What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Classy PNG players in the NRL and Super League.

jim_57

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
4,377
Would love to see PNG playing higher ranked teams more often. With a sound structure they have a much much higher ceiling than any other tier 2 nation, except France. PNG and France should be battling hard for that #4 ranking... currently at #15 and #6

I think there should be more reward for the better developed Nations. Giving France and PNG annual games against England and NZ for example would be a good start.
 

mikail-eagle

Bench
Messages
2,785
Am not sure what the squad sizes allowable for the world cup are but I think PNG will probably take 3 hookers for this World Cup.

My guess is Baptiste, Segeyaro and Puara Jnr.

However if they go for 4 than maybe Tommy Butterfield over Paul Aiton.
 

Chip Kick

Juniors
Messages
64
Am not sure what the squad sizes allowable for the world cup are but I think PNG will probably take 3 hookers for this World Cup.

My guess is Baptiste, Segeyaro and Puara Jnr.

However if they go for 4 than maybe Tommy Butterfield over Paul Aiton.

I don't know about Segeyaro playing hooker, given he's only played 8 games so far this year
Baptiste could be same as well.
Paul Aiton has been quiet the past couple of years but his form at Catalans can be telling factor
Tommy Butterfield was good in test match earlier this year....

I'll go with Baptiste, Puara and Buttefield
 

hutch

First Grade
Messages
6,810
I don't know about Segeyaro playing hooker, given he's only played 8 games so far this year
Baptiste could be same as well.
Paul Aiton has been quiet the past couple of years but his form at Catalans can be telling factor
Tommy Butterfield was good in test match earlier this year....

I'll go with Baptiste, Puara and Buttefield

Segeyaro is a much better player than those mentioned. He will be the starting hooker!
 

Chip Kick

Juniors
Messages
64
Segeyaro is a much better player than those mentioned. He will be the starting hooker!
I beg to differ, the recent match Segeyaro played in over the weekend against the Cowboys when coming off the bench was telling factor about how he controlled the pace of the ruck. Couple of darts out of dummy half by Chicko was all too predictable and he was trying too hard IMO.
Don't get me wrong, he's a great player, he's defensive play is still there, in making the hard tackles but I would go for Puara over him based on the fact that Puara is part of the spine of the current Kumuls.
 

mikail-eagle

Bench
Messages
2,785
http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2017/08/24/segeyaro-asks-png-forgive-and-forget

Cronulla hooker James Segeyaro admits he doesn't know how he will be received by Papua New Guinea fans during the upcoming Rugby League World Cup.

Even after being abused on social media, James Segeyaro is still hoping the people of Papua New Guinea open their hearts to him during this year's Rugby League World Cup.

Two years ago Segeyaro turned his back on the country of his birth, declaring he would never represent them again.

But he has done an about-face and put his hand up for the Kumuls for the end-of-year tournament which will be played in Australia, New Zealand and PNG.

There are no league fans more passionate than that of the Pacific nation - the only country in the world where the 13-man game is the national sport.

The Cronulla hooker's decision to sever ties with PNG before going back on his word has divided opinions and some angry fans expressed their disdain via social media.

"It's been a bit negative in the sense that people are telling me they don't need me," Segeyaro said.

"It is what it is but at the end of the day it is my choice and if they can look past the whole me turning my back on my country, it was my personal choice because of what the people did to my old man.

"It's not because I didn't like the country or anything like that."

Segeyaro relinquished his eligibility for PNG two years ago because he was disappointed with how his father Iffysoe, himself a Kumuls player, was treated by league officials.

The 26-year-old said he decided to return to the fold after the coach of Queensland Cup club PNG Hunters, Michael Marum, took over the national side.

"It was hilarious, reading the comments and the direct messages - it was hate mail more than anything. Everyone's got a right to their opinion," Segeyaro said.

He still doesn't know how he will be received during the Kumuls' three World Cup pool matches, all of which will be played in Port Moresby.

"You know what, it's my homeland," Segeyaro said.

"The people of Papua New Guinea are very opinionated because they love the sport, that's what's beautiful about it, they're passionate. They're very passionate about it, it's the No.1 sport in the country.

"I'm not too worried about it. It's a bit of mixed emotions at the moment, seeing what it's going to be like if I get picked and go over. I should be right."
 

Chip Kick

Juniors
Messages
64
Some "interesting" selections there hardly too surprising. Have to say I think PNG will do well, especially given 3 home games. If things go as expected it should be England V PNG in the quarters, bit of a banana skin game for England.
True
 
Top