What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Graham injured

trev

Juniors
Messages
50
Just watching the City vs Country game...Graham went off the field injured. They're talking about a knee problem.
 

Raiding Dazz

Juniors
Messages
779
So who should they put in the side now.

I hope Howell isnt going to be center but it looks like it, they should give Campese a go in the centers and bring in Hinchcliffe as 5/8th with Sau on the bench
 

Freddo

Juniors
Messages
800
Hinchcliffe 5/8 UMMMM NO



Being Practical

It Will be Howell To the Centres

and Bring Milne on the wing


Or Bringing in Goodwin and slotting him in the centres
 

Raiding Dazz

Juniors
Messages
779
Hinchcliffe would make a good 5/8th as he does posses certain Ball skills in the dummy half area that shows he could be capable
 
Messages
4,007
What is it with some of you and playing people out of position, Howell has been given enough chances in the centres, leave him where he is, put campo to the centres if carney i right to go, if carney isnt right to go, bring in a specialist centre like brad cross or someone else.
 

aussies1st

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,154
I'd bring in Sau, Howell sucks in the centres and I'd rather not try another hooker at 5/8.
 

legend

Coach
Messages
15,150
I think we will see Withers to half, Hinchliffe to hooker, Dobson to five eighth and Campese into the centres.
 

nickraider

Juniors
Messages
738
Just heard on the news. This sux. As if we didn't have enough injuries!! I'd be putting Campo in the centres - he deserves it. There's still talk Carney might play, so he could slot straight back into 5/8. Don't want to see Howell in the centres.
 

dubby

Bench
Messages
3,005
Theres alway Cross who is a chance, and Campo who is my choice. I would say Howell would get a reprive unfortunately. We are a bit light on in the quality centre department until Chalk is fit.
 

Sydney_Raider

Juniors
Messages
527
Sounds like both Carney and Weyman are chances to play in this game. Campese should replace Graham if that is the case. Goodwin hasn't been named in PL and Sau can't even make the PL team so I doubt either of those two will come in to contention, about as much chance as Hichcliffe playing 5/8????. If Carney is out, then it is time for Milne or Cross to be given a shot.

If Carney and Weyman both play wouldn't be surprised to see Hinchliffe dropped off bench but at least we know Withers will have to play at his absolute best from now on to retain his spot.

Colin Best and David Howell can you please stay on your f___ing wings and not charge up in to thin air when defending!!!!
 

skeepe

Immortal
Messages
48,303
The Canberra Times has said that Marshall Chalk will come into the side for Graham.
 

julian87

Juniors
Messages
966
Awesome news. Chalk is the better replacement imo. Must mean Carney might not be fit still. If he is though, I'd say he might play off the bench.
 

skeepe

Immortal
Messages
48,303
Carney is a 50/50 chance at best. Henry has said there is no way he will risk Carney unless he's absolutely 100%... and that Campese's good form has given him this luxury.
 

Macko8

Juniors
Messages
1,369
Thats weird.
I thought chalk was out until round 9.

Bring in brad cross, he was named in the trials pre season give him a go.

If carneys fit though im all for moving campese into the centres.
 

thickos

First Grade
Messages
7,086
Terrible game last night, and terrible result for us. Feel really sorry for Phil who I'm sure was excited about making his rep debut.
 

aussies1st

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,154
WTF 10 weeks :(

'Not out of our depth': Henry backs his makeshift side
David Jean

Canberra Raiders coach Neil Henry is confident his makeshift backline can outpoint a stingy Manly outfit tomorrow despite losing another key player to injury.

Scans yesterday revealed centre Phil Graham would be sidelined for up to 10 weeks with a ruptured medial ligament, meaning the Raiders will be without their most dangerous broken-play runner for the Canberra Stadium clash.

The 25-year-old will wear a knee brace for the next month and faces a further six weeks recovery time after that.

Graham said he was yet to come to terms with the devastating blow, which came just 30 minutes into his representative debut for Country on Thursday.

"I wasn't expecting to be like this after such a big game for my career," Graham said.

"I was expecting to still be on a high going into the Raiders game."

Graham vowed to return to the representative scene despite the massive setback.

"It gives you the desire to get better and try to go further with your career," he said.

"I've got a taste of it and seen how good it is. I'm going to try to put a bit more weight on and come back fitter and stronger than I have been in the last few weeks."

The Raiders are also likely to be without five-eighth Todd Carney - who is still battling a thigh injury - while first-choice winger Brett Kelly's injured ankle will keep him out for at least another four weeks.

Henry yesterday drafted utility Marshall Chalk into his squad in place of Graham. Terry Campese is likely to hang on to the No6 jersey in the absence of Carney.

The Sea Eagles are the equal-best defensive unit in the competition, having conceded only 82 points in seven games this season.

They kept the Raiders to just one try in round one while piling on six of their own.

Henry said it would be difficult to create point-scoring opportunities without Graham and Carney, but he backed their replacements to do the job.

"Phil is a big loss for us because he is one of our real attackers," Henry said.

"He can create something from nothing and he's a dangerous carrier of the ball.

"He's got a knack of popping up at times to get tries or to create opportunities so that part of his game will be missed.

"We've got a fair list of guys that have been injured or are injured so it is testing our depth, but the way the guys stepped up last week showed our depth is potentially quite good."

Chalk returns five weeks after breaking six ribs against Newcastle. He has played fullback, centre and in the backrow for the Raiders this year.

Henry said Chalk would directly oppose dangerous Manly ballrunner Steve Bell.


"He did all the full contact stuff this week and he's quite keen to get back into it," he said.

"He runs a good hard line and he's a bit more direct than Phil.

"He's solid there and he's a solid defender."

Henry will give Carney until today to prove his fitness after he missed last week's win over Penrith with a torn quad. Carney yesterday completed straight running drills, but he is yet to test his thigh with lateral movement and kicking.

"Unless he can convince me he's really right to go I just don't want to risk him," Henry said.

The Raiders' SG Ball team will play Parramatta for a place in next week's grand final at Western Weekender Stadium this afternoon.

The under-18s team won through to the semi-final with a 22-18 win over Illawarra in the qualifying final last week.

James Woolford scored two tries, with Steve Naughton and Jarrad Kennedy also crossing the tryline. Jarrod Croker kicked three goals.
 

Sydney_Raider

Juniors
Messages
527
Don't know if Phil has been in such great form so providing Marshall Chalk can aim up remain confident of a good showing tomorrow. Would of preferred Milne or Cross only because they have been playing week to week, albeit in PL. Maybe there are salary cap concerns (PL to NRL) to be considered in the selection process, particularly at this relatively early stage of the year.

A win tomorrow followed by Souths next week (not impressive last night) and then a bye combined with players coming back (Bickerstaff????) gives us an opportunity to be well placed come round 11 and beyond.
 

Latest posts

Top