Well the good games show he has the ability there. Bad games just mean he needs to work on his consistency.He’s playing much better tonight, but you can’t judge him off one good game, just as you shouldn’t judge him off one bad game.
But there’s enough there for me to think he can be a good quality NRL half. Maybe even more.
Including his games at 6 for us. He was pretty decent in about half of his games. And he's obviously still learning so for mine that's a pass mark.
If he's 50/50 after a season... yeah you probably need to question it. Depending how big the gap between good and bad is.