[seanoff]

worse decision was the dragons no try.

 

[Iafeta]

No try. Deliberate attempt to get past a defender with an unfair tap forward.

Then again, it is Paul Simpkins, AKA the man who sent Wade McKinnon off for a phantom knee to Taniela Tuiaki's head. He is the worst referee of all time, just ahead of Steve Clark.

 

[Ianc]

He was offside, no need to worry about knock forward.

 

[gong_eagle]

it was awarded so it is a try

 

[Kornstar]

He is the worst referee of all time, just ahead of Steve Clark.

100% correct, the sooner these 2 morons retire, the better our game will be!

 

[innsaneink]

No try. Deliberate attempt to get past a defender with an unfair tap forward.

Then again, it is Paul Simpkins, AKA the man who sent Wade McKinnon off for a phantom knee to Taniela Tuiaki's head. He is the worst referee of all time, just ahead of Steve Clark.

How do you know it was a deliberate tap forward, it was just out of his reach at full stretch in mid air, he looked to me to be attemptring to control it as best he could...fair try imo, the offside was negligible

 

[petetheileet]

it was awarded so it is a try

hillarious!!!

off side, no try

 

[Iafeta]

How do you know it was a deliberate tap forward, it was just out of his reach at full stretch in mid air, he looked to me to be attemptring to control it as best he could...fair try imo, the offside was negligible

He makes no attempt whatsoever to catch it. He had a fair chance at bringing it under control. He doesn't, instead he taps it in an upward motion past Nightingale. If he was trying to catch it, he would have tried to use two hands or tap it not so far forward, but certainly not flick the ball in an upward motion over the fullback.

 

[parra-matters]

for mine the first 3 titans tries all have question marks over them.

 

[God-King Dean]

I have no problem with the tap forward. He didn't knock it over Nightingale's head. I have a problem with the offside.

 

[Collateral]

Walker Try = No try...Offside and knocked it forward to gain an advantage.
Second Titans try = No Try foward pass.

No Try ruling against the Dragons = Try...Scott Prince takes his own player out and is awarded a penalty.

 

[Rovelli]

I was more irate about the offside. Could we conclude he was 100% onside. Tap-back was contentious as always.

 

[innsaneink]

He makes no attempt whatsoever to catch it. He had a fair chance at bringing it under control. He doesn't, instead he taps it in an upward motion past Nightingale. If he was trying to catch it, he would have tried to use two hands or tap it not so far forward, but certainly not flick the ball in an upward motion over the fullback.

I disagree....I think he was attempting to control it...Nightingale was nowhere near the ball...the ball was out of his reach on first attempt, so you cant say he had a fair chance at controlling it, I think he was off balance as well avoiding nightingale so two hands wouldve been impossible for him

 

[Cletus]

I disagree....I think he was attempting to control it...Nightingale was nowhere near the ball...the ball was out of his reach on first attempt, so you cant say he had a fair chance at controlling it, I think he was off balance as well avoiding nightingale so two hands wouldve been impossible for him

Exactly, he didn't even tap it over Nightingale. Plus he was onside.

TRY!!

 

[Iafeta]

He was deadset offside at the bare minimum.

 

[Iafeta]

Exactly, he didn't even tap it over Nightingale. Plus he was onside.

TRY!!

Where'd he tap it? Under him? Through him?

 

[Cletus]

Where'd he tap it? Under him? Through him?

About a metre the other side of him. It didn't go over him and Nightingale wasn't even contesting it.